Jurisprudence (Judicial Law-Making)
- LAST REVIEWED: 21 November 2016
- LAST MODIFIED: 24 July 2013
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199796953-0081
- LAST REVIEWED: 21 November 2016
- LAST MODIFIED: 24 July 2013
- DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199796953-0081
Jurisprudence (used herein as a synonym for judicial law-making) is at the center of a perennial debate, almost secular, at the core of the sources of international law. Indeed, since its incorporation into Article 38 of the Statute of the Permanent Court of International Justice—added afterward to its correspondent in the Statute of the International Court of Justice—several scholarly theories are still open as to whether judicial decisions are or are not a source of international law. In other words, the debate is about whether international courts and tribunals can create international law or not, and hence, if they can fill up gaps in international law—non liquet. The intensity of this doctrinal debate increased markedly over the last half of the 20th century and during the 21st century alongside the proliferation of international jurisdictions. Its universal expansion in a growing number of subjects, such as its compulsory jurisdiction in certain regions, places jurisprudence in a position of particular strength, but it also appears quite destructive to those who fear for the unity of international law. Beyond this irresolvable debate, opinions turn unanimous, although variable in intensity, to stress the important contributions made by jurisprudence in both the formation and the development of international law. In fact, on one hand, jurisprudence contributes to the creation and development of international custom, because continuous and constant repetition of acts may constitute the material element of the creative process of a customary rule. On the other hand, it has influenced the development of concepts such as jus cogens, obligations erga omnes, and international crimes. However, the authority or influence of jurisprudence in international law is deeply bounded by state consent. Jurisprudence is a concept with many ramifications, which could lead us from the general theory of sources of international law, to the role of international judge, to the proliferation of jurisdictions or to the debate on the unity and fragmentation of jurisdictions. All the above requires the hard work of conceptual definition and bibliographic selection in order not to get lost in these other key issues, which, however, will be inevitably alluded to the extent necessary for the purpose of the work.
In the absence of any treatise on international jurisprudence, the best references to achieve a general approach to the matter are those addressing its main aspects as comprehensively as possible. From the general study dealing with the international judgment, El Ouali 1984, to complete, wide-ranging works on judicial precedents such as Shahabuddeen 1996 or Guillaume 2011, as well as Siorat 1958 about lacunae and judicial function, all of these constitute basic references, as do Oellers-Frahm 2011, on law-making by advisory opinions, and Ortega Carcelén 1988, about the theories on the position of jurisprudence among the sources of international law. Nevertheless, the classical studies in this area are Lauterpacht 1958 and Schwarzenberger 1945.
El Ouali, Abdelhamid. Effets juridiques de la sentence internationale: contribution à l’etude de l’exécution des normes internationales. Paris: Librairie générale de droit et de jurisprudence, 1984.
On the assumption that jurisprudence is integrated by a plurality of jurisdictional acts, this professor of the University of Casablanca analyzes the juridical nature and effectiveness of international judicial decisions as individual acts.
Guillaume, Gilbert. “The Use of Precedent by International Judges and Arbitrators.” Journal of International Dispute Settlement 2.1 (2011): 5–23.
The French member of the Institut de droit international, and former president of the International Court of Justice, makes a complete overview of the use of precedents both in international judicial and arbitral tribunals. Available online for purchase or by subscription.
Lauterpacht, Hersch. The Development of International Law by the International Court. London: Stevens, 1958.
This classic book of worldwide popularity is the second edition of the 1934 work The Development of International Law by the Permanent Court of International Justice. While the work has five parts, Part Three, titled “Judicial Legislation” and discussing the issue over more than seventy pages, is especially relevant for our purpose.
Oellers-Frahm, Karin. “Lawmaking through Advisory Opinions?” German Law Journal 12 (2011): 1033–1055.
This complete article offers, on one hand, a general overview of the different international tribunals, courts, and international institutions endowed with advisory competence and, on the other hand, explores their specific contributions to the international judicial law-making process.
Ortega Carcelén, Martín. “Análisis del valor de la jurisprudencia en el derecho internacional.” Revista Española de Derecho Internacional 40.2 (1988): 55–87.
One of the most complete, analytical works dealing with the principal theories and authors around the discussion about whether judicial decisions are a source of international law or not.
Schwarzenberger, Georg. International Law. Vol. 1, International Law as Applied by International Courts and Tribunals. London: Stevens, 1945.
The first part of this classical, three-volume work is dedicated by this relevant British jurist to giving a complete, systematic survey of international jurisprudence in its more than 600 pages, 25 of which are dedicated to useful tables of cases and treaties.
Shahabuddeen, Mohamed. Precedent in the World Court. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1996
This is an essential book from the eminent jurist from Guyana, a former judge of the International Court of Justice, the International Criminal Court, the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, and the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda as well as a member of the Permanent Court of Arbitration since 1998.
Siorat, Lucien. Le problème des lacunes en droit international: Contribution à l´étude des sources du droit et de la fonction judiciaire. Paris: Librairie générale de droit et de jurisprudence, 1958.
This book is a classical dealing with an ancient problem of international law, namely, the lacunae and the question of non liquet. The French author dedicates two of the three parts of the book to the competence and methods of international judges to rule on both questions through decisions.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login.
- African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights and the Af...
