Permanent school exclusion rates are increasing for all genders, with much of the dominant discourse being framed around a widening concern about white working-class boys increasingly likely to disengage from formal education systems. Boys are more likely to receive formal fixed or permanent exclusions, but girls too are arguably at a disproportionate risk of being excluded via other means, such as school moves. Alternative education is for pupils under the school leaving age who because of exclusion, illness, or other reasons would not otherwise receive mainstream education. As such more males, then females tend to occupy alternative education provision. There is a great deal of literature about alternative education provision, much of which is international in its scope. This literature represents consistent findings across different countries and time when evaluating particular programs and exploring young people’s perceptions of such provisions, but the literature is much narrower in scope when analyzing the specificities of gender and alternative education. This bibliography is structured to present seminal studies, reports, and other key sources that serve to highlight the definitional issues with alternative education, while also identifying who alternative education tends to serve (with a focus on gender) and how such provision has been evaluated. Gender does to some extent shape the alternative education landscape, being dominated by boys. As such this bibliography serves to fill the dearth of knowledge with regards to the increasing need to highlight the differences in defining alternative education, in terms of who it is for and for what purpose, as well as to investigate how such varying provision is monitored in relation to gender.
Defining Alternative Education and Its Purpose
There is a general agreement that there is no single definition of alternative education, and that there are significant tensions and differences in the task of identifying and ordering the vast array of provision under the umbrella term “Alternative Education” (Krafti 2014; Malcolm 2022; Raywird 1994; Rix and Twinning 2007; Te Riele 2007; Thomson and Pennacchia 2016; Thomson and Russell 2007). This term is used to denote a multitude of practices and sites (Guerin and Denti 1999; O’Gorman, et al. 2015; Thomson and Russell 2009). While a range of alternative education on offer exists across different countries, there is an ongoing need to acknowledge that alternative education in itself is not a new phenomenon, rather it has existed alongside mainstream public education since the first half of the nineteenth century and has a long history located within a progressive tradition in education. Criticisms directed toward alternative education often point to the notion that there are “warehousing” sites reinforcing the cycle of educational inequality (Kim 2010; Mills, et al. 2015; Plows, et al. 2016; Nairn and Higgins 2011).
Guerin, G., and L. Denti. 1999. Alternative education support for youth at-risk. The Clearing House 73.2: 76–78.
Authors note the increase in numbers of students who are educated in alternative education settings. These students are disproportionately from lower socioeconomic backgrounds, are differently abled, bilingual, and from minority groups. Successful alternative education programs are flexible enough to meet the needs of the young people who partake in them. However, Guerin and Denti suggest there is a dearth of research on the competencies needed to teach in alternative education.
Kim, J-H. 2010. Narrative inquiry into re-imagining alternative schools: A case study of Kevin Gonzales. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education 24.1: 77–96.
Based on the biographical journal experience of one boy’s experience of alternative education in the United States, questions arise about who benefits from alternative education. Provisions are often viewed as a “dumping ground” rather than an “idealistic haven” founded to serve the needs of young people. While no direct analysis of gender is made, it is thought that Kevin’s story helps shine a much-needed light on the role of alternative education.
Krafti, P. 2014. What are alternative education spaces—and why do they matter? Geography 99.3: 128–138.
Based on research undertaken in fifty-nine alternative education sites in England, an overview of what it is that makes alternative education “alternative” is offered. Geography is purported as playing a role in terms of how and where education takes place. Outdoor spaces to include parks, farms, and forests are thought to be more prominently utilized, alongside differences in how they are financed, managed, and run when compared to mainstream schooling.
Malcolm, A. 2022. Sustaining post-16 destinations from alternative provision: A review of data and the perspectives of heads from low, mid and high performing schools. Emotional and Behavioural Difficulties 27.1: 20–42.
