Whiteness
- LAST REVIEWED: 29 September 2014
- LAST MODIFIED: 29 September 2014
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199791286-0125
- LAST REVIEWED: 29 September 2014
- LAST MODIFIED: 29 September 2014
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199791286-0125
Introduction
Notions of whiteness as race and ethnicity have existed in intellectual and political discourses since at least the start of the European and American slave trade, perhaps most explicitly in the constitutional and scientific embrace and resistance to the Eugenics movement in the early 20th century. Whiteness studies as an established field of academic inquiry came into focus in the late 1980s during the height of US neo-conservatism, and it surged in the 1990s. Evolving in part from the writings of such key intellectuals as Franz Fanon and Edward Said, whiteness studies began to focus on three areas: 1) whiteness as race, 2) race outside of “nature” and thus in the context of social history, and 3) the applicability of critical paradigms used to investigate question of whiteness. These areas remain important topics among whiteness studies scholars working across a wide range of disciplines today: from labor and legal studies to feminism and sexuality studies to literary and film studies. The field of whiteness studies is as diverse in method and theoretical orientation as the racial formation it focuses on. Employing models from structuralism to post-structuralism, whiteness studies scholars have worked to illuminate the historical formation of meaning and attendant practices situated as being “invented” by early American Anglo-Saxon elites as a way of controlling labor, faith, and privilege, and maintaining power and privilege for those that pass as white. Whiteness studies scholars have worked to shed light on this “invisible” power of whiteness. Hence, the impetus behind this work is political in the broadest sense: to expose the myriad intuitional and cultural mechanisms that perpetuate social injustice historically and today. Because of the amount and range of scholarship that arose in a relatively short period, the controversial nature of whiteness, and its increasing maturity as a field of scholarly inquiry, political intellectuals and scholars alike have criticized the work and the field itself. Political figures such as David Horowitz have situated whiteness studies as liberal bias, producing a popular backlash to the field, while other scholars have focused their criticism on the methodology and arguments, suggesting that whiteness studies lacks theoretical rigor and historical specificity. Some have even suggested that the field reifies whiteness as race in its attempt to deconstruct it. These myriad approaches to and arguments about whiteness studies have produced a rich and diverse body of scholarship, an important cross-section of which is represented in this bibliography.
Bibliographies and Reviews
Scholars have both situated whiteness studies as an emerging paradigm and scrutinized it, illuminating and challenging its methods, goals, and conclusions as they work to define its boundaries and limitations. A common critique of the discipline is that it reinforces the power of what it seeks to “de-center” by placing whites, as opposed to people of color, at the center of analysis. Bonnett 1996, Giroux 1997, Arnesen 2001, and Hartman 2004 discuss rhetorical problems in the field, while Warren 1999, Pruitt 2002, and MacMullan 2005 summarize various approaches with an emphasis on methodology. Of the bibliographies, Woll and Miller 1987 (cited under Gender and Ethnicity in Film and Television) catalogues entries on representational lines (e.g., the way whiteness is positioned in film and television), while Engles 2006 comprehensively catalogues virtually every extant critical whiteness book and article across multiple disciplines to include popular accounts and criticism.
Arnesen, Eric. “Whiteness and the Historians’ Imagination.” International Labor and Working Class History 60 (Fall 2001): 3–32.
Critical examination of working-class whiteness scholarship by labor historians such as David Rodiger, Noel Ignatiev, Matthew Frye Jacobson, Neil Foley, and Karen Brodkin. Argues that historians have “defined whiteness too loosely” and that “many of the assumptions, interpretive styles and techniques, and methodologies pursued by cultural historians of whiteness are highly problematic” (p. 25).
Bonnett, Alastair. “‘White Studies’: The Problems and Projects of a New Research Agenda.” Theory, Culture, and Society 13.2 (1996): 145–155.
DOI: 10.1177/026327696013002010
Looking at important works by David Roediger, Theodore Allen, and Ruth Frankenberg, among others, this article summarizes some crucial debates within whiteness studies during an important time in its development as a field of research and asserts some problems with the discipline, including its dominance by American scholars.
Engles, Tim, ed. Towards a Bibliography of Critical Whiteness Studies. Urbana: University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2006.
