Bail and Pretrial Detention
- LAST REVIEWED: 24 June 2019
- LAST MODIFIED: 28 May 2013
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780195396607-0084
- LAST REVIEWED: 24 June 2019
- LAST MODIFIED: 28 May 2013
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780195396607-0084
Introduction
Determining the accused pretrial status requires tracing the interplay between legislative and case law attempts to define the legal function of bail. The perennial concern has been the clash between the defendant’s interest in pretrial freedom and the government’s interest to protect the community. Studies conducted as early as the 1930s revealed widespread bail practices that detained defendants solely due to the defendant’s inability to meet financial conditions of release. In the 1950s and 1960s a heated debate emerged over the legal function of bail and the legally relevant information upon which judicial officers are to base the severity of bail imposed prior to trial. Legislative attempts to reform bail practices were codified in the Bail Reform Act of 1966 (18 U.S.C. § 3146 [1966] [current version at 18 U.S.C. § 3142 Supp. III. 1985]) and the Bail Reform Act of 1984 (18 U.S.C. § 3141–3156 Supp. III 1985). The acts and case law contained primarily in Stack v. Boyle (342 U.S. 1, 4 [1951]), Carlson v. Landon (342 U.S. 524 [1952]), Gerstein v. Pugh (420 U.S. 103 [1976]), Bell v. Wolfish (441, U.S. 520 [1979]), and U.S. v. Salerno (794 F.2d 64 [2nd Cir. 1986]), reversed, 107 S. Ct. 2095 (1987) produced inconsistent and contradictory positions on the legal function of bail. Extensive legal literature developed debating the ongoing tension between defendant’s liberty rights and public safety. At the heart of this debate are challenges centered around substantive and procedural rights about pretrial preventive detention and the defendant’s protections under the Fourth, Fifth, and Eighth Amendments, and the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Social science research has taken three general directions. The first direction sought to describe bail practices in terms of pretrial outcomes in large urban areas. The second direction focused on identifying the variables predictive of pretrial dangerousness and flight risk. The third direction attempts to estimate the variables significantly affecting the severity of bail outcomes. These avenues of research are reflected throughout seven decades of empirical work presented herein. Because of the centrality of legislative reform, this bibliography is organized in terms of time periods relative to the passage of the Bail Reform Act of 1966 and the Bail Reform Act of 1984.
Practices Prior to the Bail Reform Act of 1966
As early as 1927, researchers including Beeley 1927 and Morse and Beattie 1932 empirically examined the judicial discretion at the bail hearing. Much of the early research, such as Alexander, et al. 1958; Foote 1954; Goldfarb 1965; and Rankin 1964, found that judges relied heavily on high amounts of cash bail, resulting in pretrial detention for a large number of defendants who posed little risk of nonappearance. Beeley 1927; Morse and Beattie 1932; Foote 1954; and Ares, et al. 1963 argued that preventive detention prior to trial violates the accused’s constitutional rights and is contrary to the principle of the presumption of innocence. Research indicated that offense seriousness was the strongest predictor of the amount of cash bail. This finding called into question the constitutionality of bail practices that penalized defendants for offenses yet to be proven according to due process procedures (see Goldfarb 1965).
Alexander, G., M. Glass, J. W. Roberts, J. S. Palermo, and A. Sturz. 1958. A study of administration of bail in New York City. University of Pennsylvania Law Review 106:693–730.
DOI: 10.2307/3310385E-mail Citation »
Research indicated that bail is typically set without regard for the defendant’s ability to meet the bail amount. The research documented how the New York bail system discriminated against defendants who could not afford bail and for whom a lower more reasonable amount of bail would have assured appearance at trial.
Ares, C. E., Anne Rankin, and A. Sturz. 1963. The Manhattan bail project: An interim report on the use of pre-trial parole. New York University Law Review 38:67–95.
Findings from the multi-year study of bail decision making in Manhattan. The project was designed to investigate pre-arraignment investigations and to determine whether a significant number of indigent defendants could successfully be released on parole during pretrial processing. Researchers concluded that the use of cash bail resulted in widespread pretrial detention for defendants who posed no flight risk.
Beeley, A. 1927. The bail system in Chicago. Chicago: The Univ. of Chicago Press.
Used official court records and interviews with defendants in Chicago for the purpose of studying bail decision making outcomes. Findings indicated that judges heavy relied on imposing financial conditions for bail. This widespread practice resulted in many defendants being detained during pretrial processing solely due to an inability to meet the cash amount.
Foote, Caleb. 1954. Compelling appearance in court: Administration of bail in Philadelphia. University of Pennsylvania Law Review 102:1031–1079.
