The Insanity Defense
- LAST MODIFIED: 25 July 2023
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199828340-0318
- LAST MODIFIED: 25 July 2023
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199828340-0318
Introduction
The insanity defense is a legal standard that deals with determining culpability for criminal acts. When met, it absolves the individual of a criminal act they committed, although they are typically mandated to a secure hospital for treatment. As defined in federal jurisdictions under 18 U.S.C. §17(a), insanity “is an affirmative defense under any Federal Statute that, at the time of the commission of the acts constituting the offense, the defendant as a result of severe mental disease or defect, was unable to appreciate the nature and quality or the wrongfulness of his acts.” The presence of a mental disease or defect is considered a threshold condition, meaning it first must be determined if a mental disease or defect exists, and then determined if that condition was severe enough to cause the individual to be unable to appreciate the wrongfulness of their acts. Some states have added a volitional component to their insanity defense. This prong deals with if an individual, as the result of a threshold condition, lacks the substantial capacity to conform their conduct to the law. However, it must be noted that the insanity defense is unpopular with many state legislatures. Four states (Idaho, Kansas, Montana, and Utah) have abolished the insanity defense. Forensic psychiatrists and psychologists are often tasked with conducting these retrospective evaluations. This is a difficult task, as it requires the forensic practitioner to reconstruct an individual’s mental state as it relates to the alleged criminal act days, months, or even years after the event. To conduct these evaluations properly often requires a substantial amount of collateral information, including previous mental health records, academic records, employment records, and, most recently, information gleaned from social media, that can assist the evaluator in the reconstruction of an individual’s mental state. This bibliography emphasizes the complexity of the insanity defense and its complicated and lengthy history. However, readers are encouraged to further explore articles and books to elucidate the lengthy legal history of the insanity defense and complexities in conducting insanity evaluations.
General Overviews
These overviews focus primarily on mental health issues and how the courts have handled, and in many respects failed to handle, them. Some cover broad aspects relative to mental illness and the law and incorporate specific aspects of the insanity defense. Erickson and Erickson 2008, a book on mental illness, focuses on the criminalization of the mentally ill, with a specific chapter (chapter 4) dedicated to the insanity defense. Likewise, Finkel 1988 discusses many of the controversies that accompany the insanity defense. In a different and unique take, Ewing 2008 provides examples from several high-profile cases that are highly informative for understanding the inner workings of the insanity defense. Slovenko 1995 provides an overview of the insanity defense and its many complications. It also provides information useful to the testifying clinician. Sadoff 1989 is a chapter underscoring the necessity of maintaining the insanity defense for fundamental fairness; it deals with misperceptions of the insanity defense.
Erickson, P. E., and S. K. Erickson. 2008. Crime, punishment, and mental illness: Law and the behavioral sciences in conflict. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers Univ. Press.
This book focuses on the problem of the criminalization of mental illness and how individuals with mental illness populate the penal system. This book has clear implications for the insanity defense, and chapter 4 focuses on the conflict and difficulty of the insanity defense.
Ewing, C. P. 2008. Insanity: Murder, madness, and the law. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.
DOI: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195326130.001.0001
This book reviews ten cases of insanity that cover a variety of topics. These high-profile cases are highly informative for when considering how case law has developed and the implementation of the insanity defense on legal cases.
Finkel, N. J. 1988. Insanity on trial. New York: Plenum Press.
DOI: 10.1007/978-1-4613-1665-7
In this book, Finkel deals with many of the controversies of the insanity defense. He has chapters on specific issues and the book provides an overview of the insanity defense and its contentiousness.
Sadoff, R. L. 1989. In defense of the insanity defense. In Criminal court consultation. Critical Issues in American Psychiatry and the Law 5. Edited by R. Rosner and R. B. Harmon, 111–118. New York: Plenum Press.
Sadoff authored a chapter underscoring the necessity of maintaining the insanity defense for fundamental fairness, and dealing with misperceptions of the insanity defense.
Slovenko, R. 1995. Psychiatry and criminal culpability. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
The focus of this book is on the insanity defense and its complications. It also deals with assessments of criminal responsibility and culpability and the psychiatrist (and psychologist) as an expert witness.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login.
How to Subscribe
Oxford Bibliographies Online is available by subscription and perpetual access to institutions. For more information or to contact an Oxford Sales Representative click here.
