Overqualification
- LAST REVIEWED: 14 August 2024
- LAST MODIFIED: 07 January 2025
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199846740-0088
- LAST REVIEWED: 14 August 2024
- LAST MODIFIED: 07 January 2025
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199846740-0088
Introduction
Overqualification is a situation in which a person’s education, experience, and skills exceed job requirements. As a result, an overqualified person has a level of skills and/or qualifications not needed to obtain or perform their job. Overqualification is regarded as a subcategory of underemployment, which refers to subpar (or deficient) employment. However, the two terms are not synonymous, because underemployment includes other forms of undesirable employment such as being employed part-time on an involuntary basis, or being underpaid compared to one’s prior job. This review will focus primarily on overqualification and not the other forms of underemployment. This article reviews the literature on overqualification, highlights work that has shaped the field over time, and summarizes the literature by way of suggesting and emphasizing work on its antecedents, mediators, consequences, and moderators.
General Overviews
This section features reviews and articles that may be regarded as highly influential summaries and reviews of the field. Feldman 1996 presents a review and organizational framework for studies of underemployment. This paper presents five different dimensions of underemployment, two of which (overeducation and overexperience) are regarded as dimensions of overqualification. A follow up to this landmark review is McKee-Ryan and Harvey 2011, which takes stock of the underemployment literature and focuses on antecedents, consequences, future research directions, and measurement issues. Erdogan, et al. 2011 is a focal article in the journal Industrial and Organizational Psychology. The article presents a comprehensive overview of the literature on overqualification, focusing on measurement issues, antecedents, consequences, and moderators; it also emphasizes some potential advantages of hiring overqualified applicants. In the same issue of the aforementioned journal, readers may find commentaries related to the focal article and the responses of the authors to these commentaries, which highlight some dilemmas and unresolved issues. Erdogan and Bauer 2021 takes stock of the literature and offers a timely update to many of the issues identified in the focal article Erdogan, et al. 2011, while also offering a roadmap for future research. Finally, two meta-analyses offer quantitative reviews of the literature. Harari, et al. 2017 examines the bivariate relationships with antecedents and outcomes of overqualification, whereas Liao, et al. in press develops a model examining the relation between perceived overqualification and its outcomes, via motivation and capability-based mechanisms.
Erdogan, Berrin, and Talya N. Bauer. “Overqualification at Work: A Review and Synthesis of the Literature.” Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior 8 (2021): 259–283.
DOI: 10.1146/annurev-orgpsych-012420-055831
The paper reviews the overqualification literature up to 2020, focusing on antecedents, outcomes, moderators, and mediators. The review also ends with a comprehensive outline of future research directions.
Erdogan, Berrin, Talya N. Bauer, José M. Peiró, and Donald M. Truxillo. “Overqualified Employees: Making the Best of a Potentially Bad Situation for Individuals and Organizations.” Industrial and Organizational Psychology 4 (2011): 215–232.
DOI: 10.1111/j.1754-9434.2011.01330.x
This accessible introduction to the topic describes the phenomenon, reviews the research on its nomological network, discusses its potential advantages and disadvantages, and points to unresolved issues. In the same issue of the journal, there are nine commentaries on this article, as well as the authors’ responses to the commentaries.
Feldman, Daniel C. “The Nature, Antecedents and Consequences of Underemployment.” Journal of Management 22 (1996): 385–407.
DOI: 10.1177/014920639602200302
Overeducation, as well as being overskilled and overexperienced, are defined as dimensions of underemployment. In this theory piece, propositions about antecedents (economic factors, job characteristics, career history, demographics, job search strategies) and consequences (attitudes, well-being, and behaviors) were included. This article has been the basis of much subsequent work on overqualification.
Harari, Michael B., Archana Manapragada, and Chockalingam Viswesvaran. “Who Thinks They’re a Big Fish in a Small Pond and Why Does It Matter? A Meta-Analysis of Perceived Overqualification.” Journal of Vocational Behavior 102 (2017): 28–47.
