Structural Realism
- LAST REVIEWED: 24 July 2018
- LAST MODIFIED: 26 August 2013
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780195396577-0154
- LAST REVIEWED: 24 July 2018
- LAST MODIFIED: 26 August 2013
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780195396577-0154
Introduction
There is a long-standing dispute about whether those parts of scientific theories that seem to describe an unobservable realm of objects and properties that cause the phenomena that are observed and measured in experiments should be taken to be straightforward, literally true descriptions, as realists would have it, or whether they should be reinterpreted or treated with skepticism, as different forms of anti-realism suggest. Structural realism was reintroduced into philosophy of science by John Worrall’s article (Worrall 1989, cited under Introductory Works) in which he proposed it as a position that could take account of the strongest arguments for both realism and anti-realism. The former is the no-miracles argument, and the latter are various arguments from radical theory change in the history of science, often known collectively as the pessimistic meta-induction, most associated with the work of Larry Laudan. Laudan argued against scientific realism, citing a long list of theories he claimed could not be regarded as approximately true, despite their empirical success. According to him, theoretical terms such as “ether” and “caloric” do not refer to anything in the world, despite being central in empirically strong theories. Realists had sought to use a causal theory of reference to argue that such terms do refer after all. But Worrall argued that this is not plausible and that realists should conclude instead that our best scientific theories describe the structure of the world but not its nature. What exactly he meant by that remains the subject of intense debate. Ladyman introduced a distinction between two ways of reading it, namely an epistemological one and a metaphysical or ontic one, and there are now two distinct traditions in the literature about structural realism, discussing the epistemic and ontic version, respectively. The debate about structural realism is made more complex by the fact that Worrall claims that his position is really that advocated by Henri Poincaré and that he also suggested a connection with the Ramsey-sentence approach to capturing the cognitive content of theoretical terms. Poincaré was a neo-Kantian, and the Ramsey-sentence approach is associated with the work on scientific representation by logical empiricists such as Carnap. Meanwhile, Ladyman introduced issues about identity and individuality in contemporary physics into the discussion.
Introductory Works
Laudan 1981 is a classical source of the so-called no-miracles argument against scientific realism. Hardin and Rosenberg 1982 is a reply to Laudan 1981, deploying a causal theory of reference to argue that the author Laudan was wrong to regard certain examples of abandoned theoretical terms as nonreferring by the lights of our best scientific theories. Psillos 1999 modifies the account and offers the author’s own account of scientific realism against theory change. Psillos 1999 is criticized in Stanford 2003a and Stanford 2003b. Worrall 1989 argues that standard scientific realism must indeed be abandoned and replaced by structural realism. Ladyman 1998 seeks to clarify what structural realism is, while Redhead 1995 also defends structural realism in the context of a commentary on various issues in the philosophy of physics.
Hardin, Clyde L., and Alexander Rosenberg. “In Defense of Convergent Realism.” Philosophy of Science 49.4 (1982): 604–615.
DOI: 10.1086/289080
The authors argue that theoretical terms that have been abandoned by our best current science can be interpreted as referring to whatever we now regard as playing the relevant causal role. Available online for purchase or by subscription.
Ladyman, James. “What is Structural Realism?” Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, Part A 29.3 (1998): 409–424.
DOI: 10.1016/S0039-3681(98)80129-5
This article introduces the distinction between epistemic and ontic structural realism, argues against the former, especially the version that uses Ramsey sentences, and advocates the latter on the basis of considerations deriving from the hole argument in general relativity and the status of particles in quantum physics. Available online for purchase or by subscription.
Laudan, Larry. “A Confutation of Convergent Realism.” Philosophy of Science 481 (1981): 19–49.
DOI: 10.1086/288975
This is a very extensively discussed critique of scientific realism that features a long list of theories that were allegedly empirically successful and yet are also nonreferring and not approximately true. Available online for purchase or by subscription.
Psillos, Stathis. Scientific Realism: How Science Tracks Truth. London: Routledge, 1999.
This is a comprehensive account of the recent history of scientific realism and anti-realism and the relevant arguments. The author develops a strategy for responding to arguments from theory change that tackles the problematic cases of the ether theory of light and the caloric theory of heat in detail.
Redhead, Michael. From Physics to Metaphysics. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1995.
In this book the author defends a version of structural realism in light of careful consideration of contemporary physics.
