Recalling J. S. Mill’s consciousness of the different goals of human life, the modern debate about pluralism has gathered momentum in liberal philosophy largely as a consequence of the intellectual historian and political theorist Isaiah Berlin. In his seminal essay, “Two Concepts of Liberty,” Berlin prompted thought about the potential overlap between the plurality of human values and the liberal tradition. In the years following, a vigorous debate with numerous strands has arisen around a synthesis of these concepts, in the form of the theory of “liberal pluralism.” A key area of controversy is whether the acceptance of pluralism supports a “perfectionist” theory of the state; or whether, by contrast, it generates a neutral liberalism which abstains from difficult questions about the highest good. A related question is whether the concepts of liberal pluralism fit together at all. Some of Berlin’s interpreters such as John Gray suggest that value pluralism does not privilege liberalism, and that the relationship between these ideas is historically contingent. Liberal pluralists such as George Crowder disagree. From their perspective, liberals defend first-order political values such as fairness or personal autonomy, to protect the various conceptions of the good life citizens personally endorse. Moreover, the most recent decades have seen a burgeoning examination by analytical political theorists of the implications of liberal pluralism for state neutrality and the protection of minority cultural or religious rights. While the equally vast literature on toleration, political liberalism, and the politics of recognition is not considered in depth in this bibliography, unless it explicitly invokes the theory of liberal pluralism, key works which apply liberal pluralism to minority cultural, religious, and ethnic identities are represented in the later sections. Therefore, this article overall reflects different dimensions of debate on a complex and much debated contemporary theory. Following the overview of foundational works, and background readings on the relationship between liberalism and the politics of difference and identity, the next substantive section covers critical studies of Berlin’s liberal pluralism. This is then followed by a section addressing the conceptual relationship between value pluralism and liberalism generally, before moving on to consider more specific works addressing the relation between liberal pluralism and the concept of neutrality. The final sections consider critical literature applying liberal pluralism to conditions of ethnic, sub-national, cultural, and religious diversity. This is crucial, because the defense of liberal pluralist theories are clearly designed to be applied to such real-world situations of diversity.
The central works in liberal pluralism in this section are all monographs. Edited collections on this subject have been integrated into the more specialized sections of the bibliography (see The Relationship between Liberalism and Value Pluralism, Liberal Pluralism, Nation, and Culture, and Liberal Pluralism and Religion). Among the works presently considered are the crucial, and contrasting, responses to pluralism offered in the 1980s by Rawls 1993, a defender of liberal neutrality, and Raz 1986, a key defender of a perfectionist liberal state. While these works do not typically invoke the term “liberal pluralist,” their thought remains foundational to the debate. Responding more directly to Berlin’s pioneering essay (Berlin 1969), the early years of the millennium witnessed a set of original and insightful monographs developing theories of liberal pluralism specifically. Bellamy 2002 directs attention to the democratic negotiation of difference and away from the internal debate about liberal values. Galston 2002, in contrast, argues for a “minimal perfectionist” internal reading of the liberal values needed to support pluralism, through which he highlights the concept of “expressive liberty.” Finally, in apparent contrast to Bellamy but like Galston, Flathman 2005 emphasizes the internal tension between liberal values, including that between commitments to unity and diversity.
Bellamy, Richard. Liberalism and Pluralism: Towards a Politics of Compromise. London: Routledge, 2002.
This monograph is a careful, clearly written, detailed application of liberal pluralism to a range of issues, mostly affecting liberal democracies in Europe, including the citizens’ charter, constitutional reform, and the Rushdie Affair. The monograph provides one of the most insightful conceptual discussions of liberal pluralism. The innovative argument is that a pluralist liberalism must be more than a “meta-political” theory about liberal values, and more a democratic “politics of compromise.”
Berlin, Isaiah. “Two Concepts of Liberty.” In Four Essays on Liberty. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1969
Acclaimed for his seminal defense of the distinction between forms of liberty, Berlin’s essay is famous for its defense of negative liberalism as the framework to recognize the plurality of human values. Partly owing to Berlin’s allusive style of argument and to the tensions within it, this text provides the most thought-provoking starting-point for examining the modern idea of liberal pluralism, for both undergraduates and more advanced researchers alike.
Flathman, R. E. Pluralism and Liberal Democracy. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2005.
Appealing to advanced scholars, Flathman’s perspective is more specialized than more standard liberal texts. It draws from more eclectic theories than liberals generally tend to do. Flathman reaches toward the insights of William James, Hannah Arendt, Stuart Hampshire, and Michael Oakeshott. By considering, for instance, Arendt’s The Origins of Totalitarianism, Flathman contends that classical liberalism is challenged by the recent emergence of more demanding forms of pluralism, such as separatist and secessionist movements.
Galston, William. Liberal Pluralism: The Implications of Value Pluralism for Political Theory and Practice. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2002.
