Belt and Road Initiative
- LAST MODIFIED: 12 January 2023
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199874002-0253
- LAST MODIFIED: 12 January 2023
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199874002-0253
Introduction
The “Belt and Road Initiative” (BRI) has been an eye-catching term among social scientists, including human geographers, across the world. Pointing to the Chinese call for new modes of regional and international cooperation, the BRI originates from Chinese President Xi Jinping’s proposal to develop a “Silk Road Economic Belt” (“One Belt”) and a “21st Century Maritime Silk Road” (“One Road”) during his visits to Kazakhstan and Indonesia in 2013. In 2015, the Chinese central government released an Action Plan of the BRI, publicizing its designated principles, framework, as well as cooperation priorities and mechanisms of promoting the BRI. This White Paper has also specified five focuses of future BRI development, including policy coordination, connectivity of infrastructure and facilities, unimpeded trade, financial integration, and closer people-to-people ties. At the end of the BRI’s first five-year development in 2018, the Chinese government announced that it had signed BRI-oriented cooperative agreements with more than one hundred countries and international organizations. Since then, the Chinese government proposed to promote the “high quality” development of the BRI and gradually added new keywords to this grand scheme, including but not limited to “green,” “digital,” and “health.” Existing literature on BRI has incorporated insights of geography, economics, international relations, development studies, and environmental studies. This article contours existing knowledge on the BRI in geography and related disciplines in social sciences, with an integrated sensitivity to spatial embeddedness of specific BRI practices and its consequences. A considerable thread of BRI literature has examined the political economic nature of BRI. The BRI is understood as a Chinese preferred “spatial fix” to its domestic overaccumulation problems as well as a tool to serve China’s geopolitical interests through the making of discourses, imaginaries, and on-ground practices. BRI boosts investment and trade flows through infrastructure and connectivity projects. Although scholarly attention is often paid to the Chinese state as a whole in the discursive and strategic making of BRI, subnational state actors and non-state actors also actively engage with host country actors for specific BRI projects, the implementation of which can be affected by the combined path dependency and temporal-spatial conditions. BRI, in turn, is also examined to inform the nature of contemporary Chinese politics, the ways in which it benefits or affects the economic development and well-being of other populations and the wider environment, the uncertainties and changing spatiality concerning social, cultural, urban and intellectual issues, as well as for methodological reflections.
General Overviews
The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) is understood and used in different ways. Generally speaking, existing BRI studies can be categorized into four strands that portray the BRI as geopolitics, geoeconomics, Chinese exceptionalism, and the “Silk Road Imaginary” (Lin, et al. 2021). For example, claiming to analyze the BRI from the Chinese perspective, Dunford and Liu 2019 conceptualizes the BRI as a Chinese call for inclusive globalization, a new model of regional and international development, inspired by the so-called “Silk Road Spirit” (Liu 2015). BRI is also viewed as a “spatial fix” of China’s domestic overaccumulation problems (Summers 2016 and Sum 2019). With attention paid to the new city-regionalism in Western China, BRI is also known as enabling a multidimensional rescaling fix to the country’s interior problems (Zhang and He 2021). Besides, many Western scholars view the BRI as China’s geopolitical project that has been brought into being and given multiple even competing logics and temporal-spatial conditions (Richardson 2021). The BRI is also used as an example to examine how space is being remade at various scales, highlighting the opportunity to interrogate state power and sovereignty at current time (Kuus 2019); and as a technopolitical endeavor and for a methodological guide (Oakes 2021).
Dunford, Michael, and Weidong Liu. “Chinese Perspectives on the Belt and Road Initiative.” Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 12.1 (2019):145–167.
DOI: 10.1093/cjres/rsy032
Outlining the BRI’s evolution and the ideas underlying it as expressed in official documents and speeches, this article regards the BRI as a Chinese call for an open and inclusive model of sustainable international cooperation and development and for a multi-polar world order. This call advocates non-interference and economic advantages of closer international cooperation with China, representing an existential danger against political and economic forces upholding the current “global hegemon.”