Stanford, P. Kyle. “No Refuge for Realism: Selective Confirmation and the History of Science.” In Special Issue: Proceedings of the 2002 Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association: Part I: Contributed Papers. Edited by Sandra D. Mitchell. Philosophy of Science 70.5 (2003a): 913–925.
DOI: 10.1086/377377
This article challenges the strategy for defending realism developed by Philip Kitcher and also employed by Stathis Psillos, which is based on isolating those parts of theories that are responsible for their empirical success. Available online for purchase or by subscription.
Stanford, P. Kyle. “Pyrrhic Victories for Scientific Realism.” Journal of Philosophy 100.11 (2003b): 553–572.
This is a critique of Psillos’s aforementioned case studies and the conclusions he draws about them. Available online for purchase or by subscription.
Worrall, John. “Structural Realism: The Best of Both Worlds?” Dialectica 43.1–2 (1989): 99–124.
DOI: 10.1111/j.1746-8361.1989.tb00933.x
This article reviews the arguments for and against scientific realism, criticizing Hardin and Rosenberg’s response to Laudan 1981 and proposing structural realism as “the best of both worlds.” Available online for purchase or by subscription.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login.
How to Subscribe
Oxford Bibliographies Online is available by subscription and perpetual access to institutions. For more information or to contact an Oxford Sales Representative click here.
Article
- A Priori Knowledge
- Abduction and Explanatory Reasoning
- Ability
- Abortion
- Abstract Objects
- Action
- Addams, Jane
- Adorno, Theodor
- Aesthetic Hedonism
- Aesthetics, Analytic Approaches to
- Aesthetics, Continental
- Aesthetics, Environmental
- Aesthetics, History of
- African Philosophy, Contemporary
- Alexander, Samuel
- Analytic/Synthetic Distinction
- Anarchism, Philosophical
- Animal Rights
- Anscombe, G. E. M.
- Anthropic Principle, The
- Applied Ethics
- Aquinas, Thomas
- Argument Mapping
- Art and Emotion
- Art and Knowledge
- Art and Morality
- Artifacts
- Assertion
- Astell, Mary
- Atheism
- Augustine
- Aurelius, Marcus
- Austin, J. L.
- Autonomy
- Bacon, Francis
- Bayesianism
- Beauty
- Belief
- Bergson, Henri
- Berkeley, George
- Biology, Philosophy of
- Bolzano, Bernard
- Boredom, Philosophy of
- British Idealism
- Buber, Martin
- Buddhist Philosophy
- Burge, Tyler
- Business Ethics
- Camus, Albert
- Canterbury, Anselm of
- Carnap, Rudolf
- Causation
- Cavendish, Margaret
- Certainty
- Chemistry, Philosophy of
- Childhood, Philosophy of
- Chinese Philosophy
- Cognitive Ability
- Cognitive Phenomenology
- Cognitive Science, Philosophy of
- Coherentism
- Color
- Communitarianism
- Computational Science
- Computer Science, Philosophy of
- Comte, Auguste
- Concepts
- Conceptual Role Semantics
- Conditionals
- Confirmation
- Confucius
- Connectionism
- Consciousness
- Constructive Empiricism
- Contemporary Hylomorphism
- Contextualism
- Contrastivism
- Cook Wilson, John
- Cosmology, Philosophy of
- Critical Theory
- Culture and Cognition
- Daoism and Philosophy
- Davidson, Donald
- de Beauvoir, Simone
- de Montaigne, Michel
- Death
- Decision Theory
- Deleuze, Gilles
- Democracy
- Depiction
- Derrida, Jacques
- Descartes, René
- Descartes, René: Sensory Representations
- Descriptions
- Dewey, John
- Dialetheism
- Disability
- Disagreement, Epistemology of
- Disjunctivism
- Dispositions
- Doing and Allowing
- du Châtelet, Emilie
- Dummett, Michael
- Dutch Book Arguments
- Early Modern Philosophy, 1600-1750
- Eastern Orthodox Philosophical Thought
- Education, Philosophy of
- Emotion
- Engineering, Philosophy and Ethics of
- Environmental Philosophy
- Epicurus
- Epistemic Basing Relation
- Epistemic Defeat
