Comparative Regionalism
- LAST REVIEWED: 24 March 2021
- LAST MODIFIED: 24 March 2021
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199743292-0301
- LAST REVIEWED: 24 March 2021
- LAST MODIFIED: 24 March 2021
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199743292-0301
Introduction
Comparative regionalism refers to the study of (“world”) regions and regionalism in comparative perspective. The field emerged in the 1960s and 1970s, and the keyword was “regional integration,” which reflected the dominance of European integration theory and practice. Although the early debate—later referred to as “old regionalism”—took comparison seriously, a general belief emerged that regionalism in the rest of the world deviated from the European integration experience. After a general decline of regionalism in the 1970s and 1980s, the phenomenon reemerged after the end of the Cold War. The explosion of literature on regionalism in the 1990s and early 2000s—often referred to as “new regionalism”—emphasized that regionalism was a global and multidimensional phenomenon, involving both state and nonstate actors across a growing number of policy fields and in a variety of forms and institutional designs. The research field remained fragmented in the 1990s and early 2000s, characterized by rivalries and a lack of dialogue between theoretical and methodological standpoints as well as regional and thematic specializations. Since the latter half of the 2000s, the intellectual landscape changed again and comparative regionalism has consolidated as a research field, with greater acceptance of contrasting theoretical and methodological perspectives and with more advanced comparisons across both regions and policy fields. The result has been that the research field is no longer structured in a hub-and-spoke fashion around Europe versus the rest. By implication, the concept of regional integration has been subsumed under a broader and more general conceptual umbrella, and it has become established to refer to the research field as comparative regionalism.
General Overviews
The return of regionalism in the 1990s triggered an intense debate about “old” and “new” regionalism (see Väyrynen 2003 for an overview). During this period, many scholars concentrated on regional organizations in comparative perspective and frequently considered Europe to be the most advanced case, which reflected the continuities from old regionalism and a general preference for “regional integration” (for an example, see Laursen 2010). In contrast, many proponents of “new regionalism” challenged Euro-dominance, advocating more pluralistic theoretical approaches and a simultaneous focus on both state and nonstate actors within both formal and informal institutions. See Shaw, et al. 2012 for a wide-ranging contribution to the new regionalism. An authoritative piece, Hettne 2005, written by one of the founders of the new regionalism, claims that the distinction between old and new regionalism often has been exaggerated or even misused. Hettne argues that after more than two decades of new regionalism it is time to think in more general terms—in terms of comparative regionalism. A further strengthening of the research field would not be possible without greater interaction and cross-fertilization between specialists in European integration and specialists in non-Western regionalism. Telò 2009 and Warleigh-Lack, et al. 2011 are two interesting edited contributions written by leading authors from both camps. Since the mid-2010s, comparative regionalism has consolidated as a field of study, evidenced by a series of publications by leading authors, such as Acharya 2012; Börzel and Risse 2016; Engel, et al. 2017; and Söderbaum 2016.
Acharya, Amitav. “Comparative Regionalism: A Field Whose Time Has Come?” In Special Issue: Regionalism in a Changing World: Perspectives from Africa, Asia, Europe and South America. Edited by Lorenzo Fioramonti. The International Spectator 47.1 (2012): 3–15.
DOI: 10.1080/03932729.2012.655004
Agenda-setting contribution by one of the most influential authors in the field that explains what distinguishes the current interest in regions and regionalism from earlier approaches and waves.
Börzel, Tanja, and Thomas Risse, eds. The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Regionalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2016.
One of the most impressive and comprehensive books in the field of comparative regionalism. The twenty-seven chapters by authoritative authors are structured in four parts: approaches, regional orders, policy fields, and regional institutions. The volume will serve as a reference source for both scholars and students for many years. A limitation is that the book does not yet exist in paperback. However, the book and individual chapters are available online in libraries subscribing to Oxford Handbooks.
Engel, Ulf, Heidrun Zinecker, Frank Mattheis, Antje Dietze, and Thomas Plötze, eds. The New Politics of Regionalism: Perspectives from Africa, Latin America and Asia Pacific. London: Routledge, 2017.
Contributors analyze how regional configurations around the world unfold as political responses to a changing global order. The book explicitly challenges conceptual Eurocentrism and approaches regionalism beyond declared objectives. A key objective is to examine how regionalism reterritorializes spaces and asserts sovereignties in response to globalization, with an empirical focus on Africa, Latin America, and the Pacific.
