Relativism and Universalism of Human Rights and Regional Protection
- LAST REVIEWED: 24 February 2021
- LAST MODIFIED: 27 June 2017
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199796953-0153
- LAST REVIEWED: 24 February 2021
- LAST MODIFIED: 27 June 2017
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199796953-0153
Introduction
The international system of human rights is organized around both a universal and a regional system of protection. This article provides guidance on the universal and the regional level of human rights understood as a single system. This might appear as a problematic relation that raises philosophical puzzles with regard to how to reconcile rights protection of local practices under a universal framework of human rights. The difficulty consists of the following: if it is the case that there is a link between prescriptive relativism and regional human rights, then regional conventions must show how to reconcile context-specific protections with the rights enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR). This is not an easy relation to tame. Indeed, already in 1947, during the drafting of the UDHR, the American Anthropological Association observed that the document reflected values only of the Western world. Among UN members of that time, forty-eight states voted in favor, none voted against, and eight abstained (six from the Soviet bloc plus South Africa and Saudi Arabia). On 10 December 1948, with the General Assembly resolution 217A (III), UN Document A/810 at 71, the UDHR was adopted. The purpose of the UDHR was to set a springboard of inviolable rights in the wake of the Second World War. The UDHR was followed by the creation of several conventions and treaties safeguarding a number of specific areas, such as women’s rights, children, workers’ rights, and so on. The UDHR was shortly anticipated by the American Declaration of the Rights and Duties of Man (cited under Americas) (2 May 1948), a regional declaration with the purpose of strengthening solidarity within the Organization of American States (OAS). Furthermore, on the European front, in 1949 the Council of Europe was founded, and in 1950 it released the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). The first human rights treaty after the Second World War was of a regional scope. In addition to the regional protection, the recently introduced Universal Periodic Review system represents an innovative cooperative process among all 193 states and the Human Rights Council. From the genesis of the modern system of human rights protection presented earlier in this section, it follows that the international and the regional levels stand in a biunivocal relation, one where the American Declaration of the Rights and Duties of Man has influenced the UDHR and the latter has contributed to shaping the formulation of a regional convention as, primarily, the ECHR.
Introductory Works
For Nickel 2006, human rights are primarily the “rights of the lawyers” and not just “the rights of the philosophers.” Nevertheless, as James Nickel and many others recognize, human rights remain legitimate claims even when governments are not willing to recognize them. Churchill 2005 notices how this is due to the moral component of human rights and to its compatibility with cultural variety. Yet, as Goodale 2009 notices, the risk is always latent on superimposing a comprehensive, mostly Western, conception of human rights by use of apparent universal language. Is there the possibility of identifying intercultural overlapping categories? This is the question answered in Renteln 1990. Indeed, for some scholars, such as in Shelton and Carozza 2013, if the overlapping between universal and contextual legal conceptions is recognized, the tension between the international and the regional levels disappears.
Churchill, Robert Paul. Human Rights and Global Diversity. Basic Ethics in Action. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education, 2005.
This introductory work defends the idea of a compatibility between universal human rights norms and cultural and value pluralism. The book shows that there is no inherent contradiction between the universality of the interests protected by human rights and the worthiness of values negotiated by cultures.
Goodale, Mark. Surrendering to Utopia: An Anthropology of Human Rights. Stanford Studies in Human Rights. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2009.
This monograph is a significant criticism of the “neoliberal” approach to human rights conducted from an anthropological perspective. Neoliberalism is seen here as marking the end of the welfare state model, and human rights are manipulated for the sake of the privatization of public interest.
Nickel, James W. “Eight Responses to the Relativist.” In Making Sense of Human Rights. 2d ed. By James W. Nickel, 168–184. Oxford: Blackwell, 2006.
This is an excellently written introduction to the most-fundamental challenges that cultural relativism advances to human rights.
Renteln, Alison Dundes. International Human Rights: Universalism versus Relativism. Frontiers of Anthropology 6. Newbury Park, CA: SAGE, 1990.