- Epistemic Injustice
- Epistemic Justification
- Epistemic Philosophy of Logic
- Epistemology
- Epistemology and Active Externalism
- Epistemology, Bayesian
- Epistemology, Feminist
- Epistemology, Internalism and Externalism in
- Epistemology, Moral
- Epistemology of Education
- Ethical Consequentialism
- Ethical Deontology
- Ethical Intuitionism
- Eugenics and Philosophy
- Events, The Philosophy of
- Evidence
- Evidence-Based Medicine, Philosophy of
- Evidential Support Relation In Epistemology, The
- Evil
- Evolutionary Debunking Arguments in Ethics
- Evolutionary Epistemology
- Experimental Philosophy
- Explanations of Religion
- Extended Mind Thesis, The
- Externalism and Internalism in the Philosophy of Mind
- Faith, Conceptions of
- Fatalism
- Feminist Philosophy
- Feyerabend, Paul
- Fichte, Johann Gottlieb
- Fiction
- Fictionalism
- Fictionalism in the Philosophy of Mathematics
- Film, Philosophy of
- Foot, Philippa
- Foreknowledge
- Forgiveness
- Formal Epistemology
- Foucault, Michel
- Free Will
- Frege, Gottlob
- Gadamer, Hans-Georg
- Geometry, Epistemology of
- God and Possible Worlds
- God, Arguments for the Existence of
- God, The Existence and Attributes of
- Grice, Paul
- Habermas, Jürgen
- Hart, H. L. A.
- Heaven and Hell
- Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich: Aesthetics
- Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich: Metaphysics
- Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich: Philosophy of History
- Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich: Philosophy of Politics
- Heidegger, Martin: Early Works
- Hermeneutics
- Higher Education, Philosophy of
- History, Philosophy of
- Hobbes, Thomas
- Horkheimer, Max
- Human Rights
- Hume, David: Aesthetics
- Hume, David: Moral and Political Philosophy
- Husserl, Edmund
- Idealizations in Science
- Identity in Physics
- Images
- Imagination
- Imagination and Belief
- Impossible Worlds
- Incommensurability in Science
- Indian Philosophy
- Indispensability of Mathematics
- Inductive Reasoning
- Infinitism
- Instruments in Science
- Intellectual Humility
- Intentionality, Collective
- Intuitions
- James, William
- Japanese Philosophy
- Kant and the Laws of Nature
- Kant, Immanuel: Aesthetics and Teleology
- Kant, Immanuel: Ethics
- Kant, Immanuel: Theoretical Philosophy
- Kierkegaard, Søren
- Knowledge
- Knowledge-first Epistemology
- Knowledge-How
- Kuhn, Thomas S.
- Lacan, Jacques
- Lakatos, Imre
- Langer, Susanne
- Language of Thought
- Language, Philosophy of
- Latin American Philosophy
- Laws of Nature
- Legal Epistemology
- Legal Philosophy
- Legal Positivism
- Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm
- Levinas, Emmanuel
- Lewis, C. I.
- Liberty
- Literature, Philosophy of
- Locke, John
- Locke, John: Identity, Persons, and Personal Identity
- Logic
- Lottery and Preface Paradoxes, The
- Lucretius
- Machiavelli, Niccolò
- Martin Heidegger: Later Works
- Martin Heidegger: Middle Works
- Marx, Karl
- Material Constitution
- Mathematical Explanation
- Mathematical Pluralism
- Mathematical Structuralism
- Mathematics, Ontology of
- Mathematics, Philosophy of
- Mathematics, Visual Thinking in
- McDowell, John
- McTaggart, John
- Meaning of Life, The
- Mechanisms in Science
- Medically Assisted Dying
- Medicine, Contemporary Philosophy of
- Medieval Logic
- Medieval Philosophy
- Memory
- Mental Causation
- Mereology
- Merleau-Ponty, Maurice
- Meta-epistemological Skepticism
- Metaepistemology
- Metaethics
- Metametaphysics
- Metaphilosophy
- Metaphor
- Metaphysical Grounding
- Metaphysics, Contemporary
- Metaphysics, Feminist
- Midgley, Mary
- Mill, John Stuart
- Mind, Metaphysics of
- Modal Epistemology
- Modality
- Models and Theories in Science
- Modularity
- Montesquieu
- Moore, G. E.