This research seeks to understand the practices of alternative education in England. Five inter-related areas are purported as important points to consider when measuring the success of post-16 destinations from alternative education provisions. These include staff perceptions, the rigor by which students are tracked, staff knowledge of the post-16 opportunities available (locally and beyond) as well as the need for a strong academic offer and well supported steps from alternative education.
Mills, M., G. McGregor, A. Baroutis, K. Te Reile, and D. Hayes. 2015. Alternative education and social justice: Considering issues of affective and contributive justice. Critical Studies in Education 57.1: 100–115.
Based on a multi-sited ethnographic study of alternative schools across three Australian states, schools are viewed as supporting a socially unjust education system. Authors recognize yet critique Nancy Fraser’s (2009) concept of “social justice” for not sufficiently considering the specific nuances and multifaceted injustices that many marginalized young people face. An argument is made to acknowledge the importance of the “affective” and “contributive” aspects of justice in alternative education contexts.
Nairn, K., and J. Higgins. 2011. The emotional geographies of neoliberal school reforms: Spaces of refuge and containment. Emotion, Space and Society 4.3: 180–186.
Drawing from a larger research project about the post high-school transitions of young people who were in school during New Zealand’s neoliberal reforms, data is drawn from four young men excluded from school and redirected into alternative education. Alternative Education operated as both a space of refuge from alienation experienced in mainstream schooling as well as a site of containment, separating these young men from their mainstream peers.
O’Gorman, E., N. Salmon, and C-A. Murphey. 2015. Schools as sanctuaries: A systematic review of contextual factors which contribute to student retention in alternative education. International Journal of Inclusive Education 20.5: 536–551.
This systematic review analyzes young peoples’ perceptions regarding their decisions to stay or leave alternative education. In all, 1586 studies were screened and data from twenty-four mixed-methods studies were scrutinized. Findings suggest that provisions that provided a safe place and enabled flexibility in their approach to enable students to affirm their cultural identities tended to increase their engagement and subsequent retention in alternative education.
Plows, V., D. Bottrell, and Te Riele. 2016. Valued outcomes in the counter-spaces of alternative education programs: Success but on whose scale? Geographical Research 55.1: 29–37.
Drawing on interview data with staff and students from one provision in Victoria (Australia), this paper explores how conceived, perceived, and lived spaces shape how alternative education programs measure success. Alternative education settings are referred to as “flexible learning programs” (FLPs) able to both effectively and somewhat contradictorily support young people, while also having the potential to reproduce stigma and disadvantage, offering what they call a “hybrid place.”
Raywird, M. A. 1994. Alternative schools. The state of the art. Educational Leadership 52.1: 26–31.
Raywird argues that the most “authentic” alternative education is that which offers a full time and permanent education option to anyone taking an alternative route to mainstream schooling. She also recognizes that some alternative provisions are designed to cater to young people who were not coping well in mainstream settings. She divides this group of provision into “quick fix” provision and those that incorporate a more “holistic” approach.
Rix, J., and P. Twining. 2007. Talking about schools: Towards a typology for future education. Educational Research 48.4: 329–341.
In the United Kingdom, Rix and Twining propose a descriptive typology defined by answering a set of key questions related to who the provision is for, where it is, what it entails, when it occurs in relation to mainstream school timetabling, and why and how the provision takes place, alongside a consideration of the type of school/ program. Their second preferred typology attempts to further acknowledge the provision’s purpose.
Te Riele, K. 2007. Educational alternatives for marginalised youth. The Australian Educational Researcher 34.3: 53–68.
Te Riele suggests programs should be differentiated by whether they have a youth at risk or learning choice focus. She divides alternative programs into four quadrants according to the provision purpose, its target population, its educational content, and expected outcomes and related credentials. This model has been used by an Australian private sector educational charity and as a basis for developing a national mapping of alternative education programs.
Thomson, P., and J. Pennacchia. 2016. Disciplinary regimes of “care” and complementary alternative education. Critical Studies in Education 57.1: 84–99.
