Urban Planning and Geography
- LAST REVIEWED: 19 December 2016
- LAST MODIFIED: 26 August 2013
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199874002-0080
- LAST REVIEWED: 19 December 2016
- LAST MODIFIED: 26 August 2013
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199874002-0080
Introduction
Urban planning refers both to collective actions that shape and improve human settlements and to a profession or professions that developed to guide urban growth and improve the conditions of industrial cities. The profession stemmed from architecture and landscape architecture, municipal engineering, public health, and social reform efforts, and it developed a distinct identity in the 20th century. Twentieth-century planning also increasingly drew on social scientific knowledge and practices, and by the century’s end urban planning research drew from and substantially contributed to geography, urban sociology, urban anthropology, and the broader urban and regional studies literatures. Planning overlaps with geography when it examines the spaces of everyday life, spatial relationships among its different dimensions, and the processes that create them. Urban planning research and practice also engages with public action and policy. How to address market failures, look out for collective interests, and work toward greater equity and better conditions for disadvantaged residents are core tenets of planning practice. Although planners are quick to note planning failures, they have been slower to develop critical analyses of how planning is implicated in the intersectional production of colonial power and gendered, racialized settlements than activists and researchers in geography and affiliated disciplines, and they have been less observant of planning’s role in concentrating rather than redistributing wealth. Planning has interrelated specializations, including housing, transportation, community development, economic development and environmental planning, among others. These continue to be core concerns, but the scope of urban planning has expanded to incorporate issues ranging from the transition to renewable energy sources, restoring fragmented ecological systems, mitigating climate change, and increased environmental vulnerability to cultural heritage preservation and living together in situations of hyperdiversity. Increasingly, planning scholars and practitioners have also recognized the importance of widespread informal urbanization. How to act effectively in a globalized world and in an era with little trust in state institutions is a current challenge facing planners. Because urban and regional planning simultaneously addresses problems of urbanization and dense settlement patterns and envisions better—more just, sustainable, prosperous, beautiful—futures through public intervention and collective community action, it often has a normative, advocacy tone with obvious affinities for particular outcomes.
General Overviews
Planning stems from divergent traditions. The classic Friedmann 1987 delineates four strands of planning’s intellectual roots. Hall 2002 offers an intellectual history of planning practice and ideology throughout the 20th century. As many western countries saw pressure for public retrenchment, Klosterman 1985 argued that planning could be defended based on the social functions it provides, from promoting collective interests and addressing externalities to looking out for less influential societal members. Planning practice and public sector action continues to be both used and challenged, and Fischler 2012 outlines major approaches to and tensions within planning origins, planning practice, planners as professionals, and planning pedagogy, arguing that the contradictions both enrich planning and make it challenging. Responding to the destruction wrought by megaproject development in the name of planning, Jacobs 1961 is an anti-planning treatise that influenced generations of planning practitioners who shifted focus to people-oriented spaces. Although public action appears necessary in complex societies, in a detailed look at statist thinking Scott 1998 demonstrates how states see and argues that limited state-centric thinking accompanied by weak civil society has led to repeated failures in large-scale planning projects. Understanding planning failures is insufficient, and Yiftachel 1998 argues that planning scholarship inadequately addresses how planning practice furthers regressive agendas (see also UN Habitat 2009, cited under Sustainability and Resilience).
Fischler, Raphaël. “Fifty Theses on Urban Planning and Urban Planners.” Journal of Planning and Education Research 32.1 (2012): 107–114.
At its core, planning has numerous contradictions and tensions. This commentary outlines nine theses about the origins of planning, ten about planning practice, ten about good planning and plans, fifteen about planners, and five about planning education and research.
Friedmann, John. Planning in the Public Domain: From Knowledge to Action. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1987.
A classic text that lays out the intellectual roots and social underpinnings of planning, by a prolific planning scholar. Delineates four dominant perspectives influencing planning theories: social reform, policy analysis, social learning, and social mobilization. One of Friedmann’s many books about planning theory and practice.
Hall, Peter. Cities of Tomorrow: An Intellectual History of Urban Planning and Design in the Twentieth Century. 3d ed. Oxford: Blackwell, 2002.
Another classic by another prolific scholar. A comparative view of planning efforts from early-19th-century reformist efforts to formalized plans and planned cities. The third edition includes trends through 2000. First published 1988.
Jacobs, Jane. The Death and Life of Great American Cities. New York: Random House, 2011.
An influential treatise against modernist urban planning. Argues that complexity and diversity are critical functions of cities. Influenced decades of planners who seek to develop vibrant people-oriented urban areas and who examine why cities continue to be sites of creativity and innovation. Critiqued for ignoring how power operates. First published in 1961.