DOI: 10.2307/3309895E-mail Citation »
Author’s research indicates widespread use of case bail in Philadelphia noting the reality that poor defendants were detained in jail during pretrial processing solely due to an inability to meet the financial condition for release. The heavy reliance on cash bail amounted to economic discrimination in bail setting with the result that indigent defendants do not have equal access to pretrial liberty or equal protection under the law.
Goldfarb, R. L. 1965. Ransom: A critique of the American bail system. New York: Harper and Row.
Reports the Vera Institute of Justice in New York City findings in the 1960s that only 1.5 percent of the 3,500 defendants released during pretrial failed to appear for further case processing. This finding was nearly three times better than the rate for comparable defendants who were released on bail.
Morse, W., and R. Beattie. 1932. Survey of the administration of criminal justice in Oregon. Oregon Law Review 11:100–130.
Finding that a large number of defendants were detained during pretrial processing solely due to an inability to meet cash amount for release.
Rankin, Anne. 1964. The effect of pretrial detention. New York University Law Review 39:641–655.
Research findings indicate that defendant’s prior record, bail amount, type of counsel, family integration, and employment stability do not account separately for the relationship between pretrial detention and the severity of punishment imposed upon conviction.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login.
How to Subscribe
Oxford Bibliographies Online is available by subscription and perpetual access to institutions. For more information or to contact an Oxford Sales Representative click here.
Article
- Active Offender Research
- Adverse Childhood Experiences
- Aging Prison Population, The
- Airport and Airline Security
- Alcohol and Drug Prohibition
- Alcohol Use, Policy and Crime
- Alt-Right Gangs and White Power Youth Groups
- Animals, Crimes Against
- Anomie
- Arson
- Bail and Pretrial Detention
- Biosocial Criminology
- Blackmail
- Black's Theory of Law and Social Control
- Blumstein, Alfred
- Boot Camps and Shock Incarceration Programs
- Burglary, Residential
- Bystander Intervention
- Capital Punishment
- Chicago School of Criminology, The
- Child Maltreatment
- Chinese Triad Society
- Civil Protection Orders
- Collateral Consequences of Felony Conviction and Imprisonm...
- Collective Efficacy
- Commercial and Bank Robbery
- Communicating Scientific Findings in the Courtroom
- Community Change and Crime
- Community Corrections
- Community Disadvantage and Crime
- Community-Based Justice Systems
- Comparative Criminal Justice Systems
- CompStat Models of Police Performance Management
- Confessions, False and Coerced
- Contextual Analysis of Crime
- Control Balance Theory
- Convict Criminology
- Corporate Crime
- Costs of Crime and Justice
- Courts, Problem-Solving
- Crime and Justice in Latin America
- Crime Control Policy
- Crime Control, Politics of
- Crime, (In)Security, and Islam
- Crime Prevention, Delinquency and
- Crime Prevention, Situational
- Crime Trends
- Crime Victims' Rights Movement
- Criminal Career Research
- Criminal Decision Making, Emotions in
- Criminal Justice Data Sources
- Criminal Justice Ethics
- Criminal Justice Reform, Politics of
- Criminal Justice System, Discretion in the
- Criminal Records
- Criminal Retaliation
- Criminal Talk
- Criminology and Political Science
- Criminology of Genocide, The
- Critical Criminology
- Cross-National Crime
- Cultural Criminology
- Cultural Theories
- Cybercrime
- Cycle of Violence
- Desistance
- Deterrence
- Developmental and Life-Course Criminology
- Digital Piracy
- Driving and Traffic Offenses
- Drug Control
- Drug Courts
- Drug Trafficking, International
- Drugs and Crime
- Electronically Monitored Home Confinement
- Employee Theft
- Environmental Crime and Justice
- Experimental Criminology
- Family Violence
- Fear of Crime and Perceived Risk
- Felon Disenfranchisement
- Femicide
- Feminist Theories
- Feminist Victimization Theories
- Fencing and Stolen Goods Markets
- Firearms and Violence
- Forensic Science
- Fraud
- Gangs, Peers, and Co-offending
- Gender and Crime
- General Opportunity Victimization Theories
- Genetics, Environment, and Crime
- Green Criminology
- Harm Reduction and Risky Behaviors
- Hate Crime
- Hate Crime Legislation
- Healthcare Fraud
- Hirschi, Travis
- History of Crime in the United Kingdom
- History of Criminology
- Homelessness and Crime
- Homicide
- Homicide Victimization
- Honor Cultures and Violence
- Hot Spots Policing
- Human Rights
