Toleration
- LAST REVIEWED: 25 April 2019
- LAST MODIFIED: 27 March 2014
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780195399301-0109
- LAST REVIEWED: 25 April 2019
- LAST MODIFIED: 27 March 2014
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780195399301-0109
Introduction
The history of religious toleration has long been dominated by Whiggish historiography, which focuses on identifying the origins of modern values and institutions. Whig historians often identified toleration as a positive value that had its origin in European intellectual traditions, especially among English and Protestant thinkers of the 16th, 17th, and 18th centuries. While some intellectual historians emphasize the period of the Enlightenment in spreading religious toleration, considerable scholarship points to contributions in the Renaissance and Reformation. Some look to Renaissance traditions of humanism and skepticism, while others point to the breakup of Christianity following the Reformation as forcing some Europeans to develop justifications for toleration. Some critics of this approach have studied advocates of toleration in the Middle Ages. Others have moved away from the history of ideas and emphasized that legal frameworks for religious toleration, such as the 1598 Edict of Nantes in France or the 1648 Peace of Westphalia in the Holy Roman Empire, were only adopted begrudgingly after persuasion, coercion, and open warfare proved unsuccessful at resolving religious conflicts. More recently, social and cultural historians have promoted a revisionist perspective that highlights that individuals learned to coexist often even in the absence of philosophical theories or legal frameworks to legitimize toleration. The result has been an increasing interest in the daily practices of toleration. Much of this scholarship has focused on coexistence between members of competing Christian churches (also called confessions), but some have also included studies of Christians, Muslims, and Jews. The breadth of this scholarship has continued to expand to include Europeans’ contact with and ideas about non-Christians and non-Europeans. Within Europe, local and biographical studies have examined the contingent and diverse nature of forms of toleration and coexistence. Considerable recent scholarship has highlighted the extent to which the permeability of religious boundaries helps explain forms of pluralism and toleration. Thus, despite the polarizing and exclusivist rhetoric of clergy, blurry, permeable, and ambiguous views toward faith and the supernatural are now often cited as essential to understanding toleration and the practices of coexistence in the Renaissance and Reformation.
General Overviews
Until the mid-20th century, scholarship on the history of toleration was largely the purview of Whiggish historians. Generally, this literature emphasized a progressive shift from the intolerance of the Middle Ages, to the transitional periods of the Renaissance and Reformation, culminating with the emergence of toleration as a defining feature of modernity from the late 17th century. Among the single-authored books recommended are leading representatives of Whiggish scholarship. These works, such as Jordan 1932–1940, emphasize Protestant and English intellectual contributions to the development of modern toleration. Also recommended are important critiques of this tradition. Whiggish history was first critiqued in 1931; see Butterfield 1965. In the 1960s, Kamen 1967 and Lecler 1960 acknowledged Catholic tolerationists as well as Protestants who were fundamentally intolerant, though both generally retained the same narrative of a transition from intolerance to toleration. Guggisberg 1983 offers a useful typology of arguments for toleration from the Renaissance to the Enlightenment. Zagorin 2003 is among the most recent authors who emphasize the spread of tolerationist ideas. This view has been recently challenged on two main fronts. First, medieval intellectual histories like Nederman 2000 point out that advocates of religious toleration long predated the Renaissance and Reformation. Second, revisionists like Kaplan 2007 point to the dynamic forms of coexistence that people developed even in the absence of modern liberal intellectual defenses of toleration. Revisionists have also introduced a variety of new methods of cultural and social history to the study of religious toleration.
Butterfield, Herbert. The Whig Interpretation of History. New York: Norton, 1965.
Essential reading for the history of toleration. Originally published in 1931, Butterfield’s book criticizes so-called Whig historians, that is, historians who focus on identifying the origins of modern institutions and values. Gives particular attention to the relationship between the Reformation and religious toleration as a modern value.
Guggisberg, Hans R. “The Defence of Religious Toleration and Religious Liberty in Early Modern Europe: Arguments, Pressures and Consequence.” History of European Ideas 4.3 (1983): 35–50.