DOI: 10.1016/j.jvb.2017.06.002
This is the first comprehensive meta-analysis of the literature and includes both antecedents and outcomes of overqualification. The analysis is based on sixty-one independent samples. Power distance was examined as a moderator. Correlations between objective and subjective measures were also reported. This is an important study for summarizing the literature up to 2016.
Liao, Meishi, Melody Jun Zhang, Joel B. Carnevale, Chengquan Huang, and Lin Wang. “Capable Fish or Deficient Ponds? A Meta-Analysis of Consequences, Mechanisms, and Moderators of Perceived Overqualification.” Journal of Management (2024).
DOI: 10.1177/01492063241239298
This is the second meta-analysis of the literature, focused on testing the mechanisms associated with positive and negative outcomes of overqualification. The authors test a model proposing that perceived overqualification has three potential types of effects on outcomes, via the pathways of “reason-to,” “energized-to,” and “can-do” motivational states. This is an important contribution that offers a theory-based explanation for the mixed effects observed on outcomes.
McKee-Ryan, Frances, and Jaron Harvey. “‘I Have a Job, But . . . ’: A Review of Underemployment.” Journal of Management 37 (2011): 962–996.
Underemployment literature is reviewed in this follow up to Feldman 1996. Antecedents, consequences, and implications for careers and personal well-being are discussed. The authors also discuss measurement issues and future research directions. Not limited to overqualification, this is a comprehensive and informative review.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login.
How to Subscribe
Oxford Bibliographies Online is available by subscription and perpetual access to institutions. For more information or to contact an Oxford Sales Representative click here.
Article
- Abusive Supervision
- Adverse Impact and Equal Employment Opportunity Analytics
- Alliance Portfolios
- Alternative Work Arrangements
- Applied Political Risk Analysis
- Approaches to Social Responsibility
- Assessment Centers: Theory, Practice and Research
- Attitudes
- Attributions
- Authentic Leadership
- Automation
- Bayesian Statistics
- Behavior, Organizational
- Behavioral Approach to Leadership
- Behavioral Theory of the Firm
- Benefits
- Between Organizations, Social Networks in and
- Brokerage in Networks
- Business and Human Rights
- Business Ethics
- Career Studies
- Career Transitions and Job Mobility
- Certified B Corporations and Benefit Corporations
- Charismatic and Innovative Team Leadership By and For Mill...
- Charismatic and Transformational Leadership
- Compensation, Rewards, Remuneration
- Competitive Dynamics
- Competitive Heterogeneity
- Competitive Intensity
- Computational Modeling
- Conditional Reasoning
- Conflict Management
- Considerate Leadership
- Cooperation-Competition (Coopetition)
- Corporate Philanthropy
- Corporate Social Performance
- Corporate Venture Capital
- Counterproductive Work Behavior (CWB)
- Creativity
- Cross-Cultural Communication
- Cross-Cultural Management
- Cultural Intelligence
- Culture, Organization
- Data Analytic Methods
- Decision Making
- Diversity
- Diversity and Firm Performance
- Diversity and Inclusion, Global Perspective on
- Dynamic Capabilities
- Emotional Labor
- Employee Aging
- Employee Engagement
- Employee Ownership
- Employee Voice
- Empowerment, Psychological
- Entrepreneurial Firms
- Entrepreneurial Orientation
- Entrepreneurship
- Entrepreneurship, Corporate
- Entrepreneurship, Women’s
- Equal Employment Opportunity
- Ethics
- Evaluation, Expatriate Selection and
- Executive Succession
- Faking in Personnel Selection
- Family Business, Managing
- Feedback
- Financial Markets in Organization Theory and Economic Soci...
- Findings, Reporting Research
- Firm Bribery
- First-Mover Advantage
- Fit, Person-Environment
- Forecasting
- Founding Teams
- Global Leadership
- Global Talent Management
- Goal Setting
- Grounded Theory
- Hofstedes Cultural Dimensions
- Human Capital Resource Pipelines
- Human Resource Management
- Human Resource Management, Strategic
- Human Resources, Global
- Human Rights
- Humanitarian Work Psychology
- Humility in Management
- Impression Management at Work
- Imprinting
- Influence Strategies/Tactics in the Workplace
- Information Economics
- Innovative Behavior
- Intelligence, Emotional
- International Economic Development and SMEs
- International Economic Systems
- International Strategic Alliances
- Job Analysis and Competency Modeling
- Job Crafting
- Job Design
- Job Satisfaction
- Judgment and Decision Making in Teams
- Knowledge Sharing and Collaboration within and across Firm...
