Military Justice, the Anglo-American Tradition
- LAST REVIEWED: 19 July 2023
- LAST MODIFIED: 06 February 2012
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199791279-0045
- LAST REVIEWED: 19 July 2023
- LAST MODIFIED: 06 February 2012
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199791279-0045
Introduction
Armed forces rely upon good discipline and willing obedience to orders from service members to meet operational requirements and run the organization within a hierarchical structure of ranks and responsibilities. The system of rules and regulations that soldiers must follow is different from normal civilian life. To enforce expected behavior, most militaries maintain their own internal disciplinary codes for the administration of military justice; that is, justice peculiar to the armed forces and its members. The military is accorded certain authority and powers to try and to punish offending individuals. The most frequent means is summarily, by immediate superiors in a quasijudicial fashion, for service offenses less serious in nature; more formally, courts-martial composed of military judges, and, when necessary, panels of military members convene for civilian criminal and more serious military-related service offenses. Both forms are rooted in historical traditions and norms in respective armed forces, tempered by parallel developments in civilian jurisprudence, in which military justice generally lags. Today, decisions from courts-martial may be subject to appeal to higher courts on the basis of legality of finding and appropriateness of sentence, and in some countries harsher penalties, such as death, are rarely handed out or are expressly disallowed in the scale of punishments. It was not always so. Military justice, particularly in the field, closer to battle, could often be swift and arbitrary and have dear consequences for those individuals deemed to have contravened military authority and regulations. Military trials are part theater, to demonstrate military authority, and part enforcement of discipline and good behavior, for the sake of larger units and bodies of troops in a military context. Military justice encourages all members of armed forces to act in a predictable manner, in accordance with known rules, during the conduct of military operations and extends as well to those on the opposing side who might transgress accepted conventions and codes of conduct recognized by a group of nations engaged in armed conflict. War crimes, therefore, come under the purview of military justice when national military courts are involved. Military justice is still evolving as a serious field of legal jurisprudence in terms of legitimacy, mechanics of form, balancing of the unique needs and function of the armed forces in relation to society, and fairness to the individual, who, in most Western militaries at least, is a volunteer and chooses to serve the country.
General
Because each nation has different laws and traditions, it is hard to make generalizations about military justice applicable to all, though commonalities certainly exist. Each armed forces is unique in character, and even within those, individual service environments may have distinct attitudes and methods in regard to the maintenance of discipline. The historical trend has been toward greater uniformity across armed forces and closer mirroring of civilian criminal jurisprudence, in response to societal change. Reform of military law periodically becomes an issue when it falls too far behind or when some particular event happens that shakes public confidence in the military. Sherrill 1970 notes the practical nature of military justice as a separate form of legal jurisprudence that serves the particular needs of militaries in being operationally effective. Bishop 1974 describes the public pressure that can build when doubts are raised about militaries that have not performed according to expectations and the disappointment in the administration of military justice. Many writers are critical of military justice, premised either on the need for improvement or on the backwardness and supposed conservatism of military institutions. Other writers focus on the general aim and mechanics of military justice (for our purposes here, as practiced in the United States; other nations have similar how-to works). Davidson 1999 provides a basic guide to the practice of military criminal law geared toward a predominantly nonlegal audience, especially those either in or entering the military profession. Morris 2010 meets a similar need and, in focus and content, reflects the broader interpretation given to military justice today compared with earlier decades. Military justice, or rather military legality, touches upon many operational matters of interest to militaries, because the requirement for discipline and good behavior in the military context cannot be divorced from the core mandate of armed forces. Historical treatment of military justice is still catching up to this broader focus and to changes to military law itself. It is a very specialized field that requires some knowledge of the law and how it has been practiced in armed forces over time. In the early 21st century, good overviews focused on the history are yet to be written.
Bishop, Joseph W., Jr. Justice under Fire: A Study of Military Law. New York: Charterhouse, 1974.
NNNThe state of military justice in the US armed services post-Vietnam, by a knowledgeable military law writer.
Davidson, Michael J. A Guide to Military Criminal Law. Annapolis, MD: Naval Institute, 1999.