DOI: 10.1016/0191--6599(83)90039--6
Traces arguments used by advocates of religious toleration in Europe from the 16th to the 17th century. Distinguishes the more limited religious toleration from religious liberty, which did not gain adherents until the Enlightenment. Guggisberg makes similar claims in several other German-language writings that are worth consulting too.
Jordan, W. K. The Development of Religious Toleration in England. 4 vols. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1932–1940.
Though widely critiqued now as Whiggish, this survey of religious toleration in England from 1558 to 1660 provides a useful introduction. Identifies the origins of toleration in the so-called “moderation” of the Elizabethan regime. For a contrary position, see Shagan 2011 (cited under Law and Practice: England).
Kamen, Henry. The Rise of Toleration. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1967.
A readable introduction to the history of religious toleration in Europe from the Middle Ages to the Enlightenment for undergraduates or the general public. Offers a narrative that generally moves from intolerance of the Middle Ages to increasing toleration. Focuses on intellectual and legal forms of toleration.
Kaplan, Benjamin J. Divided by Faith: Religious Conflict and the Practice of Toleration in Early Modern Europe. Cambridge, MA: Belknap, 2007.
The most authoritative survey of forms of religious coexistence. This revisionist treatment of religious toleration offers an alternative to teleological or Whiggish histories as well as histories that privilege intellectual history over social and cultural realities of Early Modern Europe.
Lecler, Joseph. Toleration and the Reformation. 2 vols. Translated by T. L. Weslow. London: Longmans, 1960.
Originally published in French in 1955 as Histoire de la tolérance au siècle de la Réforme. An intellectual history of toleration that provides a counterpoint to Whiggish historians who find the origins of toleration in England and/or Protestantism. Still susceptible to the criticisms of revisionists like Kaplan 2007.
Nederman, Cary. Worlds of Difference: European Discourses of Toleration, c. 1100–c. 1550. University Park: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2000.
In contrast to those who find the origins of toleration in the Renaissance, Reformation or Enlightenment, this book offers studies of seven advocates of religious toleration in the Middle Ages.
Zagorin, Perez. How the Idea of Religious Toleration Came to the West. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2003.
Traces a transition from an era when persecution was the norm, in the Middle Ages, to a time when the idea of religious toleration became a dominant mode of thought in the late 17th century. Read in contrast with Kaplan 2007 and Nederman 2000.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login.
How to Subscribe
Oxford Bibliographies Online is available by subscription and perpetual access to institutions. For more information or to contact an Oxford Sales Representative click here.
Article
- Academies
- Aemilia Lanyer
- Agrippa d’Aubigné
- Alberti, Leon Battista
- Alexander VI, Pope
- Amsterdam
- Andrea Mantegna
- Andreas Bodenstein von Karlstadt
- Anne Boleyn
- Anne Bradstreet
- Antwerp
- Aretino, Pietro
- Ariosto, Ludovico
- Art and Science
- Art, German
- Art in Renaissance England
- Art in Renaissance Florence
- Art in Renaissance Siena
- Art in Renaissance Venice
- Art Literature and Theory of Art
- Art Market
- Art of Poetry
- Art, Spanish
- Art, 16th- and 17th-Century Flemish
- Art, 17th-Century Dutch
- Artemisia Gentileschi
- Artisans
- Ascham, Roger
- Askew, Anne
- Astell, Mary
- Astrology, Alchemy, Magic
- Augsburg
- Austria
- Avignon Papacy
- Bacon, Francis
- Banking and Money
