Pastorals
- LAST REVIEWED: 11 May 2023
- LAST MODIFIED: 13 September 2010
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780195393361-0089
- LAST REVIEWED: 11 May 2023
- LAST MODIFIED: 13 September 2010
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780195393361-0089
Introduction
The modern study of the Pastoral Epistles (1–2 Timothy, Titus) began in the first decade of the 19th century when German scholars first questioned Paul’s authorship of 1 Timothy, and Friedrich Schleiermacher’s “critical open letter” to J. C. Gass, written in 1807 on 1 Timothy, proposed that its author based his work on 2 Timothy and Titus. With Johann Gottfried Eichhorn’s Introduction to the New Testament, published in 1810 to 1827, critical German scholarship began to question the authenticity of the three epistles. Ferdinand Christian Baur’s Die sogenannten Pastoralbriefe des Apostels Paulus, of 1835, was the first commentary that used the hypothesis as the basis for a thorough study of the texts. Although Edward Evanson questioned the authenticity of Titus in 1805, the notion that the Pastorals were not written by Paul was largely confined to German scholarship. The debate about the authenticity of the Pastorals dominated scholarship on these letters. Epistles became a matter of scholarly consensus. Some conservative authors continued to maintain the Pauline authorship of the texts, while other scholars expressed hesitancy about the consensus as it applied to 2 Timothy. In recent years several scholars have called for an interpretation of the Pastorals in terms of their individuality, rather than as a unit.
History of Interpretation
As the history of the interpretation of the Pastorals indicates, the issue of the authorship of the Pastorals has dominated scholarly investigation of these texts during the 19th and 20th centuries (Patsch 1999) and the concomitant issues of interpretation that the views on authorship entail. The oldest reference to the Pastorals appears in the writing of Polycarp of Smyrna (Berding 1999). Twomey 2009 provides a selection of interpretations over the course of the centuries. Schenk 1988, Harding 2001, and Donfried 2008 survey important issues that have arisen in recent study of the Pastorals. Richards 2002 and Gourges 2009 plead for the study of each of the Pastorals in terms of their individuality, rather than as a unit.
Berding, Kenneth. “Polycarp of Smyrna’s View of the Authorship of 1 and 2 Timothy.” Vigiliae Christianae 53 (1999): 349–360.
Polycarp is the earliest witness to the belief that the apostle Paul is the author of these epistles.
Donfried, Karl Paul. “Rethinking Scholarly Approaches to 1 Timothy.” In 1 Timothy Reconsidered. Edited by Karl Paul Donfried, 153–182. Louvain, Belgium: Peeters, 2008.
Surveys approaches to the relationship between 1 Timothy and the authentic Paul, as well as some ethical issues.
Gourgues, Michel. “Étude critique: La recherche sur les pastorales à un tournant?” Science et Esprit 61 (2009): 73–86.
A critical overview of recent commentaries: Towner 2006, Fiore 2007 (cited under Recent Commentaries), and Aageson 2008 (cited under Paul in the Pastorals).
Harding, Mark. What Are They Saying about the Pastoral Epistles? New York: Paulist Press, 2001.
This is a concise historical study of the authorship of the Pastorals, their social and literary settings, and their relationship with Pauline theology and classic rhetoric.
Patsch, Hermann. “The Fear of Deutero-Paulinism: The Reception of Friedrich Schleiermacher’s ‘Critical Open Letter’ Concerning 1 Timothy in the First Quinquenium.” Journal of Higher Criticism 6 (1999): 3–31.
Nineteenth-century scholars found it difficult to evaluate 1 Timothy other than using a simple perspective of “authentic” versus “inauthentic.”
Richards, William A. Difference and Distance in Post-Pauline Christianity: An Epistolary Analysis of the Pastorals. Studies in Biblical Literature 44. New York: Peter Lang, 2002.
The three Pastoral Epistles are real letters, but a detailed analysis of grammatical features shows that they were not written by the same person.
Schenk, Wolfgang. “Die Briefe an Timotheus I und II und an Titus (Pastoralbriefe) in der neueren Forschung (1945–1985).” In Aufstieg und Niedergang der römischen Welt: Geschichte und Kultur Roms im Spiegel der neueren Forschung. Vol. 25, Part 6. Edited by Hildegard Temporini and Wolfgang Haase, 3404–3438. Berlin and New York: de Gruyter, 1988.