Article
- Abnormal Psychology
- Academic Assessment
- Acculturation and Health
- Action Regulation Theory
- Action Research
- Addictive Behavior
- Adolescence
- Adoption, Social, Psychological, and Evolutionary Perspect...
- Adulthood
- Affective Forecasting
- Ageism
- Ageism at Work
- Aggression
- Allport, Gordon
- Alzheimer’s Disease
- Ambulatory Assessment in Behavioral Science
- Analysis of Covariance (ANCOVA)
- Anger
- Animal Behavior
- Animal Learning
- Anxiety Disorders
- Art and Aesthetics, Psychology of
- Assessment and Clinical Applications of Individual Differe...
- Attachment in Social and Emotional Development across the ...
- Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) in Adults
- Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) in Childre...
- Attitudes
- Attitudinal Ambivalence
- Attraction in Close Relationships
- Attribution Theory
- Authoritarian Personality
- Autism
- Bayesian Statistical Methods in Psychology
- Behavior Therapy, Rational Emotive
- Behavioral Economics
- Behavioral Genetics
- Belief Perseverance
- Bereavement and Grief
- Biological Psychology
- Birth Order
- Body Image in Men and Women
- Burnout
- Bystander Effect
- Categorical Data Analysis in Psychology
- Childhood and Adolescence, Peer Victimization and Bullying...
- Clinical Neuropsychology
- Clinical Psychology
- Cognitive Consistency Theories
- Cognitive Dissonance Theory
- Cognitive Neuroscience
- Communication, Nonverbal Cues and
- Comparative Psychology
- Competence to Stand Trial: Restoration Services
- Competency to Stand Trial
- Computational Psychology
- Conflict Management in the Workplace
- Conformity, Compliance, and Obedience
- Consciousness
- Coping Processes
- Correspondence Analysis in Psychology
- Counseling Psychology
- Courage
- Creativity
- Creativity at Work
- Critical Thinking
- Cross-Cultural Psychology
- Cultural Psychology
- Daily Life, Research Methods for Studying
- Data Science Methods for Psychology
- Data Sharing in Psychology
- Death and Dying
- Deceiving and Detecting Deceit
- Defensive Processes
- Depression
- Depressive Disorders
- Development, Prenatal
- Developmental Psychology (Cognitive)
- Developmental Psychology (Social)
- Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM...
- Discrimination
- Disgust
- Dissociative Disorders
- Drugs and Behavior
- Eating Disorders
- Ecological Psychology
- Educational Settings, Assessment of Thinking in
- Effect Size
- Embodiment and Embodied Cognition
- Emerging Adulthood
- Emotion
- Emotional Intelligence
- Empathy and Altruism
- Employee Stress and Well-Being
- Environmental Neuroscience and Environmental Psychology
- Ethics in Psychological Practice
- Event Perception
- Evolutionary Psychology
- Expansive Posture
- Experimental Existential Psychology
- Exploratory Data Analysis
- Eyewitness Testimony
- Eysenck, Hans
- Factor Analysis
- Festinger, Leon
- Five-Factor Model of Personality
- Flynn Effect, The
- Forensic Psychology
- Forgiveness
- Friendships, Children's
- Fundamental Attribution Error/Correspondence Bias
- Gambler's Fallacy
- Game Theory and Psychology
- Geropsychology, Clinical
- Global Mental Health
- Habit Formation and Behavior Change
- Happiness
- Health Psychology
- Health Psychology Research and Practice, Measurement in
- Heider, Fritz
- Heuristics and Biases
- History of Psychology
- Human Factors
- Humanistic Psychology
- Humor
- Hypnosis
- Implicit Association Test (IAT)
- Industrial and Organizational Psychology
- Inferential Statistics in Psychology
- Insanity Defense, The
- Intelligence
- Intelligence, Crystallized and Fluid
- Intercultural Psychology
- Intergroup Conflict
- International Classification of Diseases and Related Healt...