Hettne, Björn. “Beyond the ‘New Regionalism.’” New Political Economy 10.4 (2005): 543–571.
DOI: 10.1080/13563460500344484
One of the most influential scholars in the field in the 1990s and 2000s provides a wide-ranging overview of the field, looking beyond the new regionalism toward comparative regionalism. This piece provides an accessible overview of Hettne’s thinking and the new regionalism approach.
Laursen, Finn, ed. Comparative Regional Integration: Europe and Beyond. Farnham, UK: Ashgate, 2010.
Comprehensive edited book covering all regional integration efforts in all major parts of the world. The key objectives are to explain variation and to compare the European Union (EU) with other regions around the world.
Shaw, Timothy, Andrew Grant, and Scarlett Cornelissen, eds. The Ashgate Research Companion to Regionalisms. Farnham, UK: Ashgate, 2012.
Comprehensive volume of twenty-one chapters coverring a range of approaches and types of formal and informal regionalisms across a range of cases and policy fields. Aimed at both scholars and students and published within the International Political Economy of New Regionalisms series (originally launched by Ashgate Publishing).
Söderbaum, Fredrik. Rethinking Regionalism. London: Macmillan Education, 2016.
DOI: 10.1057/978-1-137-57303-2
Wide-ranging book tackling the intellectual, theoretical, and methodological rivalries in the field and providing new answers to why and how regionalism evolves and consolidates, how it can be compared, and its significance to various policy fields in a changing world. Aimed at both scholars and students and suited for teaching purposes.
Telò, Mario, ed. European Union and New Regionalism: Competing Regionalism and Global Governance in a Post-hegemonic Era. 2d ed. Farnham, UK: Ashgate, 2009.
Popular and well-known volume that focuses on competing models of regionalism around the world and the role of the European Union. Includes contributions from many leading authors from both European studies and specialists from the rest of the world. Updated and improved in several editions and useful for teaching purposes.
Väyrynen, Raimo. “Regionalism: Old and New.” International Studies Review 5.1 (2003): 25–51.
A thorough and much cited review of the debates in old and new regionalism, focusing, in particular, on regional economic integration and security regionalism.
Warleigh-Lack, Alex, Nick Robinson, and Ben Rosamond, eds. New Regionalism and the European Union: Dialogues, Comparisons and New Research Directions. London: Routledge, 2011.
This book challenges the polarization between EU and non-EU specialists. In addition to a useful introduction and framework by the editors, leading experts from both camps offer a series of case studies on regionalism within Africa, Asia, Europe, Latin America, and North America.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login.
How to Subscribe
Oxford Bibliographies Online is available by subscription and perpetual access to institutions. For more information or to contact an Oxford Sales Representative click here.
Article
- Academic Theories of International Relations Since 1945
- Africa, The Islamic State (ISIS/ISIL) in
- Alliances
- Al-Qaeda in the Islamic Maghreb
- Al-Shabaab
- Arab-Israeli Wars
- Arab-Israeli Wars, 1967-1973, The
- Armed Conflicts/Violence against Civilians Data Sets
- Arms Control
- Arms Races
- Arms Trade
- Asylum Policies
- Audience Costs and the Credibility of Commitments
- Authoritarian Regimes
- Balance of Power Theory
- Bargaining Theory of War
- Battle
- Boko Haram
- Brazilian Foreign Policy, The Politics of
- Canadian Foreign Policy
- Case Study Methods in International Relations
- Casualties and Politics
- Causation in International Relations
- Central Europe
- Challenge of Communism, The
- China and Japan
- China's Defense Policy
- China’s Foreign Policy
- Chinese Approaches to Strategy
- Cities and International Relations
- Civil Resistance
- Civil Society in the European Union
- Cold War, The
- Colonialism
- Comparative Foreign Policy Security Interests
- Comparative Regionalism
- Complex Systems Approaches to Global Politics
- Conflict Behavior and the Prevention of War
- Conflict Management
- Conflict Management in the Middle East
- Constructivism
- Contemporary Shia–Sunni Sectarian Violence
- Corruption
- Counterinsurgency
- Countermeasures in International Law
- Coups and Mutinies
- Criminal Law, International
- Crisis Bargaining
- Critical Theory of International Relations
- Cuban Missile Crisis, The
- Cultural Diplomacy
- Cyber Security
- Cyber Warfare
- Decision-Making, Poliheuristic Theory of