The standard review of research on the Pastorals from 1945 to 1985.
Twomey, Jay. The Pastoral Epistles through the Centuries. Blackwell Bible Commentaries. Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell, 2009.
A compendium of interpretations of the text from ancient times to the present.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login.
How to Subscribe
Oxford Bibliographies Online is available by subscription and perpetual access to institutions. For more information or to contact an Oxford Sales Representative click here.
Article
- Archaeology and Material Culture of Nabataea and the Nabat...
- Aaron
- Acts of Peter
- Acts of the Apostles
- Adam and Eve
- Aelia Capitolina
- Afterlife and Immortality
- Agriculture
- Alexander the Great
- Alexandria
- Altered States of Consciousness in the Bible
- Ancient Christianity, Churches in
- Ancient Israel, Schools in
- Ancient Medicine
- Ancient Mesopotamia, Schools in
- Ancient Near Eastern Law
- Angels
- Anti-Semitism and the New Testament
- Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
- Apocryphal Acts
- Apostolic Fathers
- Aram
- Archaeology and Material Culture of Ammon and the Ammonite...
- Archaeology and Material Culture of Aram and the Arameans
- Archaeology and Material Culture of Judah and the Judeans ...
- Archaeology and Material Culture of Moab and the Moabites
- Archaeology and Material Culture of Phoenicia and the Phoe...
- Archaeology and Material Culture of the Kingdom of Israel ...
- Archaeology, Greco-Roman
- Art, Early Christian
- Asceticism
- Astrology and Astronomy
- Athaliah
- Atonement
- Augustus
- Babylon
- Baptism
- Barnabas, Epistle of
- Benefaction/Patronage
- Bible and Visual Art
- Biblical Criticism
- Biblical Studies, Cognitive Science Approaches in
- Caesarea Maritima
- Canaanites
- Canon, Biblical
- Ceramics
- Cherubim
- Child Metaphors in the New Testament
- Children in the Hebrew Bible
- Children in the New Testament World
- Christian Apocrypha
- Christology
- Chronicles, First and Second
- Cities of Refuge
- Clement, First
- Clement of Alexandria
- Clement, Second
- Clothing
- Colossians
- Conversation Analysis
- Conversion
- Corinthians, Second
- Cosmology, Near East
- Covenant
- Covenant, Ark of the
- Crucifixion
- Cyrus
- Daniel
- Daniel, Additions to
- David
- Death and Burial
- Deborah
- Demons
- Deuteronomistic History
- Deuteronomy
- Diaspora in the New Testament
- Didache
- Digital Humanities and the Bible
- Divination and Omens
- Domestic Architecture, Ancient Israel
- Early Christianity
- Ecclesiastes/Qohelet
- Economics and Biblical Studies
- Edom
- Education, Greco-Roman
- Education in the Hebrew Bible
- Egyptian Book of the Dead
- Election in the Bible
- Elijah
- Elisha
- Enoch
- Ephesians
- Epistles, Catholic
- Epistolography (Ancient Letters)
- Esther and Additions to Esther
- Ethics
- Evil Eye
- Exodus, Book of
- Exorcism
- Ezekiel
- Ezra-Nehemiah
- Faith in the New Testament
- Feminist Scholarship on the Old Testament
- Flora and Fauna of the Hebrew Bible
- Food and Food Production
- Friendship, Kinship and Enmity
- Funerary Rites and Practices, Greco-Roman
- Galatians
- Galilee
- Genesis, Book of
- Gentiles
- Gnosticism
- God, Ancient Israel
- God, Greco-Roman
- God, Son of
- Gospels
- Gospels, Apocryphal
- Great, Herod the
- Greco-Roman World, Associations in the
- Greek Language
- Hagar
- Heaven
- Hebrew Bible, Biblical Law in the
- Hebrew Language
- Hebrews
- Hell
- Hellenistic and Roman Egypt
- Hermas, Shepherd of
- Historiography, Greco-Roman
- History of Ancient Israelite Religion