Against criticisms of theorists such as John Gray (see Gray 1988, cited under The Relationship between Liberalism and Value Pluralism), Galston takes value pluralism to support a “minimal perfectionist” politics based on the value of expressive liberty. Galston also argues against “monist” theories, which rank all human goods hierarchically and presuppose a single, most rational way to live. As one of the most insightful readers of Berlin 1969, Galston’s perspective would appeal to advanced researchers and undergraduates alike.
Larmore, Charles. Patterns of Moral Complexity. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1987.
Larmore’s defense of liberal neutrality assists the advanced student or researcher to understand liberalism’s reactions to the fact of pluralism. Larmore disagrees with Rawls, in claiming that the core issue for liberalism is not the fact of pluralism (which is a meta-ethical doctrine), but the fact of reasonable disagreement. Larmore’s argument is pursued by Mendus 2014 (see The Relationship between Liberalism and Value Pluralism), encouraging further thought about the differences between Rawls and Larmore’s liberalisms.
Rawls, John. Political Liberalism. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1993.
In contrast with Raz, Rawls provides what has been widely viewed as one of the most significant justifications within contemporary political philosophy for a neutralist, anti-perfectionist liberal politics. This politics accommodates human beings’ reasonable disagreements about their conception of the good within the nation-state. This text is foundational for the study of modern liberalism generally. It is essential reading for any researchers keen to understand a liberal response to diversity and pluralism, from the perspective of a modern social contract theory.
Raz, Joseph. The Morality of Freedom. Oxford: Clarendon, 1986.
Raz provides a seminal defense of a liberal-perfectionist accommodation of pluralism on the basis of explicitly accepting value pluralism. More specifically, Raz offers a political theory which politically defends autonomy as a higher good. It is through this good that human beings choose between different, equally valuable modes of living. If, as Raz argues, human ends are incommensurable and potentially conflicting, the important issue is the human freedom to choose between them.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login.
How to Subscribe
Oxford Bibliographies Online is available by subscription and perpetual access to institutions. For more information or to contact an Oxford Sales Representative click here.
Purchase an Ebook Version of This Article
Ebooks of the Oxford Bibliographies Online subject articles are available in North America via a number of retailers including Amazon, vitalsource, and more. Simply search on their sites for Oxford Bibliographies Online Research Guides and your desired subject article.
If you would like to purchase an eBook article and live outside North America please email firstname.lastname@example.org to express your interest.
- Advanced Democracies, Electoral System Reform in
- Advanced Democracies, Public Opinion and Public Policy in
- Advertising and Election Campaigns in the United States
- Africa, Comparative Politics of
- American Indian Politics
- Arab-Israel Conflict, The
- Arendt, Hannah
- Aristotle's Political Thought
- Australia and New Zealand, Comparative Politics of
- Authoritarianism in Russia
- Bicameralism in Stable Democracies
- Biopolitics and State Regulation of Human Life
- Brazilian Political Development
- Business-State Relations in Europe
- Campaign Finance in the Era of Super-PACS
- Canadian Foreign Policy
- Candidate Emergence and Recruitment
- Channels of Electoral Representation in Advanced Industria...
- China's One-Child Policy
- China-Taiwan Relations
- Chinese Communist Party
- Chinese Economic Policy
- Chinese Nationalism
- Civil Society in South Asia
- Civil War in Sub-Saharan Africa
- Civil-Military Relations in Asia
- Civil-Military Relations in Latin America
- Class in American Politics
- Comparative Capitalism Theory
- Comparative Industrial Relations in Europe
- Comparative Politics of Angola, Mozambique, and Guinea-Bis...
- Comparative Politics of Chile and Uruguay
- Comparative Politics of Federalism
- Comparative Politics of the Middle East and North Africa
- Congress, Defense, and Foreign Policy
- Congressional Reassertion of Authority
- Conservative Litigation Strategies and Groups in US Judici...
- Corruption in China
- Cosmopolitan Political Thought
- Crisis of European Integration in Historical Perspective, ...
- Critical Theory and the Frankfurt School
- Cuban Political Development
- Cycles of Protest
- Democracy and Authoritarianism in Sub-Saharan Africa
- Democracy and Dictatorship in Central Asia
- Democracy in Latin America
- Democratic Citizenship
- Democratic Consolidation
- Democratic Peace Theory
- Democratic Theory
- Democratization in Africa
- Democratization in Central America
- Democratization in Mexico
- Development of Survey Research
- Direct Democracy in the United States
- East Africa, Politics of
- Economic Voting
- Election Forecasting
- Election Laws in Democracies
- Electoral and Party System Development in Sub-Saharan Afri...
- Electoral Change in Latin America
- Emotion and Racial Attitudes in Contemporary American Poli...
- Environmental Governance
- Environmental Politics among Advanced Industrial Democraci...
- Ethnic Diasporas and US Foreign Policy
- Ethnic Politics
- Eurasia, Comparative Politics of
- European Social Democracy
- European Union, Politics of the
- Failed and Weak States in Theory and Practice
- Far-Right Parties in Europe
- Federalism in the United States
- Field Experiments
- Filibuster, The
- Gender and Electoral Politics in the United States
- Gender and International Relations
- Gender, Behavior, and Representation
- Global Inequality
- Globalization and the Welfare State
- Globalization, Health Crises, and Health Care
- Governance in Africa
- Governmental Responses to Political Corruption
- Gridlock and Divided Government in the U.S.
