Indefiniteness
- LAST REVIEWED: 30 August 2022
- LAST MODIFIED: 27 November 2013
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199772810-0102
- LAST REVIEWED: 30 August 2022
- LAST MODIFIED: 27 November 2013
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199772810-0102
Introduction
The philosophical work on definite and indefinite descriptions of the form “the N” and “a N” focuses on the logic of natural language. Definites and indefinites are sometimes treated as devices of reference and at other times associated with quantificational expressions. Along with quantificational noun phrases such as “every N” they receive a unified analysis as generalized quantifiers. Insights into the semantic properties of generalized quantifiers have led to productive lines of research on indefinites in existential contexts and indefinites under negation, including negative polarity items and negative concord items. Clearly, indefinites have referential features as well. Unlike true quantificational expressions, they serve as anchors for anaphoric pronouns in subsequent discourse, which motivates Discourse Representation theory as a dynamic extension of first-order logic. Their variable quantificational force is accounted for by the treatment of indefinites as variables, which depend on other quantifiers in the sentence. The observation that indefinites can scope out of scope islands such as embedded clauses gave rise to analyses in terms of choice functions. Finally, indefinites are frequently found in predicative contexts, which have led to analyses in terms of property denotations. Many analyses focus on one particular aspect of indefinites, or posit ambiguities between different types of denotations. However, the quantificational, referential, and predicative roles of indefinites can be reconciled in a type-shifting framework, which allows indefinites to live in different types. Besides singular indefinite articles, languages may also have plural indefinite articles. Interestingly, many languages do not grammaticalize indefinite articles and instead use bare plurals or bare singulars. In English, bare plurals are ontologically different from full indefinites in that they may refer to kinds, besides regular individuals. They also display a different scopal behavior, in that they take obligatory narrow scope with respect to other scope-bearing operators. In languages where we find them, bare singulars share these features. Typological variation raises a special interest in grammaticalization patterns over time. Indefinites have also drawn attention in the psycholinguistic literature in which their cognitive status and the relation of indefinites with bare nominals and definites in acquisition and processing has been investigated. All in all, the study of indefiniteness is relevant for philosophy of language, semantic theory, the syntax-semantics interface, language typology, historical linguistics, and psycholinguistics. Additional relevant references to indefinite descriptions and indefiniteness appear in the Oxford Bibliographies articles Definiteness, Anaphora, Negation, and Polarity.
Textbooks and General Overviews
The literature on indefiniteness in linguistics, logic, and philosophy of language is quite extensive. Hawkins 1978 focuses on descriptive features of indefinites in relation to definites. Haspelmath 1997 provides a large-scale typological overview of indefinite pronouns. De Swart 1998 is a textbook introduction to natural language semantics, which pays special attention to indefinites. Szabolcsi 2010 provides a survey of the literature on quantification, scope, and indefinites. Landman 2004 (cited under Type-Shifting Perspectives) and Dobrovie-Sorin and Beyssade 2012 offers in-depth book-length overviews of the descriptive and formal semantic features of indefinites. Recent encyclopedic and handbook articles discussing the role of indefinites in the linguistics, logical, and philosophical debates of the 20th and early 21st century include Abbott 2006, Ludlow 2011, and Heim 2012.
Abbott, Barbara. 2006. Definite and indefinite. In Encyclopedia of language and linguistics. 2d ed. Vol. 3. Edited by Keith Brown, 392–399. Oxford: Elsevier.
Concise overview of a range of characterizations of the definite/indefinite contrast that have been proposed in the literature. Contains many illustrative examples and puzzles and helpful definitions of terminology. Accessible to undergraduate students.
Dobrovie-Sorin, Carmen, and Claire Beyssade. 2012. Redefining indefinites. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer.
DOI: 10.1007/978-94-007-3002-1
English translation of the French Définir les indéfinis, published in 2004. Accessible, yet thorough overview of the logical, semantic, and linguistic literature on indefinites and bare singulars/plurals, dealing with scope, weak/strong interpretations, and genericity. Includes discussion of French indefinite mass nouns and plurals introduced by du/des.
Haspelmath, Martin. 1997. Indefinite pronouns. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.
Large-scale typological study on the form and meaning of indefinite pronouns in a wide range of languages that is widely cited in the literature. Groups special meanings such as specificity, polarity, and free choice in semantic maps, which provides insight into the distributional patterns of indefinites across languages.
Hawkins, John A. 1978. Definiteness and indefiniteness. Atlantic Highlands, NJ: Humanities Press.
Early work that describes a wide range of uses of definite and indefinite noun phrases in natural language grammar and defines many empirical puzzles that subsequent literature tries to account for. While the definite article signals inclusive reference to objects in the shared speaker-hearer set, the indefinite article refers exclusively.