- Barbaro, Ermolao, the Younger
- Barbaro, Francesco
- Baron, Hans
- Baroque
- Baroque Art and Architecture in Italy
- Barzizza, Gasparino
- Bathsua Makin
- Beaufort, Margaret
- Bellarmine, Cardinal
- Bembo, Pietro
- Benito Arias Montano
- Bernardino of Siena, San
- Beroaldo, Filippo, the Elder
- Bessarion, Cardinal
- Bible, The
- Biondo, Flavio
- Bishops, 1550–1700
- Bishops, 1400-1550
- Black Death and Plague: The Disease and Medical Thought
- Boccaccio, Giovanni
- Bohemia and Bohemian Crown Lands
- Borgia, Cesare
- Borgia, Lucrezia
- Borromeo, Cardinal Carlo
- Bosch, Hieronymous
- Bracciolini, Poggio
- Brahe, Tycho
- Bruegel, Pieter the Elder
- Bruni, Leonardo
- Bruno, Giordano
- Bucer, Martin
- Buonarroti, Michelangelo
- Burgundy and the Netherlands
- Calvin, John
- Calvinism
- Camões, Luís de
- Caravaggio
- Cardano, Girolamo
- Cardinal Richelieu
- Cardinals
- Carvajal y Mendoza, Luisa De
- Cary, Elizabeth
- Casas, Bartolome de las
- Castiglione, Baldassarre
- Catherine of Siena
- Catholic/Counter-Reformation
- Catholicism, Early Modern
- Cecilia del Nacimiento
- Cellini, Benvenuto
- Cervantes, Miguel de
- Charles V, Emperor
- China and Europe, 1550-1800
- Christian-Muslim Exchange
- Church Fathers in Renaissance and Reformation Thought, The
- Ciceronianism
- Cities and Urban Patriciates
- Civic Humanism
- Civic Ritual
- Classical Tradition, The
- Clifford, Anne
- Colet, John
- Colonna, Vittoria
- Columbus, Christopher
- Comenius, Jan Amos
- Commedia dell'arte
- Concepts of the Renaissance, c. 1780–c. 1920
- Confraternities
- Constantinople, Fall of
- Contarini, Gasparo, Cardinal
- Convent Culture
- Conversion
- Conversos and Crypto-Judaism
- Copernicus, Nicolaus
- Cornaro, Caterina
- Cosimo il Vecchio de' Medici
- Costume
- Council of Trent
- Crime and Punishment
- Croatia
- Cromwell, Oliver
- Cruz, Juana de la, Mother
- Cruz, Juana Inés de la, Sor
- Dance
- d'Aragona, Tullia
- Datini, Margherita
- Davies, Eleanor
- de Commynes, Philippe
- de Sales, Saint Francis
- de Valdés, Juan
- Death and Dying
- Decembrio, Pier Candido
- Dentière, Marie
- Des Roches, Madeleine and Catherine
- d’Este, Isabella
- di Toledo, Eleonora
- Dialogue
- Diplomacy
- Dolce, Ludovico
- Donatello
- Donne, John
- Drama, English Renaissance
- Dürer, Albrecht
- du Bellay, Joachim
- Du Guillet, Pernette
- Dutch Overseas Empire
- Ebreo, Leone
- Edmund Campion
- Edward IV, King of England
- El Greco
- Elizabeth I, the Great, Queen of England
- Emperor, Maximilian I
- England, 1485-1642
- English Overseas Empire
- English Puritans, Quakers, Dissenters, and Recusants
- Environment and the Natural World
- Epic and Romance
- Erasmus
- Europe and the Globe, 1350–1700
- European Tapestries
- Family and Childhood
- Fedele, Cassandra
- Federico Barocci
- Ferrara and the Este
- Ficino, Marsilio
- Filelfo, Francesco
- Florence
- Fonte, Moderata
- Foscari, Francesco
- France in the 17th Century
- France in the 16th Century
- Francis Xavier, St
- Francisco Jiménez de Cisneros
- French Law and Justice
- French Renaissance Drama
- Fugger Family
- Galilei, Galileo
- Gallicanism
- Gambara, Veronica
- Garin, Eugenio
- General Church Councils, Pre-Trent
- Geneva (1400-1600)
- George Buchanan
- George of Trebizond
- Georges de La Tour
- Ghetto
- Giambologna
- Ginés de Sepúlveda, Juan
- Giustiniani, Bernardo
- Góngora, Luis de
- Gournay, Marie de
- Greek Visitors
- Guarino da Verona
- Guicciardini, Francesco
- Guilds and Manufacturing
- Hamburg, 1350–1815
- Hanseatic League
- Henry VII
- Henry VIII, King of England
- Herbert, George
- Hispanic Mysticism
- Historiography
- Hobbes, Thomas
- Holy Roman Empire 1300–1650
- Homes, Foundling
- Huguenots
- Humanism
- Humanism, The Origins of
- Hundred Years War, The
- Hungary, The Kingdom of
- Hus, Jan
- Hutchinson, Lucy
- Iconology and Iconography