Klosterman, Richard. “Arguments for and against Planning.” Town Planning Review 56.1 (1985): 5–20.
During the rise of the neoliberal return to market solutions, public sector planning increasingly came under attack. This article justifies planning when it promotes collective interests, addresses externalities, provides information for decision making, and considers the distributional effects of a given action or protecting the interests of those with less clout.
Scott, James C. Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition have Failed. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1998.
A rich explanation of statecraft and the limitations of statist simplification and legibility. Provides cases, including Le Corbusier’s modernist urban design in Europe, Soviet collectivism, and compulsory villagization in Tanzania, as well as agriculture and forestry.
Yiftachel, Oren. “Planning and Social Control: Exploring the Dark Side.” Journal of Planning Literature 12.4 (1998): 395–406.
DOI: 10.1177/088541229801200401
An influential article that argues that planning’s work toward goals such as oppression, economic inefficiency, or ethnic marginalization has been inadequately recognized, and offers a conceptual framework that addresses four dimensions—territorial, procedural, socioeconomic, and cultural—across which planning control has advanced regressive goals.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login.
How to Subscribe
Oxford Bibliographies Online is available by subscription and perpetual access to institutions. For more information or to contact an Oxford Sales Representative click here.
Article
- Abortion, Geographies of
- Accessing and Visualizing Archived Weather and Climate Dat...
- Activity Space
- Actor Network Theory (ANT)
- Age, Geographies of
- Agent-based Modeling
- Agricultural Geography
- Agricultural Meteorology/Climatology
- Animal Geographies
- Anthropocene and Geography, The
- Anthropogenic Climate Change
- Applied Geography
- Arctic Climatology
- Arctic, The
- Art and Geography
- Assemblage
- Assessment in Geography Education
- Atmospheric Composition and Structure
- Automobility
- Aviation Meteorology
- Beer, Geography of
- Behavioral and Cognitive Geography
- Belonging
- Belt and Road Initiative
- Biodiversity Conservation
- Biodiversity Gradients
- Biogeography
- Biogeomorphology and Zoogeomorphology
- Biometric Technologies
- Biopedoturbation
- Body, Geographies of the
- Borders and Boundaries
- Brownfields
- Carbon Cycle
- Carceral Geographies
- Cartography
- Cartography, History of
- Cartography, Mapping, and War
- Chicago School
- Children and Childhood, Geographies of
- Citizenship
- Climate Literacy and Education
- Climatology
- Communication
- Community Mapping
- Commuting
- Comparative Urbanism
- Complexity
- Conservation Biogeography
- Consumption, Geographies of
- Crime Analysis, GIS and
- Crime, Geography of
- Critical GIS
- Critical Military Geographies
- Cultural Ecology and Human Ecology
- Cultural Geography
- Cultural Landscape
- CyberGIS
- Cyberspace, Geography of
- Desertification
- Developing World
- Development, Regional
- Development Theory
- Disability, Geography of
- Disease, Geography of
- Drones, Geography of
- Drought
- Drugs, Geography of
- Economic Geography
- Economic Historical Geography
- Edge Cities and Urban Sprawl
- Education (K-12), Geography
- El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO)
- Elderly, Geography and the
- Electoral Geography
- Empire, Geography and
- Energy, Geographies of
- Energy, Renewable
- Energy Resources and Use
- Environment and Development
- Environmental Electronic Sensing Systems
- Environmental Justice
- Ethics, Geographers and
- Ethics, Geography and
- Ethnicity
- Ethnography
- Ethnonationalism
- Everyday Life, Geography and
- Extreme Heat
- Family, Geographies of the
- Feminist Geography
- Fieldwork
- Film, Geography and
- Finance, Geography of
- Financial Geographies of Debt and Crisis
- Fluvial Geomorphology
- Folk Culture and Geography
- Future, Geographies of the
- Gender and Geography
- Gentrification
- Geocomputation in Geography Education
- Geographic Information Science
- Geographic Methods: Archival Research
- Geographic Methods: Discourse Analysis
- Geographic Methods: Interviews
- Geographic Methods: Life Writing Analysis
- Geographic Methods: Visual Analysis
- Geographic Thought (US)
- Geographic Vulnerability to Climate Change
- Geographies of Affect
- Geographies of Diplomacy
- Geographies of Education
- Geographies of Resilience
- Geography and Class
- Geography, Gramsci and
- Geography, Legal
- Geography of Biofuels
- Geography of Food
- Geography of Hunger and Famine
- Geography of Industrialization
- Geography of Public Policy
- Geography of Resources
- Geopolitics
- Geopolitics, Energy and
- Geospatial Artificial Intelligence (GeoAI)
- GIS and Computational Social Sciences
- GIS and Health
- GIS and Remote Sensing Applications in Geomorphology
- GIS and Virtual Reality
- GIS applications in Human Geography
- GIS, Geospatial Technology, and Spatial Thinking in Geogra...