Interdisciplinary bibliography compiled by The Center on Democracy in a Multi-Racial Society at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.
Giroux, Henry. “Rewriting the Discourse of Racial Identity: Towards a Pedagogy and Politics of Whiteness.” Harvard Educational Review 67.2 (1997): 285–320.
Summarizes the rise of whiteness studies in the early 1990s and the conservative backlash to it. Also examines the problems that stem from the association of whiteness with domination and oppression. Giroux calls for a discourse that frames whiteness as a progressive identity in an effort to ensure “white” students have a stake in the fight against racism.
Hartman, A. “The Rise and Fall of Whiteness Studies.” Race and Class 46.2 (2004): 22–38.
Criticizes whiteness studies as being inherently limited by its failure to take into account class as a primary engine that has driven power relations throughout American history. Seems to sidestep the important work done on whiteness and class by Roediger, Ignatiev, and others.
MacMullan, Terrance. “Beyond the Pale: A Pragmatist Approach to Whiteness Studies.” Philosophy and Social Criticism 31.3 (May 2005): 267–292.
Summarizes two recent approaches in whiteness studies: eliminativists, who would abolish the idea of race altogether; and critical conservationists, who agree that race lacks a biological referent but nonetheless think that it is a useful cultural category for understanding the history of discrimination. Proposes a way to reconcile the two approaches so as to preserve values and eliminate flaws.
Pruitt, Christina. “The Complexions of ‘Race’ and the Rise of ‘Whiteness’ Studies.” Clio: A Journal of Literature History and the Philosophy of History 32.1 (Fall 2002): 27–50.
Reviews the canonical scholarship on whiteness, which in Pruitt’s estimation, moves beyond the initial step of simply identifying whiteness to suggest political strategies for the purpose of more “egalitarian social relations” (p. 50). Authors reviewed include Henry Louis Gates Jr., Toni Morrison, David Roediger, Mike Hill, and Howard Winant.
Warren, John. “Whiteness and Cultural Theory: Perspectives on Research and Education.” The Urban Review 31.2 (June 1999): 185–204.
Summarizes four different approaches within whiteness studies: social critique, textual analysis, discursive practice, and racial performance. Warren addresses what these approaches mean for education, and how “progressive educators” can use them to “continually mark the unmarked and question unearned racial privilege as the tool of the oppressor in a racist society” (p. 200).
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login.
How to Subscribe
Oxford Bibliographies Online is available by subscription and perpetual access to institutions. For more information or to contact an Oxford Sales Representative click here.
Article
- 8 ½
- 2001: A Space Odyssey
- À bout de souffle
- Accounting, Motion Picture
- Acting
- Action Cinema
- Adaptation
- Advertising and Promotion
- African American Cinema
- African American Stars
- African Cinema
- AIDS in Film and Television
- Akerman, Chantal
- Allen, Woody
- Almodóvar, Pedro
- Alphaville
- Altman, Robert
- American Cinema, 1895-1915
- American Cinema, 1939-1975
- American Cinema, 1976 to Present
- American Independent Cinema
- American Independent Cinema, Producers
- American Public Broadcasting
- Anderson, Wes
- Animals in Film and Media
- Animation and the Animated Film
- Anime
- Arbuckle, Roscoe
- Architecture and Cinema
- Argentine Cinema
- Aronofsky, Darren
- Art Cinema