Drawing on Foucault as a theoretical frame, this paper looks in depth at two alternative education provisions in the United Kingdom taken from a national study on Alternative Education. The alternative education landscape is acknowledged as vast and diverse. The notion of “care” is often synonymous with alternative education. Three types of disciplinary regimes at work in schools include dominant performative reward and punishment, team-building, and therapeutic.
Thomson, P., and L. Russell. 2007. Mapping the provision of alternatives to school exclusion. York, UK: Joseph Rowntree Foundation.
Thomson and Russell take a programmatic approach to mapping alternative provision suggesting nine different programs defined via their nature. These include vocational, work skills, basic skills, life skills, activity based, environmental, art, therapeutic, work experience and academic.
Thomson, P., and L. Russell. 2009. Data data everywhere: But not the ones that count? Mapping the provision of alternatives to education. International Journal of Inclusive Education 13.4: 423–438.
Mapping alternative education across two English Local Authorities resulted in the identification of two main types of alternative provision to include “core” provision, where a young person is on roll and may attend full time; core providers take legal responsibility for the young person’s attendance and entitlement and commonly organize a package of programs and “specialist” provision where a young person undertakes a part-time program, usually incorporating work-related basic skills.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login.
- Academic Achievement
- Academic Audit for Universities
- Academic Freedom and Tenure in the United States
- Action Research in Education
- Adjuncts in Higher Education in the United States
- Administrator Preparation
- Advanced Placement and International Baccalaureate Courses
- Advocacy and Activism in Early Childhood
- African American Racial Identity and Learning
- Alaska Native Education
- Alternative Certification Programs for Educators
- Alternative Schools
- American Indian Education
- Art Education
- Artificial Intelligence and Learning
- Assessing School Leader Effectiveness
- Assessment, Behavioral
- Assessment, Educational
- Assessment in Early Childhood Education
- Assistive Technology
- Augmented Reality in Education
- Beginning-Teacher Induction
- Bilingual Education and Bilingualism
- Blended Learning
- Case Study in Education Research
- Changing Professional and Academic Identities
- Character Education
- Children’s and Young Adult Literature
- Children's Beliefs about Intelligence
- Children's Rights in Early Childhood Education
- Citizenship Education
- Civic and Social Engagement of Higher Education
- Classroom Learning Environments: Assessing and Investigati...
- Classroom Management
- Coherent Instructional Systems at the School and School Sy...
- College Admissions in the United States
- College Athletics in the United States
- Community Relations
- Comparative Education
- Computer-Assisted Language Learning
- Computer-Based Testing
- Conceptualizing, Measuring, and Evaluating Improvement Net...
- Continuous Improvement and "High Leverage" Educational Pro...
- Counseling in Schools
- Critical Approaches to Gender in Higher Education
- Critical Perspectives on Educational Innovation and Improv...
- Critical Race Theory
- Crossborder and Transnational Higher Education
- Cross-National Research on Continuous Improvement
- Cross-Sector Research on Continuous Learning and Improveme...
- Cultural Diversity in Early Childhood Education
- Culturally Responsive Leadership
- Culturally Responsive Pedagogies
- Culturally Responsive Teacher Education in the United Stat...
- Curriculum Design
- Data Collection in Educational Research
- Data-driven Decision Making in the United States
- Deaf Education
- Desegregation and Integration
- Design Thinking and the Learning Sciences: Theoretical, Pr...
- Development, Moral
- Dialogic Pedagogy
- Digital Age Teacher, The
- Digital Citizenship
- Digital Divides
- Distance Learning
- Distributed Leadership
- Doctoral Education and Training
- Early Childhood Education and Care (ECEC) in Denmark
- Early Childhood Education and Development in Mexico
- Early Childhood Education in Aotearoa New Zealand
- Early Childhood Education in Australia
- Early Childhood Education in China
- Early Childhood Education in Europe
- Early Childhood Education in Sub-Saharan Africa
- Early Childhood Education in Sweden
- Early Childhood Education Pedagogy
- Early Childhood Education Policy
- Early Childhood Education, The Arts in
- Early Childhood Mathematics
- Early Childhood Science
- Early Childhood Teacher Education
- Early Childhood Teachers in Aotearoa New Zealand
- Early Years Professionalism and Professionalization Polici...