- Leader-Member Exchange
- Leadership Development
- Leadership Development and Organizational Change, Coaching...
- Leadership, Ethical
- Leadership, Global and Comparative
- Leadership, Strategic
- Learning by Doing in Organizational Activities
- Licensing
- Management History
- Management In Antiquity
- Managerial and Organizational Cognition
- Managerial Discretion
- Meaningful Work
- Mentoring
- Multinational Corporations and Emerging Markets
- Multiteam Systems
- Neo-institutional Theory
- Neuroscience, Organizational
- New Ventures
- Organization Design, Global
- Organization Development and Change
- Organization Research, Ethnography in
- Organization Theory
- Organizational Adaptation
- Organizational Ambidexterity
- Organizational Behavior, Emotions in
- Organizational Citizenship Behaviors (OCBs)
- Organizational Climate
- Organizational Control
- Organizational Corruption
- Organizational Hybridity
- Organizational Identity
- Organizational Justice
- Organizational Legitimacy
- Organizational Networks
- Organizational Paradox
- Organizational Performance, Personality Theory and
- Organizational Responsibility
- Organizational Surveys, Driving Change Through
- Organizations, Big Data in
- Organizations, Gender in
- Organizations, Identity Work in
- Organizations, Political Ideology in
- Organizations, Social Identity Processes in
- Overqualification
- Passion
- Paternalistic Leadership
- Pay for Skills, Knowledge, and Competencies
- People Analytics
- Performance Appraisal
- Performance Feedback Theory
- Planning And Goal Setting
- Proactive Work Behavior
- Psychological Contracts
- Psychological Safety
- Real Options Theory
- Recruitment
- Regional Entrepreneurship
- Reputation, Organizational Image and
- Research, Ethics in
- Research, Longitudinal
- Research Methods
- Research Methods, Qualitative
- Resource Redeployment
- Resource-Dependence Theory
- Resources
- Response Surface Analysis, Polynomial Regression and
- Role of Time in Organizational Studies
- Safety, Work Place
- Selection
- Selection, Applicant Reactions to
- Self-Determination Theory for Work Motivation
- Self-Efficacy
- Self-Fulfilling Prophecy In Management
- Self-Management and Personal Agency
- Sensemaking in and around Organizations
- Service Management
- Shared Team Leadership
- Social Cognitive Theory
- Social Evaluation: Status and Reputation
- Social Movement Theory
- Social Ties and Network Structure
- Socialization
- Spin-Outs
- Sports Settings in Management Research
- Stakeholder Theory, Transaction Cost Economics and
- Stakeholders
- Status in Organizations
- Strategic Alliances
- Strategic Human Capital
- Strategy
- Strategy and Cognition
- Strategy Implementation
- Stress
- Structural Contingency Theory/Information Processing Theor...
- Team Composition
- Team Conflict
- Team Design Characteristics
- Team Emergent States Team Emergent States
- Team Learning
- Team Mental Models
- Team Newcomers
- Team Performance
- Team Processes
- Teams, Global
- Technology and Innovation Management
- Technology, Organizational Assessment and
- the Workplace, Millennials in
- Theory X and Theory Y
- Time and Motion Studies
- Training and Development
- Training Evaluation
- Trust in Organizational Contexts
- Turnover
- Unobtrusive Measures
- Validity
- Virtual Teams
- Whistle-Blowing
- Work and Family: An Organizational Science Overview
- Work Contexts, Nonverbal Communication in
- Work, Mindfulness at
- Workplace Aggression and Violence
- Workplace Coaching
- Workplace Commitment
- Workplace Gossip
- Workplace Meetings
- Workplace, Spiritual Leadership in the
- World War II, Management Research during