Arguing from a social-anthropology perspective, the author claims that within cultural plurality it is still possible to determine cross-cultural category equivalents to rights. Indeed, cross-cultural investigation, when conducted on empirical bases, shows that there is widespread share of human rights standards.
Shelton, Dinah L., and Paolo G. Carozza. Regional Protection of Human Rights. 2d ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013.
This work represents the first comprehensive attempt to investigate the existing regional systems of human rights protection. Following legally sophisticated analysis, the book also considers the prospects of growth of new regional systems in the Middle East and Asia. Now in its second edition, it is still a valuable resource as a textbook for courses at the graduate and research levels.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login.
How to Subscribe
Oxford Bibliographies Online is available by subscription and perpetual access to institutions. For more information or to contact an Oxford Sales Representative click here.
Article
- Act of State Doctrine
- Africa and Intellectual Property Rights for Plant Varietie...
- African Approaches to International Law
- African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights and the Af...
- Africa’s International Intellectual Property Law Regimes
- Africa’s International Investment Law Regimes
- Agreements, Bilateral and Regional Trade
- Agreements, Multilateral Environmental
- Aliens
- Applicable Law in Investment Agreements
- Archipelagic States
- Arctic Region
- Armed Opposition Groups
- Aut Dedere Aut Judicare
- Balance of Power
- Bandung Conference, The
- British Mandate of Palestine and International Law, The
- Children's Rights
- Civil Service, International
- Civil-Military Relations
- Codification
- Cold War International Law
- Collective Security
- Command Responsibility
- Common Heritage of Mankind
- Complementarity Principle
- Compliance in International Law
- Conspiracy/Joint Criminal Enterprise
- Constitutional Law, International
- Consular Relations
- Contemporary Catholic Approaches
- Continental Shelf, Idea and Limits of the
- Cooperation in Criminal Matters, Cross-Border
- Countermeasures
- Courts, International
- Crimes against Humanity
- Criminal Law, International
- Cultural Rights
- Cyber Espionage
- Cyber Warfare
- Debt, Sovereign
- Decolonization in International Law
- Democracy
- Development Law, International
- Disarmament in International Law
- Discrimination
- Disputes, Peaceful Settlement of
- Drugs, International Regulation, and Criminal Liability
- Early 19th Century, 1789-1870
- Ecological Restoration and International Law
- Economic Law, International
- Effectiveness and Evolution in Treaty Interpretation
- Enforced Disappearances in International Law
- Enforcement of Human Rights
- Environmental Compliance Mechanisms
- Environmental Institutions, International
- Environmental Law, International
- Estoppel
- European Arrest Warrant
- Extraterritorial Application of Human Rights Treaties
- Fascism and International Law
- Feminist Approaches to International Law
- Financial Law, International
- Forceful Intervention for Protection of Human Rights in Af...
- Foreign Investment
- Fragmentation
- Freedom of Expression
- French Revolution
- Gender and International Law, Theoretical and Methodologic...
- Gender and International Security
- General Customary Law
- General Principles of Law
- Genocide
- Georgia and International Law
- Grotius, Hugo
- Habeas Corpus
- Hijaz and International Law, The
- History of International Law, 1550–1700
- Hostilities, Direct Participation in
- Human Rights
- Human Rights and Regional Protection, Relativism and Unive...
- Human Rights, European Court of
- Human Rights, Foundations of
- Human Trafficking
- Hybrid International Criminal Tribunals
- Immunities
- Immunity, Sovereign
- Indigenous Peoples
- Individual Criminal Responsibility
- Institutional Law
- Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) and Inte...
- International and Non-International Armed Conflict, Detent...
- International Committee of the Red Cross
- International Community
- International Court of Justice
- International Criminal Court, The
- International Criminal Law, Complicity in
- International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR)
- International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia ...
- International Fisheries Law
- International Humanitarian Law
- International Humanitarian Law, Targeting in
- International Investment Agreements, Fair and Equitable Tr...