- Historiography of Twentieth-Century American Conservatism,...
- Hobbes’s Political Thought
- Hume’s Political Thought
- Hybrid Regimes
- Identity and Political Behavior
- Immigrant Incorporation in Canada
- Immigrant Incorporation in Western Europe
- Immigration and International Relations
- Immigration Politics and Policy in the United States
- Impact of Campaign Contributions on Congressional Behavior...
- Implicit Attitudes in Public Opinion
- Income Dynamics and Politics in North America and Europe
- Income Inequality and Advanced Democracies
- Income Inequality in the United States, The Politics of
- Indian Democracy
- Indigenous Rights and Governance in Canada, Australia, and...
- Informal Practices of Accountability in Urban Africa
- Institutional Change in Advanced Democracies
- Intellectual Property in International Relations
- Interest Groups and Inequality in the United States
- Interest Groups in American Politics
- International Conflict Management
- International Criminal Justice
- International Law
- International NGOs
- International Political Economy of Illegal Drugs
- Internet and Politics, The
- Iran, Political Development of
- Israeli Politics
- Judicial Supremacy and National Judicial Review
- Judiciaries and Politics in East Asia
- Kant's Political Thought
- Labor Politics in East Asia
- Land Reform in Latin America
- Latin America, Democratic Transitions in
- Latin America, Environmental Policy and Politics in
- Latin America, Guerrilla Insurgencies in
- Latin America, Social Movements in
- Legal Mobilization
- LGBT Politics in the United States
- Liberal Pluralism
- Local Governments in the United States
- Machiavelli’s Political Thought
- Marx's Political Thought
- Mass Incarceration and US Politics
- Mechanisms of Representation
- Media Effects in Politics
- Media Politics in South Asia
- Minority Political Engagement and Representation in the Un...
- Modern Dynastic Rule
- Modern Elections and Voting Behavior in Europe
- National Interbranch Politics in the United States
- NATO, Politics of
- Negative Campaigning
- Neoclassical Realism
- New Institutionalism Revisited, The
- North America, Comparative Politics of
- Oil, Politics of
- Origins and Impact of Proportional Representation, The
- Outcomes of Social Movements and Protest Activities
- Partisan and Nonpartisan Theories of Organization in the U...
- Partisan Polarization in the US Congress
- Partisan Polarization in the US Electorate
- Party Networks
- Peace Operations
- Personality and Politics
- Plato's Political Thought
- Policy Responsiveness to Public Opinion
- Political Economy of Financial Regulation in Advanced Ind...
- Political Economy of Taxation, The
- Political Geography in American Politics
- Political Obligation
- Political Parties and Electoral Politics of Japan
- Political Thought, Hegel's
- Political Thought of the American Founders, The
- Politics and Policy in Contemporary Argentina
- Politics of Anti-Americanism
- Politics of Class Formation
- Politics of Disaster Prevention and Management
- Politics of Financial Crises
- Politics of Foreign Direct Investment in South Asia
- Politics of Higher Education in the U.S.
- Politics of Internal Conquest in the United States and Can...
- Politics of Japan
- Politics of Natural Disasters, The
- Politics of North Korea
- Politics of Science and Technology
- Politics of South Africa
- Politics of Southern Africa
- Postcolonialism and International Relations
- Post-Communist Democratization
- Preferential Trade Agreements, Politics of
- Presidential Persuasion and Public Opinion
- Presidential Primaries and Caucuses
- Private Governance
- Public Opinion in Advanced Industrial Democracies
- Public Opinion in New Democracies and Developing Nations
- Public Presidency, US Elections, and the Permanent Campaig...
- Qualitative Methods, The Renewal of
- Race in American Political Thought
- Racial and Ethnic Descriptive Representation in the United...
- Regime Transitions and Variation in Post-Communist Europe
- Regional Integration in Latin America
- Regional Security
- Regulating Food Production
- Religion in American Political Thought
- Religion in Contemporary Political Thought
- Religion, Politics, and Civic Engagement in the United Sta...
- Rousseau's Political Thought
- Rule of Law
- Russia and the West
- Science and Democracy
- Social Policy and Immigrant Integration
- South Korea, Politics of
- Spectacle, The
- State Building in Sub-Saharan Africa
- State Formation
- State, The Nature of the
- Supreme Court of the United States, The
- Systemic Theories of International Politics
- Taiwan, Politics of
- Tea Party, The
- The New Right in American Political Thought
- Transitional Justice
- Transnational Private Regulation
- Turkey, Political Development of
- US Military Bases Abroad
- US Presidency, The
- Voter Turnout
- Welfare State Development
- Welfare State Development in Latin America
- Welfare State Development in Western Europe
- West Africa, Politics of
- Worker Politics in China
- Youth and Generational Differences in US Politics