Kuus, Merje. “Political Geography III: Bounding the International.” Progress in Human Geography 44.6 (2019): 1185–1193.
The BRI is examined for understanding region-making and regionalism to inform how imaginaries and practices “remake” space at the international and supranational scale. Concerning existing studies on international borders, this article points to flexible practices and the multiple forms of borders, highlighting interdisciplinary understanding of current forms of the “resilience of state power and the transformations of sovereignty.”
Lin, Shaun, Naoko Shimazu, and James D. Sidaway. “Theorising from the Belt and Road Initiative (一带一路).” In Special Issue: BRI as Method Forum. Asia Pacific Viewpoint 62.3 (2021): 261–269.
DOI: 10.1111/apv.12322
Existing literature focusing on the nature and consequences of BRI has framed the BRI as representing the Chinese strategy and response to other powers (geopolitics), as the tool of a spatial or infrastructural fix (geoeconomics), as offering a win-win development model with a new spirit of harmony (Chinese exceptionalism), and through tracing and making “Silk Road” narrative as imaginary). BRI is also increasingly investigated through specific localities and projects.
Liu, Weidong. “Scientific Understanding of the Belt and Road Initiative of China and Related Research Themes.” Progress in Geography 34.5 (2015): 538–544.
The BRI provides an alternative way to deepen economic globalization. However, it differentiates from existing globalization practices given its integration of the Spirit of the Silk Road, which stresses “peace and cooperation, openness and inclusiveness, mutual learning and win-win.” This article proposes to advance geopolitical studies, geographies of international cooperation, foreign direct investment, and optimization of transcontinental transportation as key areas for a better understanding of the BRI. In Chinese.
Oakes, Tim. “The Belt and Road as method: Geopolitics, technopolitics and power through an infrastructure lens.” Asia Pacific Viewpoint 62.3 (2021): 281–285.
DOI: 10.1111/apv.12319
Conventional approach to the political and political power of BRI is insufficient. Reframing the BRI from the perspective of technopolitics, the authors questions “how political power is realized or frustrated, enhanced or diverted, by the distributed and relational nature of infrastructure projects” and attempts to set up a research agenda and research framework concerning the growth and evolution of infrastructure projects, their social-political-cultural embeddedness, and their political effects.
Richardson, Paul B. “Geopolitical Encounters and Entanglements along the Belt and Road Initiative.” Geography Compass 15.8 (2021): e12583.
DOI: 10.1111/gec3.12583
The BRI is viewed as a visible geopolitical project that has been examined from classical, critical, radical, assemblage, and feminist perspectives. This review article also facilitates a conversation on the value of applying multiple approaches and different types of knowledge to the BRI, with attention paid to the competing logics, contexts, relations, and elements that bring the BRI into being.
Sum, Ngai-Ling. “The Intertwined Geopolitics and Geoeconomics of Hopes/Fears: China’s Triple Economic Bubbles and the ‘One Belt One Road’ Imaginary.” Territory, Politics, Governance 7.4 (2019): 528–552.
DOI: 10.1080/21622671.2018.1523746
This article examines China’s geostrategic imaginary of the BRI and its development concerning political and geoeconomics of hopes and fears. The “China Dream,” “New Normal,” and the BRI are viewed as Chinese hope-based discursive production. The material translation of the BRI imaginary into policies is viewed as a “spatial fix” to suspend China’s over-accumulation crises, while consolidating a China-intended infrastructural mode of growth in production, finance, and security.
Summers, Tim. “China’s ‘New Silk Roads’: Sub-national Regions and Networks of Global Political Economy.” Third World Quarterly 37.9 (2016):1628–1643.
DOI: 10.1080/01436597.2016.1153415
This article argues that the BRI contains sub-national ideas and practices that the spatial paradigms of BRI represent the reproduction of capitalist ideas of development in the form of networks, featuring contemporary global political economy. In so doing, the vision of BRI is more of a state-led “spatial fix” than for geopolitical ambition, tending to promote the networks of capital flows through infrastructure development, at least across the Eurasian continent.