- Demobilization, Post World War I
- Democracies and World Order
- Democracy and Conflict
- Democracy in World Politics
- Deterrence Theory
- Development
- Diasporas
- Digital Diplomacy
- Diplomacy
- Diplomacy, Gender and
- Diplomacy, History of
- Diplomacy in the ASEAN
- Diplomacy, Public
- Disaster Diplomacy
- Diversionary Theory of War
- Drone Warfare
- Eastern Front (World War I)
- Economic Coercion and Sanctions
- Economics, International
- Embedded Liberalism
- Emerging Powers and BRICS
- Emotions
- Empirical Testing of Formal Models
- Energy and International Security
- Environmental Peacebuilding
- Epidemic Diseases and their Effects on History
- Ethics and Morality in International Relations
- Ethnicity in International Relations
- European Migration Policy
- European Security and Defense Policy, The
- European Union as an International Actor
- European Union, International Relations of the
- Experiments
- Face-to-Face Diplomacy
- Fascism, The Challenge of
- Feminist Methodologies in International Relations
- Feminist Security Studies
- Food Security
- Forecasting in International Relations
- Foreign Aid and Assistance
- Foreign Direct Investment
- Foreign Policy Decision-Making
- Foreign Policy of Non-democratic Regimes
- Foreign Policy of Saudi Arabia
- Foreign Policy, Theories of
- French Empire, 20th-Century
- From Club to Network Diplomacy
- Future of NATO
- Game Theory and Interstate Conflict
- Gender and Terrorism
- Gendering Disasters
- Gendering Forced Migration
- Genocide
- Genocide, Politicide, and Mass Atrocities Against Civilian...
- Genocides, 20th Century
- Geopolitics and Geostrategy
- Germany in World War II
- Global Citizenship
- Global Civil Society
- Global Constitutionalism
- Global Environmental Politics
- Global Ethic of Care
- Global Governance
- Global Justice, Western Perspectives
- Globalization
- Governance of the Arctic
- Grand Strategy
- Greater Middle East, The
- Greek Crisis
- Hague Conferences (1899, 1907)
- Hegemony
- Hezbollah
- Hierarchies in International Relations
- History and International Relations
- History of Brazilian Foreign Policy (1808 to 1945)
- Human Nature in International Relations
- Human Rights
- Human Rights and Humanitarian Diplomacy
- Human Rights, Feminism and
- Human Rights Law
- Human Security
- Hybrid Warfare
- Ideal Diplomat, The
- Idealism
- Identity and Foreign Policy
- Ideology, Values, and Foreign Policy
- Illicit Trade and Smuggling
- Imperialism
- Indian Foreign Policy
- Indian Perspectives on International Relations, War, and C...
- Indigenous Rights
- Industrialization
- Intelligence
- Intelligence Oversight
- Internal Displacement
- International Conflict Settlements, The Durability of
- International Criminal Court, The
- International Economic Organizations (IMF and World Bank)
- International Health Governance
- International Justice, Theories of
- International Law
- International Law, Feminist Perspectives on
- International Monetary Relations, History of
- International Negotiation and Conflict Resolution
- International Nongovernmental Organizations
- International Norms for Cultural Preservation and Cooperat...
- International Organizations
- International Relations, Aesthetic Turn in
- International Relations as a Social Science
- International Relations, Practice Turn in
- International Relations, Research Ethics in
- International Relations Theory
- International Security
- International Society
- International Society, Theorizing
- International Support For Nonstate Armed Groups
- Internet Law
- Interstate Cooperation Theory and International Institutio...
- Intervention and Use of Force
- Interviews and Focus Groups
- Iran, Politics and Foreign Policy
- Iraq: Past and Present
- Japanese Foreign Policy
- Jihadism
- Just War Theory
- Korean War
- Kurdistan and Kurdish Politics
- Law of the Sea
- Laws of War
- Leadership in International Affairs
- Leadership Personality Characteristics and Foreign Policy
- League of Nations
- Lean Forward and Pull Back Options for US Grand Strategy
- Liberalism
- Marxism
- Mediation and Civil Wars
- Mediation in International Conflicts
- Mediation via International Organizations
- Memory and World Politics
- Mercantilism
- Middle East, The Contemporary
- Middle East, The Contemporary
- Middle Powers and Regional Powers
- Military Science
- Minorities in the Middle East
- Minority Rights
- Morality in Foreign Policy
- Multilateralism (1992–), Return to
- National Liberation, International Law and Wars of
- National Security Act of 1947, The
- Nation-Building
- Nations and Nationalism
- NATO
- NATO, Europe, and Russia: Security Issues and the Border R...