- Economics of Education
- Education For Children with Autism
- Education for Sustainable Development
- Education Leadership, Empirical Perspectives in
- Education of Native Hawaiian Students
- Education Reform and School Change
- Educational Statistics for Longitudinal Research
- Educator Partnerships with Parents and Families with a Foc...
- Emotional and Behavioral Disorders
- Environmental and Science Education: Overlaps and Issues
- Epistemic Beliefs
- Equity and Improvement: Engaging Communities in Educationa...
- Equity, Ethnicity, Diversity, and Excellence in Education
- Ethical Research with Young Children
- Ethics and Education
- Ethics of Teaching
- Ethnic Studies
- Evidence-Based Communication Assessment and Intervention
- Family and Community Partnerships in Education
- Family Day Care
- Federal Government Programs and Issues
- Feminization of Labor in Academia
- Finance, Education
- Financial Aid
- Formative Assessment
- Future-Focused Education
- Gender and Achievement
- Gender and Alternative Education
- Gifted Education
- Global Mindedness and Global Citizenship Education
- Global University Rankings
- Governance, Education
- Grounded Theory
- Growth of Effective Mental Health Services in Schools in t...
- Higher Education and Globalization
- Higher Education and the Developing World
- Higher Education Faculty Characteristics and Trends in the...
- Higher Education Finance
- Higher Education Governance
- Higher Education Graduate Outcomes and Destinations
- Higher Education in Africa
- Higher Education in China
- Higher Education in Latin America
- Higher Education in the United States, Historical Evolutio...
- Higher Education, International Issues in
- Higher Education Management
- Higher Education Policy
- Higher Education Research
- Higher Education Student Assessment
- High-stakes Testing
- History of Early Childhood Education in the United States
- History of Education in the United States
- History of Technology Integration in Education
- Inclusion in Early Childhood: Difference, Disability, and ...
- Inclusive Education
- Indigenous Education in a Global Context
- Indigenous Learning Environments
- Indigenous Students in Higher Education in the United Stat...
- Infant and Toddler Pedagogy
- Inservice Teacher Education
- Integrating Art across the Curriculum
- Intensive Interventions for Children and Adolescents with ...
- International Perspectives on Academic Freedom
- Intersectionality and Education
- Knowledge Development in Early Childhood
- Leadership Development, Coaching and Feedback for
- Leadership in Early Childhood Education
- Leadership Training with an Emphasis on the United States
- Learning Analytics in Higher Education
- Learning Difficulties
- Learning, Lifelong
- Learning, Multimedia
- Learning Strategies
- Legal Matters and Education Law
- LGBT Youth in Schools
- Linguistic Diversity
- Linguistically Inclusive Pedagogy
- Literacy Development and Language Acquisition
- Literature Reviews
- Mathematics Identity
- Mathematics Instruction and Interventions for Students wit...
- Mathematics Teacher Education
- Measurement for Improvement in Education
- Measurement in Education in the United States
- Meta-Analysis and Research Synthesis in Education
- Methodological Approaches for Impact Evaluation in Educati...
- Methodologies for Conducting Education Research
- Mindfulness, Learning, and Education
- Mixed Methods Research
- Multiliteracies in Early Childhood Education
- Multiple Documents Literacy: Theory, Research, and Applica...
- Multivariate Research Methodology
- Museums, Education, and Curriculum
- Music Education
- Narrative Research in Education
- Native American Studies
- Numeracy Education
- One-to-One Technology in the K-12 Classroom
- Online Education
- Open Education
- Organizing for Continuous Improvement in Education
- Organizing Schools for the Inclusion of Students with Disa...