- GIS, Historical
- GIS, History of
- GIS, Space-Time
- Glacial and Periglacial Geomorphology
- Glaciers, Geography of
- Globalization
- Health Care, Geography of
- Hegemony and Geographic Knowledge
- Historical Geography
- Historical Mobilities
- Histories of Protest and Social Movements
- History, Environmental
- Homelessness
- Human Dynamics, GIScience of
- Human Geographies of Outer Space
- Human Trafficking
- Humanistic Geography
- Human-Landscape Interactions
- Humor, Geographies of
- Hurricanes
- Hydroclimatology and Climate Variability
- Hydrology
- Identity and Place
- "Imagining a Better Future through Place": Geographies of ...
- Immigration and Immigrants
- Indigenous Peoples and the Global Indigenous Movement
- Informal Economy
- Innovation, Geography of
- Intelligence, Geographical
- Islands, Human Geography and
- Justice, Geography of
- Knowledge Economy: Spatial Approaches
- Knowledge, Geography of
- Labor, Geography of
- Land Use and Cover Change
- Land-Atmosphere Interactions
- Landscape Interpretation
- Literature, Geography and
- Location Theory
- Marine Biogeography
- Marine Conservation and Fisheries Management
- Media Geography
- Medical Geography
- Migration
- Migration, International Student
- Military Geographies and the Environment
- Military Geographies of Popular Culture
- Military Geographies of Urban Space and War
- Military Geography
- Moonsoons, Geography of
- Mountain Geography
- Mountain Meteorology
- Music, Sound, and Auditory Culture, Geographies of
- National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) in Geog...
- Nations and Nationalism
- Natural Hazards and Risk
- Nature-Society Theory
- Neogeography
- New Urbanism
- Nightlife
- Non-representational Theory
- Nuclear War, Geographies of
- Nutrition Transition, The
- Oceans
- Orientalism and Geography
- Participatory Action Research
- Peace, Geographies of
- Pedagogical Content Knowledge in Geography Education
- Perspectives in Geography Internships
- Phenology and Climate
- Photographic and Video Methods in Geography
- Physical Geography
- Place
- Polar Geography
- Policy Mobilities
- Political Ecology
- Political Geography
- Political Geology
- Popular Culture, Geography and
- Population Geography
- Ports and Maritime Trade
- Postcolonialism
- Postmodernism and Poststructuralism
- Pragmatism, Geographies of
- Producer Services
- Psychogeography
- Public Participation GIS, Participatory GIS, and Participa...
- Qualitative GIS
- Qualitative Methods
- Quantitative Methods in Human Geography
- Questionnaires
- Race and Racism
- Refugees, Geography of
- Religion, Geographies of
- Retail Trade, Geography of
- Rural Geography
- Science and Technology Studies (STS) in Geography
- Sea-Level Research, Quaternary
- Security and Securitization, Geographies of
- Segregation, Ethnic and Racial
- Service Industries, Geography of
- Settlement Geography
- Sexuality, Geography of
- Slope Processes
- Social Justice
- Social Media Analytics
- Soils, Diversity of
- Sonic Methods in Geography
- Spatial Analysis
- Spatial Autocorrelation
- Sports, Geography of
- Sustainability Science
- Sustainable Agriculture
- Synoptic Climatology
- Technological Change, Geography of
- Telecommunications
- Teleconnections, Atmospheric
- Terrestrial Snow, Measurement of
- Territory and Territoriality
- Terrorism, Geography of
- The Climate Security Nexus
- The Voluntary Sector and Geography
- Time, Geographies of
- Time Geography
- Time-Space Compression
- Tourism Geography
- Touristification
- Transnational Corporations
- Unoccupied Aircraft Systems
- Urban Geography
- Urban Heritage
- Urban Historical Geography
- Urban Meteorology and Climatology
- Urban Planning and Geography
- Urban Political Ecology
- Urban Sustainability
- Visualizations
- Vulnerability, Risk, and Hazards
- Vulnerability to Climate Change
- War on Terror, Geographies of the
- Water
- Weather and Climate Damage Studies
- Wetlands
- Whiteness, Geographies of
- Wine, Geography of
- World Cities
- Young People's Geography