- Natural Resources, Energy Politics, and Environmental Cons...
- Neorealism
- New Multilateralism in the Early 21st Century
- Nigeria
- Nonproliferation and Counterproliferation
- Nonviolent Resistance Datasets
- Normative Aspects of International Peacekeeping
- Normative Power Beyond the Eurocentric Frame
- Nuclear Proliferation
- Peace Education in Post-Conflict Zones
- Peace of Utrecht
- Peacebuilding, Post-Conflict
- Peacekeeping
- Piracy
- Political Demography
- Political Economy of National Security
- Political Extremism in Sub-Saharan Africa
- Political Learning and Socialization
- Political Psychology
- Politics and Islam in Turkey
- Politics and Nationalism in Cyprus
- Politics of Extraction: Theories and New Concepts for Crit...
- Politics of Resilience
- Popuism and Global Politics
- Popular Culture and International Relations
- Post-Civil War State
- Post-Conflict and Transitional Justice
- Post-Conflict Reconciliation in the Middle East and North ...
- Power Transition Theory
- Preventive War and Preemption
- Prisoners, Treatment of
- Private Military and Security Companies (PMSCs)
- Process Tracing Methods
- Pro-Government Militias
- Proliferation
- Prospect Theory in International Relations
- Psychoanalysis in Global Politics and International Relati...
- Psychology and Foreign Policy
- Public Opinion and Foreign Policy
- Public Opinion and the European Union
- Quantum Social Science
- Race and International Relations
- Realism
- Rebel Governance
- Reconciliation
- Reflexivity and International Relations
- Religion and International Relations
- Religiously Motivated Violence
- Reputation in International Relations
- Responsibility to Protect
- Rising Powers in World Politics
- Role Theory in International Relations
- Russian Foreign Policy
- Russian Revolutions and Civil War, 1917–1921
- Sanctions
- Sanctions in International Law
- Science Diplomacy
- Second Sino-Japanese War (1937-1945), The
- Secrecy and Diplomacy
- Securitization
- Self-Determination
- Shining Path
- Sinophone and Japanese International Relations Theory
- Small State Diplomacy
- Social Scientific Theories of Imperialism
- Sovereignty
- Soviet Union in World War II
- Space Strategy, Policy, and Power
- Spatial Dependencies and International Mediation
- State Theory in International Relations
- Statehood
- Status in International Relations
- Strategic Air Power
- Strategic and Net Assessments
- Sub-Saharan Africa, Conflict Formations in
- Sustainable Development
- Systems Theory
- Teaching International Relations
- Territorial Disputes
- Terrorism
- Terrorism and Poverty
- Terrorism, Geography of
- Terrorist Financing
- Terrorist Group Strategies
- The Changing Nature of Diplomacy
- The Politics and Diplomacy of Neutrality
- The Politics and Diplomacy of the First World War
- The Queer in/of International Relations
- the Twenty-First Century, Alliance Commitments in
- The Vienna Conventions on Diplomatic and Consular Relation...
- Theories of International Relations, Feminist
- Theory, Chinese International Relations
- Time Series Approaches to International Affairs
- Trade Law
- Transnational Actors
- Transnational Law
- Transnational Social Movements
- Tribunals, War Crimes and
- Trust and International Relations
- Turkey
- UN Security Council
- United Nations, The
- United States and Asia, The
- Uppsala Conflict Data Program
- US and Africa
- US–UK Special Relationship
- Venezuelan Politics and Foreign Policy
- Voluntary International Migration
- War
- War of the Spanish Succession (1701-1714)
- Weapons of Mass Destruction
- Western Balkans
- Western Front (World War I)
- Westphalia, Peace of (1648)
- Women and Peacemaking Peacekeeping
- World Economy 1919-1939
- World Polity School
- World War II Diplomacy and Political Relations
- World-System Theory