- Hittites
- Holy Spirit
- Honor and Shame
- Hosea, Book of
- Idol/Idolatry (HB/OT)
- Idol/Idolatry (New Testament)
- Imperial Cult and Early Christianity
- Infancy Gospel of Thomas
- Interpretation and Hermeneutics
- Intertextuality in the New Testament
- Isaiah
- Israel, History of
- James
- Jeremiah
- Jeroboam
- Jerusalem
- Jesus of Nazareth
- Jewish Christianity
- Jewish Festivals
- Jezebel
- Job
- Joel, Book of
- John, Gospel of
- John the Baptist
- Joshua
- Jubilees, Book of
- Judaism, Hellenistic
- Judaism, Rabbinic
- Judaism, Second Temple
- Judas, Gospel of
- Jude, Epistle of
- Judges, Book of
- Judith, Book of
- Kings, First and Second
- Kingship
- Lamentations
- Letters, Johannine
- Letters, Pauline
- Levi/Levittes
- Levirate Obligation in the Hebrew Bible
- Levitical Cities
- Leviticus
- LGBTIQ Hermeneutics
- Literacy, New Testament
- Literature, Apocalyptic
- Lord’s Prayer
- Luke, Gospel of
- Maccabean Revolt
- Maccabees, First–Fourth
- Man, Son of
- Manasseh, King of Judah
- Manasseh, Tribe/Territory
- Mark, Gospel of
- Martyrdom
- Mary
- Matthew, Gospel of
- Medieval Biblical Interpretation (Jewish)
- Mesopotamian Mythology and Genesis 1-11
- Messianism
- Midian
- Midrash and Aggadah
- Minoritized Criticism of the New Testament
- Miracle Stories
- Modern Bible Translations
- Moses
- Music
- Mysticism in Ancient Judaism and Early Christianity
- Myth in the Hebrew Bible
- Nahum, Book of
- Names of God in the Hebrew Bible
- New Testament and Early Christianity, Women, Gender, and S...
- New Testament, Feminist Scholarship on the
- New Testament, Men and Masculinity in the
- New Testament, Rhetoric of the
- New Testament, Social Sciences and the
- New Testament Studies, Emerging Approaches in
- New Testament, Textual Criticism of the
- New Testament Views of Torah
- Numbers, Book of
- Nuzi (Nuzi Tablets)
- Old Testament, Biblical Theology in the
- Old Testament, Social Sciences and the
- Orality and Literacy
- Parables
- Paraenesis
- Passion Narratives
- Pastorals
- Paul
- Pauline Chronology
- Paul's Opponents
- Pentateuch
- Performance Criticism
- Period, The "Persian"
- Peter
- Philemon
- Philippians
- Philistines
- Philo of Alexandria
- Piety/Godliness in Early Christianity and the Roman World
- Poetry, Hebrew
- Pontius Pilate
- Priestly/Holiness Codes
- Priest/Priesthood
- Prophets
- Proverbs
- Psalms
- Pseudepigraphy, Early Christian
- Pseudo-Clementines
- Q
- Qumran/Dead Sea Scrolls
- Race, Ethnicity and the Gospels
- Revelation (Apocalypse)
- Romans
- Ruth
- Sacrifice
- Samaria/Samaritans
- Samuel, First and Second
- Satan
- Scriptures
- Second Baruch
- Sects, Jewish
- Septuagint
- Sermon on the Mount
- Sexual Violence and the Hebrew Bible
- Sin (Hebrew Bible/Old Testament)
- Sirach
- Slavery
- Sojourner
- Solomon
- Solomon, Wisdom of
- Song of Songs
- Succession Narrative
- Synagogue
- Synoptic Problem
- Tales, Court
- Talmud
- Targum
- Temples and Sanctuaries
- Temples, Near Eastern
- Ten Commandments
- The Bible and the American Civil War
- The Bible in China
- the Hebrew Bible, Ancient Egypt and
- The New Testament and Creation Care
- Thessalonians
- Thomas, Gospel of
- Tobit
- Trauma and the Bible, Hermeneutics of
- Twelve Prophets, Book of the
- Ugarit
- Virtues and Vices: New Testament Ethical Exhortation in I...
- War, New Testament
- Wisdom
- Women, Gender, and Sexuality in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testa...
- Worship in the New Testament and Earliest Christianity
- Worship, Old Testament
- Zadok
- Zechariah
- Zoology (Animals in the New Testament)