- Ignatius of Loyola, Saint
- Inquisition, Roman
- Ireland
- Isaac Casaubon
- Isabel I, Queen of Castile
- Italian Wars, 1494–1559
- Ivan IV the Terrible, Tsar of Russia
- Jacques Lefèvre d’Étaples
- Jansenism
- Japan and Europe: the Christian Century, 1549-1650
- Jeanne d’Albret, queen of Navarre
- Jesuits
- Jews
- Jews and Christians in Venice
- Jews and the Reformation
- Jews in Florence
- Joan of Arc
- Jonson, Ben
- Joseph Justus Scaliger
- Juan de Torquemada
- Julius II
- Kepler, Johannes
- King of France, Francis I
- King of France, Henri IV
- Knox, John
- Kristeller, Paul Oskar
- Labé, Louise
- Landino, Cristoforo
- Landscape
- Last Wills and Testaments
- Laura Cereta
- Law
- Lay Piety
- Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm
- Leo X
- Leonardo da Vinci
- Leoni, Leone and Pompeo
- Leto, Giulio Pomponio
- Letter Writing and Epistolary Culture
- Libraries
- Literary Criticism
- Literature, French
- Literature, Italian
- Literature, Late Medieval German
- Literature, Penitential
- Literature, Spanish
- Locke, John
- London
- Lorenzo de' Medici
- Lorenzo Ghiberti
- Louis XI, King of France
- Louis XIII, King of France
- Louis XIV, King of France
- Lucas Cranach the Elder
- Lucretius in Renaissance Thought
- Luther, Martin
- Lyric Poetry
- Machiavelli, Niccolo
- Macinghi Strozzi, Alessandra
- Malatesta, Sigismondo
- Manetti, Giannozzo
- Mannerism
- Mantovano (Battista Spagnoli), Battista
- Manuel Chrysoloras
- Manuzio, Aldo
- Margaret Clitherow
- Margaret Fell Fox
- Margery Kempe
- Marinella, Lucrezia
- Marino Sanudo
- Marlowe, Christopher
- Marriage and Dowry
- Mary Stuart (Mary, Queen of Scots)
- Mary Tudor, Queen of England
- Masculinity
- Medici Bank
- Medici, Catherine de'
- Medici Family, The
- Medicine
- Mediterranean
- Memling, Hans
- Merici, Angela
- Midwifery
- Milan, 1535–1706
- Milan to 1535
- Mirandola, Giovanni Pico della
- Mission
- Monarchy in Renaissance and Reformation Europe, Female
- Montaigne, Michel de
- More, Thomas
- Morone, Cardinal Giovanni
- Music
- Naples, 1300–1700
- Navarre, Marguerite de
- Netherlandish Art, Early
- Netherlands (Dutch Revolt/ Dutch Republic), The
- Netherlands, Spanish, 1598-1700, the
- Nettesheim, Agrippa von
- Newton, Isaac
- Niccoli, Niccolò
- Nicholas of Cusa
- Nicolas Malebranche
- Nobility
- Opera
- Ottoman Empire
- Ovid in Renaissance Thought
- Panofsky, Erwin
- Paolo Veronese
- Papacy
- Papal Rome
- Paracelsus
- Paris
- Parr, Katherine
- Patronage of the Arts
- Perotti, Niccolò
- Persecution and Martyrdom
- Peter the Great, Tsar of Russia
- Petrarch
- Petrus Ramus and Ramism
- Philip Melanchthon
- Philips, Katherine
- Piccolomini, Aeneas Sylvius
- Piero della Francesca
- Pierre Bayle
- Pilgrimage in Early Modern Catholicism
- Plague and its Consequences
- Platonism, Neoplatonism, and the Hermetic Tradition
- Poetry, English
- Pole, Cardinal Reginald
- Polish Literature: Baroque
- Polish Literature: Renaissance
- Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, The
- Political Thought
- Poliziano, Angelo
- Polydore Vergil
- Pontano, Giovanni Giovano
- Pope Innocent VIII
- Pope Nicholas V
- Pope Paul II
- Portraiture
- Portugal
- Poulain de la Barre, Francois
- Poverty and Poor Relief
- Prince Henry the Navigator
- Printing and the Book
- Printmaking
- Prophecy
- Purgatory
- Purity of Blood
- Quirini, Lauro
- Rabelais, François
- Raphael
- Reformation and Hussite Revolution, Czech
- Reformation and Wars of Religion in France, The
- Reformation, English
- Reformation, German
- Reformation, Italian, The
- Reformation, The
- Reformations and Revolt in the Netherlands, 1500–1621
- Rembrandt
- Renaissance, The
- Reuchlin, Johann
- Revolutionary England, 1642-1702
- Rhetoric
- Ricci, Matteo
- Richard III
- Rienzo, Cola Di
- Roman and Iberian Inquisitions, Censorship and the Index i...