Zhang, Mengzhu, and Shenjing He. “From Dissensus to Consensus: State Rescaling and Modalities of Power under the Belt and Road Initiative in Western China.” Annals of the American Association of Geographers 111.5 (2021): 1519–1538.
DOI: 10.1080/24694452.2020.1823808
This article draws on the territory–place–scale–network (TPSN) approach and post-structural theory of state power to reconceptualize state rescaling as a multidimensional process. Pointing to the new city-regionalism in Western China, it examines the ways in which China uses BRI for a “rescaling fix” to address domestic problems. It regards BRI as a TPSN-informed reconfiguration of China’s interior production system, which optimistically involves a complicated reorganization of socio-spatial relations.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login.
How to Subscribe
Oxford Bibliographies Online is available by subscription and perpetual access to institutions. For more information or to contact an Oxford Sales Representative click here.
Article
- Abortion, Geographies of
- Accessing and Visualizing Archived Weather and Climate Dat...
- Activity Space
- Actor Network Theory (ANT)
- Age, Geographies of
- Agent-based Modeling
- Agricultural Geography
- Agricultural Meteorology/Climatology
- Animal Geographies
- Anthropocene and Geography, The
- Anthropogenic Climate Change
- Applied Geography
- Arctic Climatology
- Arctic, The
- Art and Geography
- Assemblage
- Assessment in Geography Education
- Atmospheric Composition and Structure
- Automobility
- Aviation Meteorology
- Beer, Geography of
- Behavioral and Cognitive Geography
- Belonging
- Belt and Road Initiative
- Biodiversity Conservation
- Biodiversity Gradients
- Biogeography
- Biogeomorphology and Zoogeomorphology
- Biometric Technologies
- Biopedoturbation
- Body, Geographies of the
- Borders and Boundaries
- Brownfields
- Carbon Cycle
- Carceral Geographies
- Cartography
- Cartography, History of
- Chicago School
- Children and Childhood, Geographies of
- Citizenship
- Climate Literacy and Education
- Climatology
- Communication
- Community Mapping
- Commuting
- Comparative Urbanism
- Complexity
- Conservation Biogeography
- Consumption, Geographies of
- Crime Analysis, GIS and
- Crime, Geography of
- Critical GIS
- Cultural Ecology and Human Ecology
- Cultural Geography
- Cultural Landscape
- CyberGIS
- Cyberspace, Geography of
- Desertification
- Developing World
- Development, Regional
- Development Theory
- Disability, Geography of
- Disease, Geography of
- Drones, Geography of
- Drought
- Drugs, Geography of
- Economic Geography
- Economic Historical Geography
- Edge Cities and Urban Sprawl
- Education (K-12), Geography
- El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO)
- Elderly, Geography and the
- Electoral Geography
- Empire, Geography and
- Energy, Geographies of
- Energy, Renewable
- Energy Resources and Use
- Environment and Development
- Environmental Electronic Sensing Systems
- Environmental Justice
- Ethics, Geographers and
- Ethics, Geography and
- Ethnicity
- Ethnography
- Ethnonationalism
- Everyday Life, Geography and
- Extreme Heat
- Family, Geographies of the
- Feminist Geography
- Fieldwork
- Film, Geography and
- Finance, Geography of
- Financial Geographies of Debt and Crisis
- Fluvial Geomorphology
- Folk Culture and Geography
- Future, Geographies of the
- Gender and Geography
- Gentrification
- Geographic Information Science
- Geographic Methods: Archival Research
- Geographic Methods: Discourse Analysis
- Geographic Methods: Interviews
- Geographic Methods: Life Writing Analysis
- Geographic Methods: Visual Analysis
- Geographic Thought (US)
- Geographic Vulnerability to Climate Change
- Geographies of Affect
- Geographies of Diplomacy
- Geographies of Education
- Geographies of Resilience