NNNA practical reference meant for the lay person, not practicing military lawyers. A good primer and introduction to the subject, from an American perspective.
Morris, Lawrence J. Military Justice: A Guide to the Issues. Contemporary Military, Strategic, and Security Issues. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger, 2010.
NNNNotwithstanding the different subtitle on the cover (A Reference Handbook), this book provides a good general overview, in plain language, of the purpose of military justice in the American context, backed up with ample historical illustrations. The basics are well described in the middle chapters.
Sherrill, Robert. Military Justice Is to Justice as Military Music Is to Music. New York: Harper and Row, 1970.
NNNTitle borrows from the French prime minister Georges Clemenceau’s famous twist of phrase for describing the different character of military justice. This older book, though now dated in many regards, still offers background and some interesting general statements on military justice in a pleasing manner and without too many encumbering references.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login.
How to Subscribe
Oxford Bibliographies Online is available by subscription and perpetual access to institutions. For more information or to contact an Oxford Sales Representative click here.
Article
- 1916 Easter Rising, The
- 1812, War of
- Aerial Bombardment, Ethics of
- Afghanistan, Wars in
- Africa, Gunpowder and Colonial Campaigns in
- African Wars of Independence
- Air Transport
- Allenby, Edmund
- All-Volunteer Army, Post-Vietnam Through 2016
- American Colonial Wars
- American Indian Wars
- American War of Independence
- Animals and the Military
- Antietam, Battle of
- Arab-Israeli Wars, 1948-Present
- Arctic Warfare
- Armed Forces of the Ottoman Empire, 1683–1918
- Armored War
- Arms Control and Disarmament
- Army, Roman
- Artillery
- Artists and War Art
- Assyrian Warfare
- Australia from the Colonial Era to the Present
- Austrian Succession, War of the
- Austro-Hungarian Armed Forces
- Balkan Liberation, 1878–1913, Wars of
- Battle of Plassey, 1757
- Battle of Route Coloniale 4, 1950: France’s first devastat...
- Battle of Salamis: 480 BC
- Boer Wars
- Bonaparte, Napoleon
- Brazilian Armed Forces
- Britain and the Blitz
- British Armed Forces, from the Glorious Revolution to Pres...
- British Army in World War II
- British Army of the Rhine, The
- British-India Armies from 1740 to 1849
- Canada from World War I to the Present
- Canada through World War I
- Cavalry since 1500
- Chaco War
- Charlemagne
- China's Modern Wars, 1911-1979
- Chinese Civil War, 1945-1949
- Chivalry
- Christianity and Warfare in the Medieval West
- Churchill, John, 1st Duke of Marlborough
- Churchill, Winston
- Civilians
- Clausewitz, Carl von
- Coalition and Alliance War
- Cold War, 1945-1990
- Commemoration
- Communications, French Revolution to Present
- Conflict and Migration
- Conquest of Mexico and Peru
- Conscription
- Cornwallis, Charles
- Counterinsurgency in the Modern World
- Crimean War, 1853–1856
- Cromwell, Oliver
- Crusades, The
- Cuban Missile Crisis
- Defense Industries
- Dien Bien Phu, Battle of
- Dominion Armies in World War II
- Douhet, Giulio, airpower theorist
- Eisenhower, Dwight
- Ethnic Cleansing and Genocide
- European Wars, Mid-Nineteenth-Century
- Finland in World War II
- Frederick the Great
- French Armies, Early Modern
- French Military, 1919-1940
- French Revolutionary Wars, The
- Gender Issues
- German Air Forces
- German Army, 1871–1945
- German Sea Power, 1848-1918
- German Unification, Wars of
- Germany's Eastern Front in 1941
- Grant, Ulysses S.