- International Investment Arbitration
- International Investment Law, Expropriation in
- International Law, Aggression in
- International Law, Amnesty and
- International Law and Economic Development
- International Law, Anthropology and
- International Law, Big Data and
- International Law, Climate Change and
- International Law, Derogations and Reservations in
- International Law, Dispute Settlement in
- International Law, Ecofeminism and
- International Law, Espionage in
- International Law, Hegemony in
- International Law in Greek
- International Law in Italian
- International Law in Northeast Asia
- International Law in Portuguese
- International Law in Turkish
- International Law, Marxist Approaches to
- International Law, Military Intervention in
- International Law, Money Laundering in
- International Law, Monism and Dualism in
- International Law, Peacekeeping in
- International Law, Proportionality in
- International Law, Reasonableness in
- International Law, Recognition in
- International Law, Self-Determination in
- International Law, State Responsibility in
- International Law, State Succession in
- International Law, the State in
- International Law, The Turkish-Greek Population Exchange a...
- International Law, the Turn to History in
- International Law, Trade and Development in
- International Law, Unequal Treaties in
- International Law, Use of Force in
- International Regulation of the Internet
- International Rule of Law, An
- International Territorial Administration
- International Trade and Human Rights
- Intervention, Humanitarian
- Investment Protection Treaties
- Investor-State Conciliation and Mediation
- Iran and International Law
- Iraq War, Britain and the
- Islamic Cooperation, International Law and the Organizatio...
- Islamic International Law
- Islamic Law and Human Rights
- Islands
- Jerusalem
- Jurisdiction
- Jurisprudence (Judicial Law-Making)
- Jus Cogens
- Just War
- Landlocked Countries and the Law of the Sea
- Law of the Sea
- Law of Treaties, The
- Law-Making by Non-State Actors
- League of Nations, The
- Lebanon, Special Tribunal for
- Legal Status of Military Forces Abroad
- Liability for International Environmental Harm
- Liberation and Resistance Movements
- Mandates in International Law
- Maritime Delimitation
- Martens Clause
- Medieval International Law
- Mens Rea, International Crimes
- Middle East Boundaries and State Formation
- Migration
- Military Necessity
- Military Occupation
- Minorities
- Modes of Participation
- Most-Favored-Nation Clauses
- Multinational Corporations in International Law
- Nationality and Statelessness
- Natural Law
- Neutrality
- New Approaches to International Law
- New Haven School of International Law, The
- Non liquet
- Noninternational Armed Conflict (“Civil War”)
- Nonstate Actors
- Nuclear Non-Proliferation
- Nuremberg Trials
- Organizations, International
- Pacifism in International Law
- Palestine (and the Israel Question)
- Peace Treaties
- Piracy
- Political Science, International Law and
- Positivism
- Private Military and Security Companies
- Protection, Diplomatic
- Public Interest, Human Rights, and Foreign Investment
- Rational Choice Theory
- Recognition of Foreign Penal Judgments
- Refugees
- Rendition, Extraterritorial Abduction, and Extraordinary R...
- Reparations
- Russian Approaches to International Law
- Sanctions, International
- Sanctions, International
- Secession
- Self-Defense
- Slavery
- Soft Law
- Space Law
- Spanish School of International Law (c. 16th and 17th Cent...
- Sports Law, International
- State of Necessity
- Superior Orders
- Taba Arbitration, The
- Teaching International Law
- Territorial Title
- Terrorism
- The 1948 Arab-Israeli Conflict and International Law
- The Ottoman Empire and International Law
- Theory, Critical International Legal
- Tibet
- Tokyo Trials, The
- Torture
- Transnational Constitutionalism, Africa and
- Transnational Corruption
- Treaty Interpretation
- Ukrainian Approaches
- UN Partition Plan for Palestine and International Law, The
- UN Security Council, Women and the
- Underwater Cultural Heritage
- Unilateral Acts
- United Nations and its Principal Organs, The
- Universal Jurisdiction
- Uti Possidetis Iuris
- Vatican and the Holy See
- Victims’ Rights, International Criminal Law, and Proceedin...
- War Crimes
- Watercourses, International
- Western Sahara