- Agreements, Bilateral and Regional Trade
- Agreements, Multilateral Environmental
- Applicable Law in Investment Agreements
- Arctic Region
- Armed Opposition Groups
- Aut Dedere Aut Judicare
- Bandung Conference, The
- Children's Rights
- Civil Service, International
- Civil-Military Relations
- Collective Security
- Command Responsibility
- Common Heritage of Mankind
- Complementarity Principle
- Conspiracy/Joint Criminal Enterprise
- Constitutional Law, International
- Consular Relations
- Contemporary Catholic Approaches
- Continental Shelf, Idea and Limits of the
- Cooperation in Criminal Matters, Cross-Border
- Courts, International
- Crimes against Humanity
- Criminal Law, International
- Cultural Rights
- Cyber Warfare
- Debt, Sovereign
- Decolonization in International Law
- Development Law, International
- Disputes, Peaceful Settlement of
- Drugs, International Regulation, and Criminal Liability
- Early 19th Century, 1789-1870
- Ecological Restoration and International Law
- Economic Law, International
- Effectiveness and Evolution in Treaty Interpretation
- Enforced Disappearances in International Law
- Enforcement of Human Rights
- Environmental Compliance Mechanisms
- Environmental Institutions, International
- Environmental Law, International
- European Arrest Warrant
- Extraterritorial Application of Human Rights Treaties
- Feminist Approaches to International Law
- Financial Law, International
- Foreign Investment
- Freedom of Expression
- French Revolution
- General Customary Law
- General Principles of Law
- Georgia and International Law
- Grotius, Hugo
- Habeas Corpus
- History of International Law, 1550–1700
- Hostilities, Direct Participation in
- Human Rights
- Human Rights and Regional Protection, Relativism and Unive...
- Human Rights, European Court of
- Human Rights, Foundations of
- Human Trafficking
- Hybrid International Criminal Tribunals
- Immunity, Sovereign
- Indigenous Peoples
- Institutional Law
- International and Non-International Armed Conflict, Detent...
- International Committee of the Red Cross
- International Court of Justice
- International Criminal Court, The
- International Criminal Law, Complicity in
- International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR)
- International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia ...
- International Humanitarian Law
- International Humanitarian Law, Targeting in
- International Investment Agreements, Fair and Equitable Tr...
- International Investment Arbitration
- International Investment Law, Expropriation in
- International Law, Aggression in
- International Law, Amnesty and
- International Law and Economic Development
- International Law, Anthropology and
- International Law, Big Data and
- International Law, Climate Change and
- International Law, Dispute Settlement in
- International Law, Espionage in
- International Law, Hegemony in
- International Law in Northeast Asia
- International Law, Marxist Approaches to
- International Law, Military Intervention in
- International Law, Monism and Dualism in
- International Law, Peacekeeping in
- International Law, Proportionality in
- International Law, Reasonableness in
- International Law, Recognition in
- International Law, Self-Determination in
- International Law, State Responsibility in
- International Law, State Succession in
- International Law, the State in
- International Law, the Turn to History in
- International Law, Trade and Development in
- International Law, Unequal Treaties in
- International Law, Use of Force in
- International Regulation of the Internet
- International Territorial Administration
- International Trade and Human Rights
- Intervention, Humanitarian
- Investment Protection Treaties
- Islamic International Law
- Islamic Law and Human Rights
- Jurisprudence (Judicial Law-Making)
- Jus Cogens
- Just War
- Law of the Sea
- Law of Treaties, The
- Law-Making by Non-State Actors
- League of Nations, The
- Lebanon, Special Tribunal for
- Legal Status of Military Forces Abroad
- Liability for International Environmental Harm
- Liberation and Resistance Movements
- Maritime Delimitation
- Martens Clause
- Medieval International Law
- Mens Rea, International Crimes
- Middle East Boundaries and State Formation
- Military Necessity
- Military Occupation
- Modes of Participation
- Most-Favored-Nation Clauses
- Multinational Corporations in International Law
- Nationality and Statelessness
- Natural Law
- New Approaches to International Law
- New Haven School of International Law, The
- Non liquet
- Nonstate Actors
- Nuclear Non-Proliferation
- Nuremberg Trials
- Organizations, International
- Pacifism in International Law
- Palestine (and the Israel Question)
- Peace Treaties
- Political Science, International Law and
- Private Military and Security Companies
- Protection, Diplomatic
- Public Interest, Human Rights, and Foreign Investment
- Rational Choice Theory
- Recognition of Foreign Penal Judgments
- Rendition, Extraterritorial Abduction, and Extraordinary R...
- Russian Approaches to International Law
- Sanctions, International
- Soft Law
- Space Law
- Spanish School of International Law (c. 16th and 17th Cent...
- Sports Law, International
- State of Necessity
- Superior Orders
- Teaching International Law
- Territorial Title
- Theory, Critical International Legal
- Tokyo Trials, The
- Transnational Corruption
- Treaty Interpretation
- Ukrainian Approaches
- Underwater Cultural Heritage
- Unilateral Acts
- United Nations and its Principal Organs, The
- Universal Jurisdiction
- Uti Possidetis Iuris
- Vatican and the Holy See
- Victims’ Rights, International Criminal Law, and Proceedin...
- Watercourses, International
- Western Sahara