- Guerrilla Warfare, Pre-20th-Century
- Haig, Douglas
- Hippolyte, Comte de Guibert, Jacques Antoine
- Hiroshima/Nagasaki
- History of Intelligence in China
- Hundred Days Campaign of 1918
- Hundred Years War
- Hungary, Warfare in Medieval and Early Modern
- Imperial China, War in
- India 'Mutiny' and 'Revolution,' 1857-1858
- Indian Army in World War I
- Indian Warfare, Ancient
- India-Pakistan Wars
- Indochina Wars, 1946-1975
- Information Warfare
- Intelligence, Military
- International Efforts to Control War
- Iraq Wars, 1980s-Present
- Irish Civil War, 1922–1923
- Irish Revolution, 1911-1923, The
- Italian Armed Forces in the Modern Age
- Italian Campaign, World War I
- Japanese Army in the World War II Era, The Imperial
- Japanese Navy
- Jomini, Antoine-Henri
- Justice, Military, the Anglo-American Tradition
- Justice of War and Justice in War
- Khan, Genghis
- Kursk, Battle of
- Learning and Adapting: The British Army from Somme to the ...
- Lee, Robert E.
- Lepizig, Battle of
- Literature and Drama, War in
- Loos, Battle of
- Louis XIV, Wars of
- Low-Intensity Operations
- Manzikert, Battle of
- Maratha Navy Maratha Navy
- Media
- Medicine, Military
- Medieval Japan, 900-1600
- Mercenaries
- Meuse-Argonne Offensive
- Mexico and the United States, 1836–1848, Wars of
- Midway, Battle of
- Militarism
- Military Officers, United States
- Military Revolutions
- Militia
- Modern Piracy
- Mongol Wars
- Montgomery, Bernard Law
- Music and War
- Napoleonic Wars, The
- Napoleonic Wars, War and Memory in the
- NATO
- Navy, British
- Nelson, Horatio
- New Zealand
- Nimitz, Chester
- Nuclear Culture
- Nuclear Weapons
- Occupations and Military Government
- Operational Art
- Ottoman Navy
- Pacifism
- Passchaendale, Battle of
- Patton, George
- Peacekeeping
- Peninsular War
- Polish Armed Forces, 1918-present
- Political Purges in the 20th Century
- Poltava, Battle of
- Popular Culture and Modern War
- Prehistoric Warfare
- Prince Eugene of Savoy
- Prisoners
- Propaganda
- Psychiatric Casualties
- Race in the US Military
- Red Cross
- Religio-Military Orders
- Revolt in the Spanish Netherlands: 1561–1609 (Dutch Revolt...
- Roman Empire
- Roman Republic
- Roses, Wars of the
- Russian and Soviet Armed Forces
- Russian Campaign of 1812
- Russian Civil War, 1918-1921
- Russian Military History
- Russian Military History, 1762-1825
- Russo-Japanese War
- Safavid Army
- Sailing Warships
- Science and Technology in War
- Science Fiction, Military
- Semi-Military and Paramilitary Organizations
- Seven Years' War
- Seven Years' War in North America, The
- Sino-Japanese Wars, 1895-1945
- South Africa's Apartheid Wars
- South West Pacific, 1941–1945, Campaigns in
- Southeast Asian Military History, Colonial
- Southeast Asian Military History, Precolonial
- Space and War
- Spain since the Reconquista
- Spanish Civil War
- Special Operations Forces
- Special Operations Forces
- Stalingrad, Battle of
- Steppe Nomadic Warfare
- Strategy
- Submarine Warfare
- Swedish Armed Forces
- Tactics
- Terrorism
- Tet Offensive
- The Allied Bombardment of Occupied Europe During World War...
- The United States and the Middle East, 1945-2001
- Thirty Years War, 1618–1648
- Trench Warfare
- United States Marine Corps, The
- Urban Warfare
- US Air Force
- US Air Power
- US Army
- Verdun, Battle of
- Victorian Warfare, 1837–1902
- Vietnam War
- Vietnam War in Hollywood Feature Films
- War, Chemical and Biological
- War Correspondents
- War, Culture of
- War in Mughal India
- War of the Spanish Succession, 1701–1714
- Warfare, Precolonial, in Africa
- Warships, Steam
- Women in the Military
- World War I in Film
- World War I Origins
- World War I: The Eastern Front
- World War I: The Western Front
- World War II and the Far East
- World War II in Film
- World War II in the Mediterranean and Middle East
- World War II, Indian Army in
- World War II Origins
- World War II, Russo-German War
- Yugoslavian Civil War, 1991-1999
- Zhukov, Georgii
- Zulu Wars