- Ronsard, Pierre de
- Roper, Margeret More
- Royal Regencies in Renaissance and Reformation Europe, 140...
- Rubens, Peter Paul
- Russell, Elizabeth Cooke Hoby
- Russia and Muscovy
- Ruzante Angelo Beolco
- Saint John of the Cross
- Saints and Mystics: After Trent
- Saints and Mystics: Before Trent
- Salutati, Coluccio
- Sandro Botticelli
- Sarpi, Fra Paolo
- Savonarola, Girolamo
- Scandinavia
- Scholasticism and Aristotelianism: Fourteenth to Seventeen...
- Schooling and Literacy
- Scientific Revolution
- Scotland
- Scève, Maurice
- Sephardic Diaspora
- Sforza, Caterina
- Sforza, Francesco
- Shakespeare, William
- Sidney Herbert, Mary, Countess of Pembroke
- Sidney, Philip
- Simon of Trent
- Sixtus IV, Pope
- Skepticism in Renaissance Thought
- Southern Italy, 1500–1700
- Southern Italy, 1300–1500
- Spain
- Spanish Inquisition
- Spanish Islam, 1350-1614
- Spenser, Edmund
- Sperone Speroni
- Spinoza, Baruch
- Stampa, Gaspara
- Stuart, Elizabeth, Queen of Bohemia
- Switzerland
- Tarabotti, Arcangela
- Tasso Torquato
- Tell, William
- Teresa of Avila
- Textiles: 1400 to 1700
- The Casa of San Giorgio, Genoa
- The Radical Reformation
- The Sack of Rome (1527)
- Thirty Years War, The
- Thomas Wyatt
- Titian
- Toleration
- Tornabuoni, Lucrezia
- Trade Networks
- Tragedy, English
- Translation
- Transylvania, The Principality of
- Traversari, Ambrogio
- Universities
- Urbanism
- Ursulines
- Valeriano, Pierio
- Valla, Lorenzo
- van Eyck, Jan
- van Schurman, Anna Maria
- Vasari, Giorgio
- Vega, Lope de
- Vegio, Maffeo
- Velázquez
- Venice
- Venice, Maritime
- Vergerio, Pier Paolo, The Elder
- Vermeer, Johannes
- Vernacular Languages and Dialects
- Vida, Marco Girolamo
- Virgil in Renaissance Thought
- Visitors, Italian
- Vives, Juan Luis
- Walter Ralegh
- War and Economy, 1300-1600
- Ward, Mary
- Warfare and Military Organizations
- Weyden, Rogier van der
- Widowhood
- Witch Hunt
- Wolsey, Thomas, Cardinal
- Women and Learning
- Women and Medicine
- Women and Science
- Women and the Book Trade
- Women and the Reformation
- Women and the Visual Arts
- Women and Warfare
- Women and Work: Fourteenth to Seventeenth Centuries
- Women Writers in Ireland
- Women Writers of the Iberian Empire
- Women Writing in Early Modern Spain
- Women Writing in English
- Women Writing in French
- Women Writing in Italy
- Wroth, Mary