- Moral Contractualism
- Moral Naturalism and Nonnaturalism
- Moral Responsibility
- Multiculturalism
- Murdoch, Iris
- Music, Analytic Philosophy of
- Nationalism
- Natural Kinds
- Naturalism in the Philosophy of Mathematics
- Naïve Realism
- Neo-Confucianism
- Neuroscience, Philosophy of
- Nietzsche, Friedrich
- Nonexistent Objects
- Normative Ethics
- Normative Foundations, Philosophy of Law:
- Normativity and Social Explanation
- Objectivity
- Occasionalism
- Olfaction
- Ontological Dependence
- Ontology of Art
- Ordinary Objects
- Other Minds
- Pacifism
- Pain
- Panpsychism
- Paradoxes
- Particularism in Ethics
- Pascal, Blaise
- Paternalism
- Patriotism
- Peirce, Charles Sanders
- Perception, Cognition, Action
- Perception, The Problem of
- Perfectionism
- Persistence
- Personal Identity
- Phenomenal Concepts
- Phenomenal Conservatism
- Phenomenology
- Philosophy for Children
- Photography, Analytic Philosophy of
- Physicalism
- Physicalism and Metaphysical Naturalism
- Physics, Experiments in
- Plato
- Plotinus
- Political Epistemology
- Political Obligation
- Political Philosophy
- Popper, Karl
- Pornography and Objectification, Analytic Approaches to
- Practical Knowledge
- Practical Moral Skepticism
- Practical Reason
- Pragmatics
- Pragmatism
- Probabilistic Representations of Belief
- Probability, Interpretations of
- Problem of Divine Hiddenness, The
- Problem of Evil, The
- Propositions
- Psychology, Philosophy of
- Punishment
- Pyrrhonism
- Qualia
- Quietism
- Quine, W. V. O.
- Race
- Racist Jokes
- Rationalism
- Rationality
- Rawls, John: Moral and Political Philosophy
- Realism and Anti-Realism
- Realization
- Reasons in Epistemology
- Reductionism in Biology
- Reference, Theory of
- Reid, Thomas
- Relativism
- Reliabilism
- Religion, Philosophy of
- Religious Belief, Epistemology of
- Religious Experience
- Religious Pluralism
- Ricoeur, Paul
- Rights
- Risk, Philosophy of
- Rorty, Richard
- Rousseau, Jean-Jacques
- Rule-Following
- Russell, Bertrand
- Ryle, Gilbert
- Sartre, Jean-Paul
- Schopenhauer, Arthur
- Science and Religion
- Science, Theoretical Virtues in
- Scientific Explanation
- Scientific Progress
- Scientific Realism
- Scientific Representation
- Scientific Revolutions
- Scotus, Duns
- Self-Knowledge
- Sellars, Wilfrid
- Semantic Externalism
- Semantic Minimalism
- Semiotics
- Seneca
- Senses, The
- Sensitivity Principle in Epistemology
- Singular Thought
- Situated Cognition
- Situationism and Virtue Theory
- Skepticism, Contemporary
- Skepticism, History of
- Slurs, Pejoratives, and Hate Speech
- Smith, Adam: Moral and Political Philosophy
- Social Aspects of Scientific Knowledge
- Social Epistemology
- Social Identity
- Sounds and Auditory Perception
- Space and Time
- Speech Acts
- Spinoza, Baruch
- Stebbing, Susan
- Strawson, P. F.
- Structural Realism
- Suicide
- Supererogation
- Supervenience
- Tarski, Alfred
- Technology, Philosophy of
- Testimony, Epistemology of
- Theoretical Terms in Science
- Thomas Aquinas' Philosophy of Religion
- Thought Experiments
- Time and Tense
- Time Travel
- Toleration
- Torture
- Transcendental Arguments
- Tropes
- Trust
- Truth
- Truth and the Aim of Belief
- Truthmaking
- Turing Test
- Two-Dimensional Semantics
- Understanding
- Uniqueness and Permissiveness in Epistemology
- Utilitarianism
- Vagueness
- Value of Knowledge
- Vienna Circle
- Virtue Epistemology
- Virtue Ethics
- Virtues, Epistemic
- Virtues, Intellectual
- Voluntarism, Doxastic
- War
- Weakness of Will
- Weil, Simone
- Well-Being
- William of Ockham
- Williams, Bernard
- Wisdom
- Wittgenstein, Ludwig: Early Works
- Wittgenstein, Ludwig: Later Works
- Wittgenstein, Ludwig: Middle Works
- Wollstonecraft, Mary