- Arzner, Dorothy
- Asian American Cinema
- Asian Television
- Astaire, Fred and Rogers, Ginger
- Audiences and Moviegoing Cultures
- Australian Cinema
- Auteurism
- Authorship, Television
- Avant-Garde and Experimental Film
- Bachchan, Amitabh
- Battle of Algiers, The
- Battleship Potemkin, The
- Bazin, André
- Bergman, Ingmar
- Bernstein, Elmer
- Bertolucci, Bernardo
- Bigelow, Kathryn
- Biopics
- Birth of a Nation, The
- Blade Runner
- Blockbusters
- Bong, Joon Ho
- Brakhage, Stan
- Brando, Marlon
- Brazilian Cinema
- Breaking Bad
- Bresson, Robert
- British Cinema
- Broadcasting, Australian
- Buffy the Vampire Slayer
- Burnett, Charles
- Buñuel, Luis
- Cameron, James
- Campion, Jane
- Canadian Cinema
- Capra, Frank
- Carpenter, John
- Casablanca
- Cassavetes, John
- Cavell, Stanley
- Censorship
- Chahine, Youssef
- Chan, Jackie
- Chaplin, Charles
- Children in Film
- Chinese Cinema
- Cinecittà Studios
- Cinema and Media Industries, Creative Labor in
- Cinema and the Visual Arts
- Cinematography and Cinematographers
- Cinephilia
- Citizen Kane
- City in Film, The
- Cocteau, Jean
- Coen Brothers, The
- Colonial Educational Film
- Color
- Comedy, Film
- Comedy, Television
- Comics, Film, and Media
- Computer-Generated Imagery (CGI)
- Copland, Aaron
- Coppola, Francis Ford
- Copyright and Piracy
- Corman, Roger
- Costume and Fashion
- Cronenberg, David
- Cuban Cinema
- Cult Cinema
- 3D Cinema
- Dance and Film
- de Oliveira, Manoel
- Dean, James
- Deleuze, Gilles
- Denis, Claire
- Deren, Maya
- Design, Art, Set, and Production
- Detective Films
- Dietrich, Marlene
- Digital Media and Convergence Culture
- Directors
- Disability
- Disney, Walt
- Doctor Who
- Documentary Film
- Downton Abbey
- Dr. Strangelove
- Dreyer, Carl Theodor
- Eastern European Television
- Eastwood, Clint
- Ecocinema
- Ecocinema
- Eisenstein, Sergei
- Elfman, Danny
- Epic Film
- Essay Film
- Ethnographic Film
- European Television
- Exhibition and Distribution
- Exploitation Film
- Fairbanks, Douglas
- Fan Studies
- Fantasy
- Fellini, Federico
- Festivals
- Film Aesthetics
- Film and Literature
- Film Guilds and Unions
- Film, Historical
- Film Noir
- Film Preservation and Restoration
- Film Theory and Criticism, Science Fiction
- Film Theory Before 1945
- Film Theory, Psychoanalytic
- Finance Film, The
- Ford, John
- French Cinema
- Game of Thrones
- Gance, Abel
- Gangster Films
- Garbo, Greta
- Garland, Judy
- German Cinema
- Gilliam, Terry
- Global Television Industry
- Godard, Jean-Luc
- Godfather Trilogy, The
- Godzilla
- Golden Girls, The
- Greek Cinema
- Griffith, D.W.
- Hammett, Dashiell
- Haneke, Michael
- Hawks, Howard
- Haynes, Todd
- Hepburn, Katharine
- Herrmann, Bernard
- Herzog, Werner
- Hindi Cinema, Popular
- Hitchcock, Alfred
- Hollywood Studios
- Holocaust Cinema
- Homeland
- Hong Kong Cinema
- Horror-Comedy
- Hsiao-Hsien, Hou
- Hungarian Cinema
- Icelandic Cinema
- Immigration and Cinema
- Indigenous Media
- Industrial, Educational, and Instructional Television and ...
- Invasion of the Body Snatchers
- Iranian Cinema
- Irish Cinema
- Israeli Cinema
- It Happened One Night
- Italian Americans in Cinema and Media
- Italian Cinema
- Japanese Cinema
- Jazz Singer, The
- Jews in American Cinema and Media
- Keaton, Buster
- King Kong
- Kitano, Takeshi
- Korean Cinema
- Kracauer, Siegfried
- Kubrick, Stanley
- Lang, Fritz
- Latin American Cinema
- Latina/o Americans in Film and Television
- Lee, Ang
- Lee, Chang-dong
- Lee, Spike
- Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, and Queer (LGBTQ) Cin...