- International Psychology
- Interviewing in Forensic Settings
- Intimate Partner Violence, Psychological Perspectives on
- Introversion–Extraversion
- Item Response Theory
- Kurtosis
- Language
- Laughter
- Law, Psychology and
- Lazarus, Richard
- Leadership
- Learned Helplessness
- Learning Theory
- Learning versus Performance
- LGBTQ+ Romantic Relationships
- Lie Detection in a Forensic Context
- Life-Span Development
- Lineups
- Locus of Control
- Loneliness and Health
- Mathematical Psychology
- Meaning in Life
- Mechanisms and Processes of Peer Contagion
- Media Violence, Psychological Perspectives on
- Mediation Analysis
- Meditation
- Memories, Autobiographical
- Memories, Flashbulb
- Memories, Repressed and Recovered
- Memory, False
- Memory, Human
- Memory, Implicit versus Explicit
- Memory in Educational Settings
- Memory, Semantic
- Meta-Analysis
- Metacognition
- Metamemory
- Metaphor, Psychological Perspectives on
- Microaggressions
- Military Psychology
- Mindfulness
- Mindfulness and Education
- Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI)
- Money, Psychology of
- Moral Conviction
- Moral Development
- Moral Psychology
- Moral Reasoning
- Motivation
- Music
- Narcissism
- Narrative
- Nature versus Nurture Debate in Psychology
- Neuroscience of Associative Learning
- Nonergodicity in Psychology and Neuroscience
- Nonparametric Statistical Analysis in Psychology
- Observational (Non-Randomized) Studies
- Obsessive-Complusive Disorder (OCD)
- Occupational Health Psychology
- Olfaction, Human
- Operant Conditioning
- Optimism and Pessimism
- Organizational Justice
- Parenting Stress
- Parenting Styles
- Parents' Beliefs about Children
- Path Models
- Peace Psychology
- Perception
- Perception, Person
- Performance Appraisal
- Personality and Health
- Personality Disorders
- Personality Psychology
- Phenomenological Psychology
- Placebo Effects in Psychology
- Play Behavior
- Positive Psychological Capital (PsyCap)
- Positive Psychology
- Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
- Prejudice and Stereotyping
- Pretrial Publicity
- Prisoner's Dilemma
- Problem Solving and Decision Making
- Procrastination
- Prosocial Behavior
- Prosocial Spending and Well-Being
- Protocol Analysis
- Psycholinguistics
- Psychological Literacy
- Psychological Perspectives on Food and Eating
- Psychology, Political
- Psychoneuroimmunology
- Psychophysics, Visual
- Psychotherapy
- Psychotic Disorders
- Publication Bias in Psychology
- Race
- Reasoning, Counterfactual
- Rehabilitation Psychology
- Relationships
- Reliability–Contemporary Psychometric Conceptions
- Religion, Psychology and
- Replication Initiatives in Psychology
- Research Methods
- Resilience
- Risk Taking
- Role of the Expert Witness in Forensic Psychology, The
- Rumination
- Sample Size Planning for Statistical Power and Accurate Es...
- Savoring
- Schizophrenic Disorders
- School Psychology
- School Psychology, Counseling Services in
- Self, Gender and
- Self, Psychology of the
- Self-Construal
- Self-Control
- Self-Deception
- Self-Determination Theory
- Self-Efficacy
- Self-Esteem
- Self-Monitoring
- Self-Regulation in Educational Settings
- Self-Report Tests, Measures, and Inventories in Clinical P...
- Sensation Seeking
- Sex and Gender
- Sexual Minority Parenting
- Sexual Orientation
- Signal Detection Theory and its Applications
- Simpson's Paradox in Psychology
- Single People
- Single-Case Experimental Designs
- Skinner, B.F.
- Sleep and Dreaming
- Small Groups
- Social Class and Social Status
- Social Cognition
- Social Neuroscience
- Social Support
- Social Touch and Massage Therapy Research
- Somatoform Disorders
- Spatial Attention
- Sports Psychology
- Stanford Prison Experiment (SPE): Icon and Controversy
- Stereotype Threat
- Stereotypes
- Stress and Coping, Psychology of
- Student Success in College
- Subjective Wellbeing Homeostasis
- Suicide
- Taste, Psychological Perspectives on
- Teaching of Psychology
- Terror Management Theory
- Testing and Assessment
- The Concept of Validity in Psychological Assessment
- The Neuroscience of Emotion Regulation
- The Reasoned Action Approach and the Theories of Reasoned ...
- The Weapon Focus Effect in Eyewitness Memory
- Theory of Mind
- Therapies, Person-Centered
- Therapy, Cognitive-Behavioral
- Thinking Skills in Educational Settings
- Time Perception
- Trait Perspective
- Trauma Psychology
- Twin Studies
- Type A Behavior Pattern (Coronary Prone Personality)
- Unconscious Processes
- Video Games and Violent Content
- Virtues and Character Strengths
- Wisdom
- Women and Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math (STEM...
- Women, Psychology of
- Work Well-Being
- Wundt, Wilhelm