- Human Trafficking
- Identity Theft
- Immigration, Crime, and Justice
- Incarceration, Mass
- Incarceration, Public Health Effects of
- Income Tax Evasion
- Institutional Anomie Theory
- Integrated Theory
- Interpersonal Violence, Historical Patterns of
- Interrogation
- Intimate Partner Violence, Criminological Perspectives on
- Intimate Partner Violence, Police Responses to
- Investigation, Criminal
- Juvenile Delinquency
- Juvenile Justice System, The
- Kidnapping
- Kornhauser, Ruth Rosner
- Labeling Theory
- Labor Markets and Crime
- Land Use and Crime
- Lead and Crime
- Legitimacy
- LGBTQ Intimate Partner Violence
- Local Institutions and Neighborhood Crime
- Lombroso, Cesare
- Mandatory Minimum Sentencing
- Mapping and Spatial Analysis of Crime, The
- Mass Media, Crime, and Justice
- Measuring Crime
- Mediation and Dispute Resolution Programs
- Mental Health and Crime
- Mental Health Courts
- Meta-analysis in Criminology
- Middle-Class Crime and Criminality
- Migrant Detention and Incarceration
- Money Laundering
- Motor Vehicle Theft
- Narrative Criminology
- National Deviancy Symposia, The
- Nature Versus Nurture
- Neighborhood Disorder
- Neutralization Theory
- New Penology, The
- Offender Decision-Making and Motivation
- Offense Specialization/Expertise
- Organized Crime
- Panel Methods in Criminology
- Peacemaking Criminology
- Peer Networks and Delinquency
- Performance Measurement and Accountability Systems
- Personality and Trait Theories of Crime
- Persons with a Mental Illness, Police Encounters with
- Phenomenological Theories of Crime
- Plea Bargaining
- Poaching
- Police Administration
- Police Cooperation, International
- Police Effectiveness
- Police History
- Police Militarization
- Police Misconduct
- Police, Race and the
- Police Use of Force
- Police, Violence against the
- Policing and Law Enforcement
- Policing, Broken Windows
- Policing, Community and Problem-Oriented
- Policing Cybercrime
- Policing, Evidence-Based
- Policing, Intelligence-Led
- Policing, Privatization of
- Policing, Proactive
- Policing, School
- Policing, Third Party
- Polyvictimization
- Prison Education Exchange Programs
- Prison Gangs and Subculture
- Prison History
- Prison Labor
- Prison Visitation
- Prisoner Reentry
- Prisons and Jails
- Procedural Justice
- Property Crime
- Prosecution and Courts
- Prostitution
- Psychiatry, Psychology, and Crime: Historical and Current ...
- Psychology and Crime
- Public Criminology
- Public Opinion, Crime and Justice
- Public Order Crimes
- Public Social Control and Neighborhood Crime
- Punishment Justification and Goals
- Qualitative Methods in Criminology
- Queer Criminology
- Race, Ethnicity, Crime, and Justice
- Racial Threat Hypothesis
- Racial Profiling
- Rape and Sexual Assault
- Rape, Fear of
- Rational Choice Theories
- Rehabilitation
- Religion and Crime
- Restorative Justice
- Risk Assessment
- Routine Activity Theories
- School Bullying
- School Crime and Violence
- Seasonality and Crime
- Self-Control, The General Theory:
- Self-Report Crime Surveys
- Sentencing Enhancements
- Sentencing Guidelines
- Sentencing Policy
- Sex Crimes
- Sex Offender Policies and Legislation
- Sex Trafficking
- Sexual Revictimization
- Situational Action Theory
- Snitching and Use of Criminal Informants
- Social and Intellectual Context of Criminology, The
- Social Construction of Crime, The
- Social Control of Tobacco Use
- Social Control Theory
- Social Disorganization
- Social Ecology of Crime
- Social Learning Theory
- Social Networks
- Social Threat and Social Control
- Solitary Confinement
- South Africa, Crime and Justice in
- Sport Mega-Events Security
- Stalking and Harassment
- State Crime
- State Dependence and Population Heterogeneity in Theories ...
- Strain Theories
- Street Code
- Street Robbery
- Substance Use and Abuse
- Surveillance, Public and Private
- Sutherland, Edwin H.
- Technology and the Criminal Justice System
- Technology, Criminal Use of
- Terrorism
- Terrorism and Hate Crime
- Terrorism, Criminological Explanations for
- Testimony, Eyewitness
- Therapeutic Jurisprudence
- Trajectory Methods in Criminology
- Transnational Crime
- Truth-In-Sentencing
- Urban Politics and Crime
- US War on Terrorism, Legal Perspectives on the
- Victimization, Adolescent
- Victimization, Biosocial Theories of
- Victimization Patterns and Trends
- Victimization, Repeat
- Victimization, Vicarious and Related Forms of Secondary Tr...
- Victimless Crime
- Victim-Offender Overlap, The
- Violence Against Women
- Violence, Youth
- Violent Crime
- White-Collar Crime
- Wilson, James Q.
- Women, Girls, and Reentry
- Wrongful Conviction