- Geography and Class
- Geography, Gramsci and
- Geography, Legal
- Geography of Biofuels
- Geography of Food
- Geography of Hunger and Famine
- Geography of Industrialization
- Geography of Public Policy
- Geography of Resources
- Geopolitics
- Geopolitics, Energy and
- Geospatial Artificial Intelligence (GeoAI)
- GIS and Computational Social Sciences
- GIS and Health
- GIS and Remote Sensing Applications in Geomorphology
- GIS applications in Human Geography
- GIS, Historical
- GIS, History of
- GIS, Space-Time
- Glacial and Periglacial Geomorphology
- Glaciers, Geography of
- Globalization
- Health Care, Geography of
- Historical Geography
- History, Environmental
- Homelessness
- Human Dynamics, GIScience of
- Human Geographies of Outer Space
- Human Trafficking
- Humanistic Geography
- Human-Landscape Interactions
- Humor, Geographies of
- Hurricanes
- Hydroclimatology and Climate Variability
- Hydrology
- Identity and Place
- Immigration and Immigrants
- Indigenous Peoples and the Global Indigenous Movement
- Informal Economy
- Innovation, Geography of
- Intelligence, Geographical
- Islands, Human Geography and
- Justice, Geography of
- Knowledge Economy: Spatial Approaches
- Knowledge, Geography of
- Labor, Geography of
- Land Use and Cover Change
- Land-Atmosphere Interactions
- Landscape Interpretation
- Literature, Geography and
- Location Theory
- Marine Biogeography
- Marine Conservation and Fisheries Management
- Media Geography
- Medical Geography
- Migration
- Migration, International Student
- Military Geography
- Moonsoons, Geography of
- Mountain Geography
- Mountain Meteorology
- Music, Sound, and Auditory Culture, Geographies of
- Nations and Nationalism
- Natural Hazards and Risk
- Nature-Society Theory
- Neogeography
- New Urbanism
- Nightlife
- Non-representational Theory
- Nutrition Transition, The
- Oceans
- Orientalism and Geography
- Participatory Action Research
- Peace, Geographies of
- Phenology and Climate
- Photographic and Video Methods in Geography
- Physical Geography
- Place
- Polar Geography
- Policy Mobilities
- Political Ecology
- Political Geography
- Political Geology
- Popular Culture, Geography and
- Population Geography
- Ports and Maritime Trade
- Postcolonialism
- Postmodernism and Poststructuralism
- Pragmatism, Geographies of
- Producer Services
- Psychogeography
- Public Participation GIS, Participatory GIS, and Participa...
- Qualitative GIS
- Qualitative Methods
- Quantitative Methods in Human Geography
- Questionnaires
- Race and Racism
- Refugees, Geography of
- Religion, Geographies of
- Retail Trade, Geography of
- Rural Geography
- Science and Technology Studies (STS) in Geography
- Sea-Level Research, Quaternary
- Segregation, Ethnic and Racial
- Service Industries, Geography of
- Settlement Geography
- Sexuality, Geography of
- Slope Processes
- Social Justice
- Soils, Diversity of
- Sonic Methods in Geography
- Spatial Analysis
- Spatial Autocorrelation
- Sports, Geography of
- Sustainability Science
- Sustainable Agriculture
- Synoptic Climatology
- Technological Change, Geography of
- Telecommunications
- Teleconnections, Atmospheric
- Terrestrial Snow, Measurement of
- Territory and Territoriality
- Terrorism, Geography of
- The Climate Security Nexus
- The Voluntary Sector and Geography
- Time, Geographies of
- Time Geography
- Time-Space Compression
- Tourism Geography
- Transnational Corporations
- Unoccupied Aircraft Systems
- Urban Geography
- Urban Heritage
- Urban Historical Geography
- Urban Meteorology and Climatology
- Urban Planning and Geography
- Urban Political Ecology
- Visualizations
- Vulnerability, Risk, and Hazards
- Vulnerability to Climate Change
- Water
- Weather and Climate Damage Studies
- Wetlands
- Whiteness, Geographies of
- Wine, Geography of
- World Cities
- Young People's Geography