Heim, Irene. 2012. Definiteness and indefiniteness. In Handbook of Semantics. Edited by Klaus von Heusinger, Claudia Maienborn, and Paul Portner, 996–1024. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Characterizes definites and indefinites as different in semantic type, uniqueness, and presuppositionality. Empirical issues addressed concern scope, genericity, and implicatures. Accessible to graduate students.
Ludlow, Peter. 2011. Descriptions. In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Edited by Edward N. Zalta.
Provides an in-depth overview of the role definite and indefinite descriptions have played in the philosophical literature of the 20th century. Discusses many puzzles that challenge the Russellian theory of definite descriptions but also includes their relation to indefinites. Accessible to graduate students.
de Swart, Henriëtte. 1998. Introduction to natural language semantics. Stanford, CA: Center for the Study of Language and Information.
Provides an accessible introduction to semantics for undergraduate students and readers with little or no background in logic. Chapters 4–6 and chapter 8 pay attention to indefinites in classical logic, Generalized Quantifier theory, and discourse theories. As a textbook, it includes exercises.
Szabolcsi, Anna. 2010. Quantification. Research Surveys in Linguistics. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Univ. Press.
Excellent reading for advanced undergraduate and graduate students looking for a thorough overview of the syntax-semantics interface literature on quantification, including generalized quantifier theory, scope, and indefinites.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login.
How to Subscribe
Oxford Bibliographies Online is available by subscription and perpetual access to institutions. For more information or to contact an Oxford Sales Representative click here.
Article
- Acceptability Judgments
- Acquisition, Second Language, and Bilingualism, Psycholin...
- Adpositions
- Affixation
- African Linguistics
- Afroasiatic Languages
- Agreement
- Algonquian Linguistics
- Altaic Languages
- Analogy in Language and Linguistics
- Anaphora
- Animal Communication
- Aphasia
- Applicatives
- Applied Linguistics, Critical
- Arawak Languages
- Argument Structure
- Artificial Languages
- Athabaskan Languages
- Australian Languages
- Austronesian Linguistics
- Auxiliaries
- Balkans, The Languages of the
- Baudouin de Courtenay, Jan
- Berber Languages and Linguistics
- Bilingualism and Multilingualism
- Biology of Language
- Blocking
- Borrowing, Structural
- Caddoan Languages
- Caucasian Languages
- Causatives
- Celtic Languages
- Celtic Mutations
- Chomsky, Noam
- Chumashan Languages
- Classifiers
- Clauses, Relative
- Clinical Linguistics
- Cognitive Linguistics
- Colonial Place Names
- Comparative Reconstruction in Linguistics
- Comparative-Historical Linguistics
- Complementation
- Complexity, Linguistic
- Compositionality
- Compounding
- Computational Linguistics
- Conditionals
- Conjunctions
- Connectionism
- Consonant Epenthesis
- Contrastive Analysis in Linguistics
- Conversation Analysis
- Conversation, Maxims of
- Conversational Implicature
- Cooperative Principle
- Coordination
- Copula
- Creoles
- Creoles, Grammatical Categories in
- Critical Periods
- Cross-Language Speech Perception and Production
- Cyberpragmatics
- Default Semantics
- Definiteness
- Dementia and Language
- Dené-Yeniseian Hypothesis, The
- Dependencies
- Dependencies, Long Distance
- Derivational Morphology
- Determiners
- Dialectology
- Dialogue
- Diglossia
- Disfluency
- Distinctive Features
- Dravidian Languages
- Ellipsis
- Endangered Languages
- English as a Lingua Franca
- English, Early Modern
- English, Old
- Ergativity
- Eskimo-Aleut
- Euphemisms and Dysphemisms
- Evidentials
- Exemplar-Based Models in Linguistics
- Existential
- Existential Wh-Constructions
- Experimental Linguistics
- Fieldwork
- Fieldwork, Sociolinguistic
- Finite State Languages
- First Language Attrition
- Formulaic Language
- Francoprovençal
- French Grammars
- Frisian
- Gabelentz, Georg von der
- Gender
- Genealogical Classification
- Generative Syntax
- Genetics and Language
- Gestures
- Grammar, Categorial
- Grammar, Construction
- Grammar, Descriptive
- Grammar, Functional Discourse