- Lord of the Rings Trilogy, The
- Los Angeles and Cinema
- Lubitsch, Ernst
- Lumet, Sidney
- Lupino, Ida
- Lynch, David
- Mad Men
- Marker, Chris
- Martel, Lucrecia
- Marxism
- Masculinity in Film
- Media, Community
- Media Ecology
- Melodrama
- Memory and the Flashback in Cinema
- Metz, Christian
- Mexican Cinema
- Micheaux, Oscar
- Ming-liang, Tsai
- Minnelli, Vincente
- Miyazaki, Hayao
- Méliès, Georges
- Modernism and Film
- Monroe, Marilyn
- Mészáros, Márta
- Music and Cinema, Classical Hollywood
- Music and Cinema, Global Practices
- Music, Television
- Music Video
- Musicals
- Musicals on Television
- Narrative
- Native Americans
- New Media Art
- New Media Policy
- New Media Theory
- New York City and Cinema
- New Zealand Cinema
- Opera and Film
- Ophuls, Max
- Orphan Films
- Oshima, Nagisa
- Ozu, Yasujiro
- Panh, Rithy
- Pasolini, Pier Paolo
- Passion of Joan of Arc, The
- Peckinpah, Sam
- Pedagogy
- Philosophy and Film
- Photography and Cinema
- Pickford, Mary
- Planet of the Apes
- Poems, Novels, and Plays About Film
- Poitier, Sidney
- Polanski, Roman
- Polish Cinema
- Politics, Hollywood and
- Pop, Blues, and Jazz in Film
- Pornography
- Postcolonial Theory in Film
- Potter, Sally
- Prime Time Drama
- Psycho
- Queer Television
- Queer Theory
- Race and Cinema
- Radio and Sound Studies
- Ray, Nicholas
- Ray, Satyajit
- Reality Television
- Reenactment in Cinema and Media
- Regulation, Television
- Religion and Film
- Remakes, Sequels and Prequels
- Renoir, Jean
- Repo Man
- Resnais, Alain
- Romanian Cinema
- Romantic Comedy, American
- Rossellini, Roberto
- Russian Cinema
- Saturday Night Live
- Scandinavian Cinema
- Scorsese, Martin
- Scott, Ridley
- Searchers, The
- Seinfeld
- Selznick, David O.
- Sennett, Mack
- Sesame Street
- Shakespeare on Film
- Silent Film
- Simpsons, The
- Singin' in the Rain
- Sirk, Douglas
- Slavic and Eastern European Cinema, Music and Sound in
- Soap Operas
- Social Class
- Social Media
- Social Problem Films
- Soderbergh, Steven
- Sound Design, Film
- Sound, Film
- Spanish Cinema
- Spanish-Language Television
- Spielberg, Steven
- Sports and Media
- Sports in Film
- Stand-Up Comedians
- Star Trek
- Star Wars
- Stardom
- Stop-Motion Animation
- Streaming Television
- Sturges, Preston
- Superhero Films
- Surrealism and Film
- Taiwanese Cinema
- Talk Shows
- Tarantino, Quentin
- Tarkovsky, Andrei
- Tati, Jacques
- Television Audiences
- Television Celebrity
- Television, History of
- Television Industry, American
- Theater and Film
- Theory, Cognitive Film
- Theory, Critical Media
- Theory, Feminist Film
- Theory, Film
- Theory, Trauma
- Touch of Evil
- Transnational and Diasporic Cinema
- Trinh, T. Minh-ha
- Truffaut, François
- Turkish Cinema
- Twilight Zone, The
- Twin Peaks
- Varda, Agnès
- Vertigo
- Vertov, Dziga
- Video and Computer Games
- Video Installation
- Violence and Cinema
- Virtual Reality
- Visconti, Luchino
- Von Sternberg, Josef
- Von Stroheim, Erich
- von Trier, Lars
- War Film
- Warhol, The Films of Andy
- Waters, John
- Wayne, John
- Weerasethakul, Apichatpong
- Weir, Peter
- Welles, Orson
- Wenders, Wim
- Whedon, Joss
- Whiteness
- Wilder, Billy
- Williams, John
- Wire, The
- Wiseman, Frederick
- Wizard of Oz, The
- Women and Film
- Women and the Silent Screen
- Wong, Anna May
- Wong, Kar-wai
- Woo, John
- Wood, Natalie
- Yang, Edward
- Yimou, Zhang
- YouTube
- Yugoslav and Post-Yugoslav Cinema
- Zinnemann, Fred
- Zombies in Cinema and Media