- Outdoor Play and Learning
- Outdoor Play and Learning in Early Childhood Education
- Pedagogical Leadership
- Pedagogy of Teacher Education, A
- Performance Objectives and Measurement
- Performance-based Research Assessment in Higher Education
- Performance-based Research Funding
- Phenomenology in Educational Research
- Philosophy of Education
- Physical Education
- Podcasts in Education
- Policy Context of United States Educational Innovation and...
- Politics of Education
- Portable Technology Use in Special Education Programs and ...
- Pre-Service Teacher Education
- Problem Solving
- Productivity and Higher Education
- Professional Development
- Professional Learning Communities
- Program Evaluation
- Programs and Services for Students with Emotional or Behav...
- Psychology Learning and Teaching
- Psychometric Issues in the Assessment of English Language ...
- Qualitative Data Analysis Techniques
- Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods Research Samp...
- Qualitative Research Design
- Quantitative Research Designs in Educational Research
- Race and Affirmative Action in Higher Education
- Reading Education
- Refugee and New Immigrant Learners
- Relational and Developmental Trauma and Schools
- Relational Pedagogies in Early Childhood Education
- Reliability in Educational Assessments
- Religion in Elementary and Secondary Education in the Unit...
- Researcher Development and Skills Training within the Cont...
- Research-Practice Partnerships in Education within the Uni...
- Response to Intervention
- Restorative Practices
- Scale and Sustainability of Education Innovation and Impro...
- Scaling Up Research-based Educational Practices
- School Accreditation
- School Choice
- School Culture
- School District Budgeting and Financial Management in the ...
- School Improvement through Inclusive Education
- School Reform
- Schools, Private and Independent
- School-Wide Positive Behavior Support
- Science Education
- Secondary to Postsecondary Transition Issues
- Self-Regulated Learning
- Self-Study of Teacher Education Practices
- Severe Disabilities
- Single Salary Schedule
- Single-sex Education
- Single-Subject Research Design
- Social Context of Education
- Social Justice
- Social Network Analysis
- Social Pedagogy
- Social Science and Education Research
- Social Studies Education
- Sociology of Education
- Standards-Based Education
- Statistical Assumptions
- Student Access, Equity, and Diversity in Higher Education
- Student Assignment Policy
- Student Engagement in Tertiary Education
- Student Learning, Development, Engagement, and Motivation ...
- Student Participation
- Student Voice in Teacher Development
- Sustainability Education in Early Childhood Education
- Sustainability in Early Childhood Education
- Sustainability in Higher Education
- Teacher Beliefs and Epistemologies
- Teacher Collaboration in School Improvement
- Teacher Evaluation and Teacher Effectiveness
- Teacher Preparation
- Teacher Training and Development
- Teacher Unions and Associations
- Teacher-Student Relationships
- Teaching Critical Thinking
- Technologies, Teaching, and Learning in Higher Education
- Technology Education in Early Childhood
- Technology, Educational
- Technology-based Assessment
- The Bologna Process
- The Regulation of Standards in Higher Education
- Theories of Educational Leadership
- Three Conceptions of Literacy: Media, Narrative, and Gamin...
- Tracking and Detracking
- Traditions of Quality Improvement in Education
- Transformative Learning
- Transitions in Early Childhood Education
- Tribally Controlled Colleges and Universities in the Unite...
- Understanding the Psycho-Social Dimensions of Schools and ...
- University Faculty Roles and Responsibilities in the Unite...
- Using Ethnography in Educational Research
- Value of Higher Education for Students and Other Stakehold...
- Virtual Learning Environments
- Vocational and Technical Education
- Wellness and Well-Being in Education
- Women's and Gender Studies
- Young Children and Spirituality
- Young Children's Learning Dispositions
- Young Children's Working Theories