- Grammars, Phrase Structure
- Grammaticalization
- Harris, Zellig
- Heritage Languages
- History of Linguistics
- History of the English Language
- Hmong-Mien Languages
- Hokan Languages
- Honorifics
- Humor in Language
- Hungarian Vowel Harmony
- Iconicity
- Ideophones
- Idiolect
- Idiom and Phraseology
- Imperatives
- Indefiniteness
- Indo-European Etymology
- Inflected Infinitives
- Information Structure
- Innateness
- Interface Between Phonology and Phonetics
- Interjections
- Intonation
- IPA
- Irony
- Iroquoian Languages
- Islands
- Isolates, Language
- Jakobson, Roman
- Japanese Word Accent
- Jones, Daniel
- Juncture and Boundary
- Khoisan Languages
- Kiowa-Tanoan Languages
- Kra-Dai Languages
- Labov, William
- Language Acquisition
- Language and Law
- Language Contact
- Language Documentation
- Language, Embodiment and
- Language for Specific Purposes/Specialized Communication
- Language, Gender, and Sexuality
- Language Geography
- Language Ideologies and Language Attitudes
- Language in Autism Spectrum Disorders
- Language Nests
- Language Revitalization
- Language Shift
- Language Standardization
- Languages of Africa
- Languages of the Americas, Indigenous
- Languages of the World
- Learnability
- Lexemes
- Lexical Access, Cognitive Mechanisms for
- Lexical Semantics
- Lexical-Functional Grammar
- Lexicography
- Lexicography, Bilingual
- Linguistic Accommodation
- Linguistic Anthropology
- Linguistic Areas
- Linguistic Landscapes
- Linguistic Prescriptivism
- Linguistic Profiling and Language-Based Discrimination
- Linguistic Relativity
- Linguistics, Educational
- Listening, Second Language
- Literature and Linguistics
- Loanwords
- Machine Translation
- Maintenance, Language
- Mande Languages
- Markedness
- Mass-Count Distinction
- Mathematical Linguistics
- Mayan Languages
- Mental Health Disorders, Language in
- Mental Lexicon, The
- Mesoamerican Languages
- Metaphor
- Metathesis
- Metonymy
- Minority Languages
- Mixed Languages
- Mixe-Zoquean Languages
- Modification
- Mon-Khmer Languages
- Morphological Change
- Morphology
- Morphology, Blending in
- Morphology, Subtractive
- Movement
- Munda Languages
- Muskogean Languages
- Nasals and Nasalization
- Negation
- Niger-Congo Languages
- Non-Pama-Nyungan Languages
- Northeast Caucasian Languages
- Nostratic
- Number
- Numerals
- Oceanic Languages
- Papuan Languages
- Penutian Languages
- Philosophy of Language
- Phonetics
- Phonetics, Acoustic
- Phonetics, Articulatory
- Phonological Research, Psycholinguistic Methodology in
- Phonology
- Phonology, Computational
- Phonology, Early Child
- Pidgins
- Polarity
- Policy and Planning, Language
- Politeness in Language
- Polysemy
- Possessives, Acquisition of
- Pragmatics, Acquisition of
- Pragmatics, Cognitive
- Pragmatics, Computational
- Pragmatics, Experimental
- Pragmatics, Game Theory in
- Pragmatics, Historical
- Pragmatics, Second Language
- Prague Linguistic Circle, The
- Presupposition
- Pronouns
- Psycholinguistics
- Quechuan and Aymaran Languages
- Questions
- Reading, Second-Language
- Reciprocals
- Reduplication
- Reflexives and Reflexivity
- Register and Register Variation
- Relevance Theory
- Salish Languages
- Saussure, Ferdinand de
- Second Language Acquisition, Anaphora Resolution in
- Semantic Maps
- Semantic Roles
- Semantic-Pragmatic Change
- Semantics, Cognitive
- Sentence Processing in Monolingual and Bilingual Speakers
- Sign Language Linguistics
- Sociolinguistics
- Sociolinguistics, Variationist
- Sonority
- Sound Change
- South American Indian Languages
- Specific Language Impairment
- Speech Perception
- Speech Production
- Speech Synthesis
- Suppletion
- Switch-Reference
- Syllables
- Syncretism
- Synonymy
- Syntactic Change
- Syntactic Knowledge, Children’s Acquisition of
- Tense, Aspect, and Mood
- Text Mining
- Tone
- Tone Sandhi
- Topic
- Transcription
- Transitivity and Voice
- Translation
- Trubetzkoy, Nikolai
- Tucanoan Languages
- Tupian Languages
- Typology
- Usage-Based Linguistics
- Uto-Aztecan Languages
- Valency Theory
- Verbs, Serial
- Visual Word Recognition
- Vocabulary, Second Language
- Voice and Voice Quality
- Vowel Harmony
- Whitney, William Dwight
- Word Classes
- Word Formation in Japanese
- Word Stress
- Writing, Second Language
- Writing Systems
- Yiddish
- Zapotecan Languages